Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
3/19/08
An Olympic Boycott Gains Momentum, While The US Forgets Its Past Stance On China And The Games
As you may know, the recent violence in Tibet is causing some countries to seriously think about boycotting the Beijing Olympics. Tibetans are saying that as many as 80 people have been killed so far in clashes, while China - of course - says no one has died.

In Europe, it's getting close to a boiling point. The German center-left paper Süddeutsche Zeitung even went so far as to call it a mistake to allow China to host the Games.
"It was a mistake to let China host the Olympic Games. The recent deaths following the military crackdown in Tibet allow no other conclusion. Who can enjoy the Olympics while monks are hunted in Lhasa?"
The IOC has also been vocal, but in the opposite direction. They've said that a boycott of the Games would only hurt athletes who have spent their lives preparing to compete in the Olympics.

While no countries seem to be considering a full-on boycott, right now there's a suggestion gaining momentum in Europe for a mini-boycott of the Beijing Olympics by VIPs at the opening ceremony, as a way of embarrassing China.

France's outspoken foreign minister, former humanitarian campaigner Bernard Kouchner, said the idea "is interesting."


Kouchner said he wants to discuss it with other foreign ministers from the 27-nation European Union next week. His comments opened a crack in what until now had been solid opposition to a full boycott, a stance that Kouchner said remains the official government position.


As I'm sure you probably know as well, the United States hasn't even tried to push any buttons. Three days before the protests and violence erupted in Tibet, the US dropped China from its list of the world’s worst human rights violators, despite a State Department assessment that overall China's human rights record remained poor.


President Bush has also avoided talking directly about the issue as well. Back in February he made it clear that he'd be attending the Olympics as only a sports fan.

I'm going to the Olympics. I view the Olympics as a sporting event.[...] There's a lot of issues that I suspect people are gonna, you know, opine, about during the Olympics. I mean, you got the Dali Lama crowd. You've got global warming folks. You've got, you know, Darfur and... I am not gonna you know, go and use the Olympics as an opportunity to express my opinions to the Chinese people in a public way 'cause I do it all the time with the president.

 

The interesting thing though is that the US seems to have forgotten its past history in regards to the letting the Olympics take place in China.

 

In 1993, the US House of Representatives urged the International Olympic Committee to reject Beijing's bid for the 2000 Summer Games because of China's "massive violations of human rights."


In a resolution passed, 287-99, the House strongly opposed allowing Beijing to be host to the Games and asked the I.O.C. "to find another, more suitable venue."

It urged the United States representative to the I.O.C. to vote against Beijing when the international committee's 94 members meet in Monte Carlo in September to select the host city for the 2000 Games.


Obviously times have changed, and with China on the verge of becoming a true world superpower, obviously some concessions have needed to be made.


But the recent protests and violence in Tibet provide a grim reminder for why we didn't want China to get the 2000 Games, and how not a lot has changed since.


I'm not calling for a boycott at all. I believe athletes should still have the right to compete. But I'd be disappointed if US officials and leaders remain silent on this issue as the Olympics approach. Remaining silent certainly isn't going to change anything.

2 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

3/19/08
5
I'm all for a boycott, and am personally doing so. I refuse to watch the games at all this year. It would be nice if some countries boycott or at least say something. I still can't believe the IOC selected Beijing to begin with. I'm not really big on political activism, but the situation is Tibet is just not right. And most of the powerful countries simply turned a blind eye to it, because there isn't much to be gained economically by confronting China on it.

The Tibetan struggle for independence has been going on for over 50 years, and for the most part, it has been a non-violent movement on the part of the Tibetan people. But almost everyone has a breaking point, and it looks like some have reached theirs. It's a shame that it's come to this, especially because of how the Chinese are now reacting to everything: accusing the Dalai Lama of instigating the violence, blocking out YouTube and all foreign reporters so that the Chinese people will only have access to the "official" reports. Foreign reporters who are in Lhasa are on lockdown in the hotels, and no one else is allowed into the area. The IOC is "disappointed" with China's reaction by blocking off freedom of the press, but are they really going to do anything about it? Probably not.

Like I said, it's a shame that some Tibetans felt it necessary to get violent. It's not the way to go about it. But on the same token, the Chinese, particularly during their initial invasion and occupation of Tibet, killed and tortured thousands of Tibetan monks and nuns in addition to destroying monasteries and their libraries. They have had the Panchen Lama in custody since he was a small boy in order to control the Tibetan people (the Panchen Lama is the one who helps determine who the next Dalai Lama is... you can imagine how the Chinese could use this to manipulate things). No one is really sure where he is....

I suppose the one good thing that might come out of having the Olympics in China is that it is bringing focus back to the situation in Tibet, making it difficult for the world to continue to ignore it. I just hope some leader/country has the decency to do something positive about it.

