Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
11/12/08
Barack Obama Has No Control Over The BCS. Unfortunately That Means No College Football Playoffs For Now
Step 1: Declare War On The BCS. Step 2: Playoffs... Simple Enough, Right?
During his interview with Chris Berman on Monday Night Football, Barack Obama was very clear. If he could change one thing in sports, he would institute a playoff system in college football. It's safe to say that millions of fans across the country agreed with that sentiment.

Unfortunately for everyone, the NCAA doesn't fall under the command of the President. In a response to Obama's suggestion, the chairman of the BCS Presidential Oversight Committee basically said thanks, but no thanks. Oregon president David Frohnmayer sent an email saying the following:

"We deeply respect the president-elect and we are glad that he is a fan of college football. We have the most compelling regular season in all of sports, and I'm sure that contributes to Senator Obama's enjoyment of our great game. My colleagues and I on the BCS Presidential Oversight Committee have discussed the future of postseason football on many occasions and we do not believe a playoff would be in the best interest of the sport, the student-athletes or our many other constituencies."

Ah, yes. The typical "we don't need a playoff because our regular season is essentially a playoff" argument, followed by the good old "we've talked about it, but it's just not right for the kids". The BCS folks are offering up the same old washed up excuses, instead of being honest and telling people that they are raking in money hand over fist, and they don't want to risk upsetting that by instituting a playoff, and rendering the rest of the Bowl games useless.

It's unfortunate that President-elect Obama won't be able to force the NCAA to give the fans what they want, and to do what makes sense. No matter what political policies he puts into place, a college football playoff would be a change that we could ALL believe in.


The BCS Committee Respectfully Disagrees With President-Elect Obama [Examiner]
21 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

11/12/08
7
MrNFL wrote:
But seriously, I wish these moron AD's and BCS people weren't such money grubbing douches.
Is it just me, or doesn't it seem like if they did a good playoff system, there would be a ton of money involved?

Imagine college bowl season the way it is now, but then add basically a Super Bowl at the end. That's essentially what it would be.

11/12/08
3
Step 1: Declare War On The BCS. Step 2: Playoffs...

Step 3, PROFIT!

11/12/08
0
But seriously, I wish these moron AD's and BCS people weren't such money grubbing douches.

11/12/08
7
MrNFL wrote:
But seriously, I wish these moron AD's and BCS people weren't such money grubbing douches.
Is it just me, or doesn't it seem like if they did a good playoff system, there would be a ton of money involved?

Imagine college bowl season the way it is now, but then add basically a Super Bowl at the end. That's essentially what it would be.

11/12/08
1
MrNFL wrote:
Step 1: Declare War On The BCS. Step 2: Playoffs...

Step 3, PROFIT!
You beat me to it.

11/12/08
1
Pat wrote:
Is it just me, or doesn't it seem like if they did a good playoff system, there would be a ton of money involved?

Imagine college bowl season the way it is now, but then add basically a Super Bowl at the end. That's essentially what it would be.
Actually, the problem I've always heard is not the big schools. They'd be for a playoff. It's the 80 schools that play in the crap bowls that don't want a playoff, because they wouldn't get any of that juicy Emerald Nuts.com Bowl money.

11/12/08
0
Pat wrote:
Is it just me, or doesn't it seem like if they did a good playoff system, there would be a ton of money involved?

Imagine college bowl season the way it is now, but then add basically a Super Bowl at the end. That's essentially what it would be.
They absolutely could make MORE with a playoff.  I hate the idiots like those who run the Rose Bowl.  Ugh.

11/12/08
2
100%InjuryRate wrote:
Actually, the problem I've always heard is not the big schools. They'd be for a playoff. It's the 80 schools that play in the crap bowls that don't want a playoff, because they wouldn't get any of that juicy Emerald Nuts.com Bowl money.
Keep the extra useless bowl games for everyone else, there's no reason to get rid of them, just put the conference champions in the playoff.

11/12/08
0
The only reason why this season is like a playoff is because there are two conferences that are so much better than everyone else.  In other season does the regular season come anywhere close to a playoff.  It just plays out like a regular season, which is what it should do.

11/12/08
2
kantwistaye wrote:
The only reason why this season is like a playoff is because there are two conferences that are so much better than everyone else.  In other season does the regular season come anywhere close to a playoff.  It just plays out like a regular season, which is what it should do.
If USC had taken care of business against Oregon State, and Penn State hadn't choked against Iowa, things would be so f'd up right now...

11/12/08
0
Pat wrote:
If USC had taken care of business against Oregon State, and Penn State hadn't choked against Iowa, things would be so f'd up right now...
They could still be a little f'd up.  If Oklahoma beats Tech this week and both win their last game, as well as Texas winning their last 2 games, the highest ranking BCS team will play in the Big 12 Title Game.  Basically, the 2nd last BCS Standings are going to be just as important as the last BCS Standings.  So we'll get twice the controversy this year!!!

