Complete Motorsports Safety: The Impossible Standard
Other Racing

Sometimes, Death Just Isn't Preventable

6/23/08 in Other Racing   |   Eric_   |   7716 respect

The death of Scott Kalitta was both tragic and pointed out the obvious: Auto racing is dangerous. As the years have passed and safety standards have improved, serious injuries and deaths have thankfully declined. Unfortunately, now and then catastrophe strikes. This decade, it happened in NASCAR with Dale Earnhardt. it happened in IndyCar with Tony Renna and Paul Dana, and now it's happened in drag racing with Scott Kalitta and Eric Medlen last year.

The one silver lining is when there is a big accident, there is usually something that can be learned that hopefully will prevent something similar from happening again. In Kalitta's case, it appeared the run off area at the track was sub-standard. Plus, it seems to me that having a retaining wall at a dragstrip for any reason other than crowd control is a bad idea.

Over the years, safety measures have evolved. Recently, the changes have been more sophisticated and advanced that ever. We now have the HANS device, the SAFER barrier, the Car of Tomorrow, and more stringent track standards than ever before. We saw how far we've come over the past year when Michael McDowell and Dario Franchitti walked away from incredible accidents.

Unfortunately, it's just not possible to make racing 100% safe. The risk of serious injury or worse will always be there, no matter how safe they make the cars and the tracks. It's the risk every driver at every level takes.

Was Scott Kalitta's death preventable? I don't know. What I do know is he wasn't the first and unfortunately he won't be the last.
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine. Preview

6/24/08   |   100%InjuryRate   |   1283 respect

wrote:
They should go careening into civilians instead?  If the parachute doesn't deploy for some reason, there isn't much hope for them anyway, so damage control becomes the name of the game.

How about a corn field at the end? Or a sand pit? Or anything but a concrete wall.

And I don't understand your argument at all. It's not like there's a law requiring civilians to be at the end of a drag race runway. It should be left open.

6/23/08   |   100%InjuryRate   |   1283 respect

I'm still stunned they had a cement wall at the end of the track. What in God's name was that doing there? Just terrible.