Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
1/6/09
37% Of Americans Would Leave Out Undefeated Utah In A 4-Game College Football Playoff
After One Of The Craziest College Football Seasons In Recent Memory, America Still Just Doesn't Get It.



The above map isn't just a random map of the United States. Nor is it an attempt to blind the viewer. It's an amazing piece of proof that despite one of the most confusing and inconclusive college football seasons in recent memory, people have still learned nothing.

The above map depicts the results from a recent poll on ESPN's website, asking sports fans who they would leave out of a theoretical 4-team playoff, if they were to choose right now. The choices were Oklahoma, Florida, Texas, USC and Utah.

As you can probably guess, the purple signifies the states whose consensus indicated that they would bypass Utah. The yellow states left out USC, the green states left out Texas, and none of the states had Oklahoma or Florida as the team that they would most likely leave out of such a tournament. 37% chose to eliminate Utah, which was significantly more than anyone else. 26% chose Texas, 22% chose USC, 10% said Oklahoma, and the remaining 5% picked Florida.

While I've already made my case for Utah, as well as a case against Texas, it's shocking to me that people would be so unified in their disrespect for Utah. They are the only undefeated team in the country, and while they certainly had some wins over bad teams, the same can most certainly be said for USC (Washington, Washington State, Stanford, Arizona State, UCLA, Virginia), Florida (Tennessee, Citadel, Kentucky, Arkansas), Oklahoma (Baylor, Washington, Chattanooga, Texas A&M) and Texas (Florida Atlantic, UTEP, Arkansas, Baylor, Texas A&M). Some say that the bad teams of the SEC or the Big 12 could destroy the bad teams in the Mountain West. This might be true, but the bottom line is, they are still teams that a championship contender should be able to beat. Does anyone think that Utah would lose to Tennessee? Arizona State? Baylor? Of course not. So should it be held against them that they didn't play them, and instead played (and beat) the likes of Wyoming and San Diego State? I think not.

Normally, when there is outrage about the BCS, it's not necessarily because people are disappointed with who GETS a chance to play for the National Championship. The outrage is in the fact that other teams, who have done everything possible to prove that they deserve a chance, are left without an opportunity to prove their worth.

This year, Utah is the epitome of that. Of all the teams in the country, Utah is the one team who can stand proudly and say that, without a doubt, they have done everything within their power to position themselves for a championship run.

Yet somehow, despite the fact that they don't have an ugly loss to a supposedly weaker conference opponent on their schedule, and they also have 4 wins against top 25 teams, Utah is the team that would most likely be snubbed, if America were allowed to choose a team to eliminate from a hypothetical 4 game playoff.

Why Utah? Beats me. While Florida and USC have made very convincing cases (in my opinion), Utah has also done so. Oklahoma and Texas are also great teams, but each of them has one fatal flaw that would lead any truly objective team to concede that one of them would have to go, in this hypothetical situation.

Oklahoma - Yes, they're the #1 team in the country right now. But they are also the only team in the discussion who already has a loss to another one of the teams in question.

Texas - Unlike all 4 of the other teams, they didn't win their conference. Sure, it was largely based on a technicality, but they simply didn't have the credentials that it took to win it.

Utah has met all of the criteria. Except, of course, their conference. Despite Utah's accomplishments, they continue to pay for the ineptitude of the teams associated with them. Forget that they completely dominated an Alabama team that finished the regular season undefeated and hung in their with Florida in the SEC Championship game. Forget that they also beat ranked opponents TCU, BYU and Oregon State (who beat USC, by the way). That all gets thrown out the window, because Utah had the audacity to be in the same conference as San Diego State.

This is why America deserves the BCS. In the face of all the whining and the cries for a playoff, the country still agrees with the BCS in the end. So why the moaning? Why the complaining? Is it truly because people think the system is unfair? Or is it because it didn't produce the result that people want to see? Do people really want a true champion? Or do they just want to choose their own results? Clearly it's not fairness that they want, nor is it a true champion. It's just more of the same... and that's what they will continue to get.
28 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

1/6/09
7
Some say that the bad teams of the SEC or the Big 12 could destroy the bad teams in the Mountain West.
So what would happen if a team like Wyoming who tied for last in the Mountain West were to play one of the bottom teams from the SEC, like say, I don't know, Tennessee?

1/6/09
1
The answer: anti-Mormonism. Of course, I'd be willing to bet that half of the black population of Utah is either on the football or basketball teams, and they are not very likely to be Mormons. Go figure.

1/6/09
4
Well, America is stupid, but then I've always known that.

1/6/09
0
(Edited by Pat)
All I can muster is, "BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!"

1/6/09
3
How bout this?  Harris Poll voters admit to never seeing Utah play before the Alabama game.  These guys decide who play in the national championship.  What a joke.

1/6/09
0
kantwistaye wrote:
How bout this?  Harris Poll voters admit to never seeing Utah play before the Alabama game.  These guys decide who play in the national championship.  What a joke.
How embarrassing.

1/6/09
0
Ok, do you see where we went wrong with this Pat? It was somewhere around "on the ESPN website". Enough said.