But yeah... it'd be ugly if those two games turned out differently. 

11/12/08
0
Well you guys seem to have covered the options with flair... however, the point to me is.. I DON"T want the President or any other governmental *agency* like that to have the power to tell NCAA or any other private organization how to run their organization.. Doesn't this reek a lil of dictatorship?  I think the *government* has plenty of things to do w/out adding another CONTROL to be followed!  How much government control do ya want... or is it one of those.. fix this *one thing* and stay outta everything else?  Unfortunately, it seems if the foot gets in the door, it stays there!  :)   Just a few thoughts to consider.. as in be careful what ya wish for...*lol*

11/13/08
0
The ONLY reason that the NCAA won't go to a playoff system is MONEY MONEY MONEY!
If we were ever lucky enough to get a playoff system I don't think it should be conference champions though, it should still be based on the rankings. Top (insert #) teams make it in.  Everyone else gets to play in the Sun City Bowl (etc).
Yea that could really screw a conference or two, ACC/Big East.  But would anyone really want to see this years ACC champ playing TT in round 1?

11/13/08
0
I'm not a big fan either.  But the guy was just answering the question asked of him.  Relax a bit.

11/13/08
0
I like the current system better. College football has one thing on the NFL and that is that every game matters. The NFL you can lock up a playoff berth and then just take it easy and let teams duke it out to play you, but in NCAAF and HSF alike you NEED to win every game that you can. I like hardnose football, and I hate seeing guys not playing to their potential and only doing enough to get by!

11/13/08
1
Dalarin wrote:
I like the current system better. College football has one thing on the NFL and that is that every game matters. The NFL you can lock up a playoff berth and then just take it easy and let teams duke it out to play you, but in NCAAF and HSF alike you NEED to win every game that you can. I like hardnose football, and I hate seeing guys not playing to their potential and only doing enough to get by!
Every game matters, sure.  Except for the 100 teams THAT NEVER HAVE A CHANCE AT THE CHAMPIONSHIP REGARDLESS OF HOW THEY DO.  That a joke/

11/13/08
0
It all goes back to the NCAA being declared exempt from the anti-monopoly\cartel rules. They control themselves, end of story.

11/13/08
0
MrNFL wrote:
Every game matters, sure.  Except for the 100 teams THAT NEVER HAVE A CHANCE AT THE CHAMPIONSHIP REGARDLESS OF HOW THEY DO.  That a joke/
Well it's a matter of conference. You do good in your conference but you get embarrassed when you play another. Do you remember the Hawaii vs. Georgia game last year? Its like comparing a 2A high school to a 5A high school. The system they currently use take in mind your opponents strength. You can beat BYU by 30 points but turn around and lose to Alabama by 30. If you do great in any division you still get a bowl game most of time.

11/13/08
1
Dalarin wrote:
Well it's a matter of conference. You do good in your conference but you get embarrassed when you play another. Do you remember the Hawaii vs. Georgia game last year? Its like comparing a 2A high school to a 5A high school. The system they currently use take in mind your opponents strength. You can beat BYU by 30 points but turn around and lose to Alabama by 30. If you do great in any division you still get a bowl game most of time.
Which is EXACTLY why we need a playoff.  Because the top teams from each conference NEVER face each other.  How bout we let the top SEC team, and Big 12 team, and Big 10 team, and so forth, have to PROVE they are the best by beating the BEST of other conferences instead of just winning their own?

That's the point of the post-season in sports, to determine a true champion.  College football's system is a sham.

11/14/08
0
How about extending the season and the winner of the big bowl games go into a playoff of sorts.

 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
NCAAF GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
MEET OUR FANS
Myka
Jodhvir
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Detroit v. Chicago
New York v. LA
Seattle v. Portland
Utah v. Houston
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
divssevenstars joined the Tennis league Fans of Agassi, Andre.
Just now!
divssevenstars joined the Tennis league Tennis Fans.
Just now!
ejimsclaudio joined the Soccer league Spanish Primera Liga Fans.
Just now!
ejimsclaudio joined the Soccer league Barcelona Fans.
Just now!
teresann09 joined the MLB league Angel Fans.
Just now!
teresann09 joined the MLB league Fantasy Baseball Fanatics!!.
Just now!
teresann09 joined the NCAAF league Loyola MarymountFans(FB).
Just now!
teresann09 joined the NFL league Bears Den.
Just now!
teresann09 joined the NFL league NFL Fantasy Football.
Just now!
teresann09 joined the NFL league NFL Draft League.
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help