Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
2/24/07
Candidate for Tiki Barber's replacement.....Willis McGahee?
I'm sorta surprised that the Bills are putting McGahee out there for a deal, considering they don't have anyone else.  

I suppose the Giants need a new back, but is Willis really the right guy to persue I wonder...
20 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

2/25/07
0
I agree. Willis seems like he is the franchise man.  Its shocking.

2/25/07
0
Who would the Giants Trade?

2/25/07
0
that would be awsome!!!

2/26/07
0

would be a great move for the Giants, and a questionable one for the Bills


2/26/07
0
kantwistaye wrote:

would be a great move for the Giants, and a questionable one for the Bills

Did you see their draft last year? "Questionable" is the Bills' middle name!

2/26/07
0
Pat wrote:
Did you see their draft last year? "Questionable" is the Bills' middle name!
thats tru...they didnt have a good draft for the most part, but they drafted both McGahee and Travis Henry...and they already got rid of Travis....i wouldn't be surprised if they lost McGahee too

2/26/07
0
chad_is_god wrote:
thats tru...they didnt have a good draft for the most part, but they drafted both McGahee and Travis Henry...and they already got rid of Travis....i wouldn't be surprised if they lost McGahee too
Even McGahee was a poor pick. They grabbed him in the first round, when he was projected for 2nd round at the earliest. Sure, he ended up being good, but they could have gotten him later, and their first round pick was out for an entire year. That's not the kind of production you want from a first rounder. And now they're getting rid of him. It doesn't make much sense at all, really.

2/26/07
0
Pat wrote:
Even McGahee was a poor pick. They grabbed him in the first round, when he was projected for 2nd round at the earliest. Sure, he ended up being good, but they could have gotten him later, and their first round pick was out for an entire year. That's not the kind of production you want from a first rounder. And now they're getting rid of him. It doesn't make much sense at all, really.
Pat, just be happy your Patriots share a division with the Bills...

2/26/07
0
MrNFL wrote:
Pat, just be happy your Patriots share a division with the Bills...
I thank God for that every day. It's one less team we have to worry about.

2/26/07
0
Pat wrote:
I thank God for that every day. It's one less team we have to worry about.
Be glad for the Dolphins too, lol.

The Colts have had the benefit the last few years of the Texans and Titans being bad, but they both may be on the way up...

2/26/07
0
Pat wrote:
Even McGahee was a poor pick. They grabbed him in the first round, when he was projected for 2nd round at the earliest. Sure, he ended up being good, but they could have gotten him later, and their first round pick was out for an entire year. That's not the kind of production you want from a first rounder. And now they're getting rid of him. It doesn't make much sense at all, really.
yea i agree that they picked him too early, but not every team has scouts like the Patriots there Pat lol

2/26/07
0
chad_is_god wrote:
yea i agree that they picked him too early, but not every team has scouts like the Patriots there Pat lol
And somehow, we still make terrible picks, like the Maroney pick, right?

2/26/07
0
Pat wrote:
And somehow, we still make terrible picks, like the Maroney pick, right?
that may have been the knockout punch lol

2/26/07
0
Pat wrote:
And somehow, we still make terrible picks, like the Maroney pick, right?
no...i just thought it was too early...if i had known that Dillion was even considering retiring after that year i wouldn't have gave them an F, but i didn't

2/26/07
0
chad_is_god wrote:
no...i just thought it was too early...if i had known that Dillion was even considering retiring after that year i wouldn't have gave them an F, but i didn't
I'm just glad I never had you for a teacher. You probably would have given Shakespeare an F in English because you thought he talked funny.

2/26/07
0
Pat wrote:
I'm just glad I never had you for a teacher. You probably would have given Shakespeare an F in English because you thought he talked funny.
to be fair I would have failed Shakespeare because I've never gotten wtf he was talking about

2/26/07
0
back then everyone talked like that tho

2/26/07
0
chad_is_god wrote:
back then everyone talked like that tho
i know it was just a joke... making fun of myself more than anyone else

2/26/07
0
Replacing a gem like Tiki won't be an easy task.   And i don't believe McGahee will be the solution to their loss.  The Chiefs were fortunate to have Larry Johnson when we lost Priest.  Tiki will be greatly missed, and fondly remembered.

2/27/07
0
slowcheetah wrote:
Replacing a gem like Tiki won't be an easy task.   And i don't believe McGahee will be the solution to their loss.  The Chiefs were fortunate to have Larry Johnson when we lost Priest.  Tiki will be greatly missed, and fondly remembered.

I'm a bills/giants fan, i watch McGahee a lot and i can tell he would be really good with an O-line!...the Giants are working on that and the bills are not, so i don't see how he can't fill the shoes of tiki...he won't ever be as good as Tiki was, but pretty close i think


 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


SHOP
NFL GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
NFL TICKETS
Loading...
MEET OUR FANS
Kimberly
Doreen
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
 more
New York v. LA
Utah v. Houston
Detroit v. Chicago
Seattle v. Portland
PREDICT THE SCORE
 more
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
TAKE A QUIZ
 more
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help