1/6/09
7
Some say that the bad teams of the SEC or the Big 12 could destroy the bad teams in the Mountain West.
So what would happen if a team like Wyoming who tied for last in the Mountain West were to play one of the bottom teams from the SEC, like say, I don't know, Tennessee?

1/6/09
2

While I agree with Utah's claim to a shot at the championship, there have been many undefeated teams in history who did not get a chance to prove themselves.

Just in the past 15 years, there have been 7 undefeated teams who didn't get their chance.
1993 Auburn University 11-0-0
1994 Penn State 12-0-0
1998 Tulane 12-0
1999 Marshall 13-0
2004 Auburn 13-0
2004 Utah 12-0
2006 Boise State 13-0

And, in 2 of those years, they were the ONLY undefeated team.
1993 Auburn University 11-0-0
2006 Boise State 13-0

Where was the outcry for those teams?
People just didn't believe that they could beat the teams who did get the chance.
Same thing this year with Utah.
We need a playoff !!!


1/6/09
1
That last paragraph is very interesting.  It's funny how people will diss the BCS and yet they watch each worthless bowl game.

Until more people take a stand by simply not watching these fraudulent games, nothing will change, because the AD's and Bowl people are raking in your cash, and the controversy is just more publicity.

1/6/09
3
Seth wrote:
Some say that the bad teams of the SEC or the Big 12 could destroy the bad teams in the Mountain West.
So what would happen if a team like Wyoming who tied for last in the Mountain West were to play one of the bottom teams from the SEC, like say, I don't know, Tennessee?
I imagine it would be a close, slightly sloppy but somewhat defensive game, with Wyoming coming out on top... say, 13-7 or so.

1/6/09
1
Pat wrote:
I imagine it would be a close, slightly sloppy but somewhat defensive game, with Wyoming coming out on top... say, 13-7 or so.
Sir, THAT was your finest hour. That last paragraph was beautiful. Here at FANIQ we are changing perceptions and giving people the truth. WE should be in every home in America and not the four letter network!

1/6/09
0
The BCS system is dead.  In a year or two we'll have an 8 team playoff spread over 3 successive Saturdays.

1/6/09
0
Shankopotamus wrote:
The BCS system is dead.  In a year or two we'll have an 8 team playoff spread over 3 successive Saturdays.
Unfortunately, that's impossible, due to the current TV contracts.

1/6/09
0
No, the 8 team playoff contract will be written in the next year or two, they just won't be able to start holding the playoff until the current contracts expire.


1/6/09
0
What was your case against Texas

1/6/09
0
aos035 wrote:
What was your case against Texas
Click here. But I'm pretty sure you already saw it.

1/6/09
0
ya I did but i find it funny you would put USC ahead of texas

1/6/09
0
aos035 wrote:
ya I did but i find it funny you would put USC ahead of texas
USC 35, OSU 3
Texas 24, OSU 21

1/6/09
2
Do any of you really believe that poll? ESPN makes up that poll..why?..because they are in it up to their eyeballs in the BCS mess...the spin is worse than the Presidential Election, just a different kind of political lobbyists.

1/7/09
1
aos035 wrote:
ya I did but i find it funny you would put USC ahead of texas
Utah deserves to be in front of them BOTH


1/7/09
0
Pat wrote:
USC 35, OSU 3
Texas 24, OSU 21
Um... one game. Oregon State beat USC by 6 we barely lost by six at night in TEch.

1/7/09
0
Im sorry, we tend to win games, not worry about score.

1/7/09
1
aos035 wrote:
Im sorry, we tend to win games, not worry about score.
Except when you lose to Texas Tech. Then, the winning thing doesn't really work out.

And it's funny that you say you don't worry about the score, because that's one of the biggest arguments you hear from Texas fans when they whine about not making the NC game.

1/7/09
1
Pat wrote:
I imagine it would be a close, slightly sloppy but somewhat defensive game, with Wyoming coming out on top... say, 13-7 or so.
Um...no!

UT would kill Wyoming...

1/7/09
0

When the BCS ends their current contract with the TV stations...we will see a playoff...there are just to many "could haves and should haves" not to. I myself am a fan off a 16 team playoff, but it will probaly just be an 8 team.


1/7/09
1
codycarlisle wrote:
Um...no!

UT would kill Wyoming...
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOooooooooooooooooooooopppsss! easy killer, Wyoming DID beat Tennessee this season

 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
NCAAF GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
MEET OUR FANS
Doreen
Caty
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Seattle v. Portland
Detroit v. Chicago
New York v. LA
Utah v. Houston
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
dino_mills joined the NFL league J-E-T-S Jets Jets Jets Fans.
Just now!
dino_mills joined the NFL league NFL Fantasy Football.
Just now!
dino_mills joined the NFL league NFL Draft League.
Just now!
areed80567 joined the Figure Skating league Fans of Ladies'.
Just now!
areed80567 joined the Figure Skating league Fans of Kristi Yamaguchi.
Just now!
Just now!
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help