3/19/08
5
I'm all for a boycott, and am personally doing so. I refuse to watch the games at all this year. It would be nice if some countries boycott or at least say something. I still can't believe the IOC selected Beijing to begin with. I'm not really big on political activism, but the situation is Tibet is just not right. And most of the powerful countries simply turned a blind eye to it, because there isn't much to be gained economically by confronting China on it.

The Tibetan struggle for independence has been going on for over 50 years, and for the most part, it has been a non-violent movement on the part of the Tibetan people. But almost everyone has a breaking point, and it looks like some have reached theirs. It's a shame that it's come to this, especially because of how the Chinese are now reacting to everything: accusing the Dalai Lama of instigating the violence, blocking out YouTube and all foreign reporters so that the Chinese people will only have access to the "official" reports. Foreign reporters who are in Lhasa are on lockdown in the hotels, and no one else is allowed into the area. The IOC is "disappointed" with China's reaction by blocking off freedom of the press, but are they really going to do anything about it? Probably not.

Like I said, it's a shame that some Tibetans felt it necessary to get violent. It's not the way to go about it. But on the same token, the Chinese, particularly during their initial invasion and occupation of Tibet, killed and tortured thousands of Tibetan monks and nuns in addition to destroying monasteries and their libraries. They have had the Panchen Lama in custody since he was a small boy in order to control the Tibetan people (the Panchen Lama is the one who helps determine who the next Dalai Lama is... you can imagine how the Chinese could use this to manipulate things). No one is really sure where he is....

I suppose the one good thing that might come out of having the Olympics in China is that it is bringing focus back to the situation in Tibet, making it difficult for the world to continue to ignore it. I just hope some leader/country has the decency to do something positive about it.

3/19/08
2
JewelOfSong wrote:
I'm all for a boycott, and am personally doing so. I refuse to watch the games at all this year. It would be nice if some countries boycott or at least say something. I still can't believe the IOC selected Beijing to begin with. I'm not really big on political activism, but the situation is Tibet is just not right. And most of the powerful countries simply turned a blind eye to it, because there isn't much to be gained economically by confronting China on it.

The Tibetan struggle for independence has been going on for over 50 years, and for the most part, it has been a non-violent movement on the part of the Tibetan people. But almost everyone has a breaking point, and it looks like some have reached theirs. It's a shame that it's come to this, especially because of how the Chinese are now reacting to everything: accusing the Dalai Lama of instigating the violence, blocking out YouTube and all foreign reporters so that the Chinese people will only have access to the "official" reports. Foreign reporters who are in Lhasa are on lockdown in the hotels, and no one else is allowed into the area. The IOC is "disappointed" with China's reaction by blocking off freedom of the press, but are they really going to do anything about it? Probably not.

Like I said, it's a shame that some Tibetans felt it necessary to get violent. It's not the way to go about it. But on the same token, the Chinese, particularly during their initial invasion and occupation of Tibet, killed and tortured thousands of Tibetan monks and nuns in addition to destroying monasteries and their libraries. They have had the Panchen Lama in custody since he was a small boy in order to control the Tibetan people (the Panchen Lama is the one who helps determine who the next Dalai Lama is... you can imagine how the Chinese could use this to manipulate things). No one is really sure where he is....

I suppose the one good thing that might come out of having the Olympics in China is that it is bringing focus back to the situation in Tibet, making it difficult for the world to continue to ignore it. I just hope some leader/country has the decency to do something positive about it.
I like the idea of the mini-boycott. It gets the point across while still letting the athletes compete. Most athletes only get one shot at the Olympics, so it's not fair to them to take that chance away. Certainly though, if individuals want to boycott, that is great and that is their own choice.

It should be interesting to see what happens. I am sure that some protesters will try and do something, and the Chinese government will be under pressure to not treat them like they normally would while the world is watching.

Oh, and in addition to everything you mentioned regarding Tibet, China has also essentially supported the genocide in Sudan.

 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
OLYMPICS GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
MEET OUR FANS
Kimberly
Jodhvir
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Utah v. Houston
New York v. LA
Detroit v. Chicago
Seattle v. Portland
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
Just now!
dilipkumar409 joined the MMA league Fans of Aaron Riley.
Just now!
dilipkumar409 joined the MMA league Fans of UFC.
Just now!
woody050681 answered the poll Have a Nice Day!.
Just now!
senoj33 joined the HS Basketball league Fans of Florida HS Basketball.
Just now!
senoj33 joined the HS Basketball league HS Basketball Fans.
Just now!
sreedee19 joined the Formula One league Fans of Kazuki Nakajima.
Just now!
sreedee19 joined the Formula One league Formula One Fans.
Just now!
yogeshsona joined the Cricket league Fans of Indian Premier League.
Just now!
yogeshsona joined the Cricket league Fans of Mumbai Indians.
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help