Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
10/2/07
Colorado Rockies Come From 2 Down in 13th, Win 14 of 15 Games to Capture National League Wild Card


The Rockies aren't interested in easy endeavors. Once 9-games below .500, Colorado won 14 of their final 15 games to capture the National League Wild Card. Naturally, they had to extend the extended regular season into extra innings, coming back from two runs down in the 13th.

I would not want to play the Rockies right now. Fearless, unflappable, and every other adjective that describes teams that have won more games than they've lost in October.

A tremendous game left me confident in two thoughts:

1. MLB needs to have Instant Replay in some form
Maintaining the traditions of the game... blah, blah, blah... when technology can help you determine whether a ball was a home run or not, why would you opt out? I'm fine with not allowing replay for close plays at 1st, 2nd or 3rd, and even home plate because an umpire is right on the play. But when asking an ump, who's more than likely out of shape, to run down the foul line and make a judgment call from 40-feet away I see a void that can easily be aided by video replay.

Due to the final play of the game, where it seems clear Matt Holliday didn't touch the plate, wouldn't replay be beneficial? Tim Kurkjian made a good point on Baseball Tonight that might have changed my mind on this as it does interpret the flow of the game and celebration. That said, don't you want to get the calls absolutely correct in contests of this magnitude? I'd like to see replay on HR calls as a starting points.

2. Matt Holliday is the NL MVP
Prince Fielder had a tremendous season, but Holliday not only contributed greatly to the Rockies win tonight, but he ignited the 14 wins in 15 games run. Most Valuable Players will their team to victories. He has done so. Case closed.

What an unbelievable finish to the MLB regular season. Wednesday night can't come soon enough.
7 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

10/2/07
0

Agree on your first point.  At the Brewer game yesterday, Braun hit a homer to straight center that went off the center field ivy (behind the wall) and then bounced off the yellow padding, and afterward bounced into the field.  It was obviously a home run but Braun only got a double from it.  Replay would be great for a play like especially since it would only take one view to confirm it.


10/2/07
0
I'd rather have the flow of the game interrupted and a celebration delayed to get a call right. This wasn't a questionable call of a ball or strike, this was a blatantly wrong call that cost a team a shot at the playoffs.

I'm just surprised that Michael Barrett didn't end up punching Tim McClelland.

10/2/07
0
Which is it that you want?  First you say no replay on close calls at the plate because an ump is right there, then you say you'd want replay on the call at the plate.  It's one or the other.

10/2/07
0

They definetly need replay on close plays at the wall, and at certain bases.  Give each manager limited challenges...it's better for the game.


10/2/07
0
I'm all for starting slow. Bring in replay for home runs calls. Give it a season for everyone to adjust and get over used to it. Then maybe add a managers's challenge kind of system where they can have calls reviewed a couple times a game. Plays at a base, out or safe kind of thing. I don't want replay on balls and strikes.

10/2/07
0
DenverGregg wrote:
Which is it that you want?  First you say no replay on close calls at the plate because an ump is right there, then you say you'd want replay on the call at the plate.  It's one or the other.
actually, I said I want replay on HR calls as a starting point ... and would be ok with replays at the plate, but can understand the logic to prevent that from happening.

10/2/07
0
Seth wrote:
I'm all for starting slow. Bring in replay for home runs calls. Give it a season for everyone to adjust and get over used to it. Then maybe add a managers's challenge kind of system where they can have calls reviewed a couple times a game. Plays at a base, out or safe kind of thing. I don't want replay on balls and strikes.

Ball and strike call replays would be a disaster.  Home run and the odd foul ball at the pole could be a starting point. 

 

I'm not sure about safe/out calls.  A cantakerous manager might challenge every play as a way of getting back at an ump over some other call he didn't like.  I think if there were to be challenges on safe/out calls, it would have to be a challenge generated by the replay official rather than by a manager.


 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
MLB GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
MLB TICKETS
Loading...
MEET OUR FANS
Caty
Myka
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Detroit v. Chicago
Seattle v. Portland
New York v. LA
Utah v. Houston
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
shelbieguillen joined the Olympics league Fans of Summer Olympics.
Just now!
shelbieguillen joined the Olympics league Fans of Gymnastics.
Just now!
shelbieguillen joined the Olympics league OlympicsFans.
Just now!
bigpn2000 joined the NFL league VikingsFans.
Just now!
bigpn2000 joined the NFL league NFL Fantasy Football.
Just now!
bigpn2000 joined the NFL league NFL Draft League.
Just now!
tatoo_girl_81 joined the NFL league Hail to the Redskins.
Just now!
tatoo_girl_81 joined the NFL league NFL Fantasy Football.
Just now!
tatoo_girl_81 joined the NFL league NFL Draft League.
Just now!
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help