Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
2/19/09
Detroit Lions Should Not Draft Matt Stafford Or Mark Sanchez
Who Should Detroit Select #1 Overall?
The NFL Draft is quickly approaching, and a lot of us are wondering… who will end up in Detroit?

Most of the “experts” are predicting Detroit will take either Matthew Stafford from Georgia or Mark Sanchez from Southern Cal. You will hear the saying, “you can’t pass on a franchise quarterback” but at the same time you can’t miss on a quarterback or your franchise will be set back for years. Both of these quarterbacks have questions, so would it be that hard to pass?

Matthew Stafford is a gunslinger. No question that Stafford has a rocket arm, but often times he will trust it too much. Stafford doesn’t have great ability to escape the pass rush either. This could be a dangerous problem if he were to end up in Detroit with one of the worst lines in all of professional football.

Mark Sanchez is a guy who has very little starting experience. Sanchez has all of the necessary tools to succeed as an NFL passer, but he still has a lot to learn. When you are as bad as Detroit is, it may be best not to take a quarterback who needs time to learn. Drew Stanton was drafted a couple years ago, and I think Detroit should pass on these two quarterbacks and go a different direction, give Stanton a chance.

Andre Smith is the popular choice as the #1 tackle. I don’t see Smith being a good fit in Detroit. There are questions as to whether or not Andre Smith is even capable of playing left tackle at the next level. In my personal opinion, Smith is best suited at RT and Detroit just drafted Gosder Cherilus to fill that position last year. Jason Smith, Michael Oher, and Eugene Monroe are the other top tackles. Oher struggles severely against a speed rusher, Jason Smith has tremendous potential, but is extremely raw, and Monroe, while he has the fewest holes in his game, is not worthy of the top pick. This continues the search.

To me it comes down to the top defensive player in the draft, Aaron Curry. Curry is a special player. He is capable of playing all of the linebacker positions and he possesses a rare set of skills. With a perfect blend of coverage skills, pass rush ability, and physicality Curry is a can’t miss prospect. He has incredible range and the ability to read and react very quickly. Coaches have spoken very highly of Curry’s character and leadership abilities, which is essential to a team like Detroit. Aaron Curry never missed a game to injury and is one of those players who will immediately improve a team. If Detroit wants to start off on the right foot, they need to take Curry and give their D a boost. It has been proven in recent years that teams with top defenses compete, and putting Aaron Curry alongside Ernie Sims is a fantastic start. If they could add a pass rusher and corner with their next two picks, they would be well on their way to being relevant once again.
24 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

2/19/09
9
Can they take 22 new players with the #1 pick?

2/19/09
1
trade it, they're not tryin to win

2/19/09
0
I just posted an article that says they are looking to trade with Cleveland for Derek Anderson and Cleveland will select Curry.  But I doubt it. 


2/19/09
6
Detriot needs help everywhere, Curry is best player available.  Draft a QB and your just going to get the kid beat to a pulp  and ruin him (ie: David Carr in Houston)

2/19/09
2
I do think the best strategy is to trade down, they just need players.

QB would be a disaster if that guy doesn't have talent around him.  Kevin Smith has potential, and Calvin Johnson is a stud, but the O-line is still garbage, and Gosder in my opinion is a bust.

They've got a LOT of problems.

2/19/09
3
They need to draft Alabama LT Andre Smith.  It doesnt matter who the hell the QB is, if his O-Line sucks, so will he (just ask David Carr).  The Dolphins went with a LT when they had some QB issues coming into the draft last year and they made the playoffs.  I'm not saying the Lions would have a 10 game turnaround if they draft Smith, but they'll be on the right path if they do that.  Then, they can take the best available player at #20 and get their QB at #33 and have their QB and LT of the future.

2/19/09
1
Detroit has so many holes to fill that one player isn't going to help.  They should pass on a much needed QB and trade the #1 pick for additional picks.

It looks as if next years stock of QB's will be at least as good as this years and lets face it, the Lions will surely have a high pick then also.

2/19/09
3
The last thing an 0-16 team should be doing is taking a quarterback with the #1 draft pick. As has been discussed on this site many times, drafting any quarterback from college is a crap shoot. Detroit should have learned something from the ineptitude of the 49ers and Raiders. Either take Curry or trade the pick for two later picks--or a quarertback and a draft pick--or a good quarterback straight up.

2/19/09
9
Can they take 22 new players with the #1 pick?

2/19/09
2
MrNFL wrote:
I do think the best strategy is to trade down, they just need players.

QB would be a disaster if that guy doesn't have talent around him.  Kevin Smith has potential, and Calvin Johnson is a stud, but the O-line is still garbage, and Gosder in my opinion is a bust.

They've got a LOT of problems.
Trading down from the #1 pick rarely ever happens in this league.  It is much harder now then ever before because of the literal boatload of money that comes with the top pick.  I think they should and will do like Miami last season and sign the guy that they can get signed the quickest and easiest.  A lot of good players up there again, and Jake Long came a bit cheaper than the guys chosen several picks after him.  It's always best to build from the line up, and LT is the most important position on the O-line for most teams.

2/19/09
1
Interesting column and a welcome change from the QB-banter on too many sites.

2/19/09
2
 The only reason Matt probaly is first overall is Detroit needs a quarterback.To bad for them Sam Bradford didnt go to the draft. there are better players then matt stanford.

2/19/09
1
yanksawboy wrote:
 The only reason Matt probaly is first overall is Detroit needs a quarterback.To bad for them Sam Bradford didnt go to the draft. there are better players then matt stanford.
Need a Quarterback???  No way!!!   Martin Mayhew and Co. just reworked Culpepper's contract - they think he is going to be their savior next year.  Actually, I almost hope that is what they have in mind.  If they can find a willing trading partner, take the extra picks and build up that pathetic defense and rework both lines.  As has already been mentioned, go after a QB next year if needed.   Stafford has "bust" written all over him if he ends up in Detroit.

2/19/09
0
If any fan thinks they know what the Lions need they are just kidding themselves. The Lions #1 draft pick needs 52 other guys to help him, and right now the Lions are short about 50 guys.

2/19/09
0
I Would Give Up The Pick For A Whole Lot Of Other Random Round Picks! 1 guy is a start, but they need a new team.

2/19/09
3
(Edited by jacobmrley)
trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick. trade the pick.

did i mention they should trade the pick? they need quantity and quality and joe montana and steve young's bastard child could be there at #1 and he would still suck because of the lack of players around him on Detroit.

2/19/09
2
Andre Smith IS ready to play LT in the NFL. Stafford will be a bust regardless of who picks him.

2/19/09
1
the best thing the could do is pickup Jeff Garcia an see if he can give them a spark at the QB position and trade that pick to someone who's interested in using it... 

2/19/09
0
Raider_Dave wrote:
Trading down from the #1 pick rarely ever happens in this league.  It is much harder now then ever before because of the literal boatload of money that comes with the top pick.  I think they should and will do like Miami last season and sign the guy that they can get signed the quickest and easiest.  A lot of good players up there again, and Jake Long came a bit cheaper than the guys chosen several picks after him.  It's always best to build from the line up, and LT is the most important position on the O-line for most teams.
I'd agree that it'd be hard to trade it.  But if they can, I believe it's the best move.

If not, I'd go with the best offensive or defensive lineman.

2/19/09
4
Raider_Dave wrote:
Can they take 22 new players with the #1 pick?
They'd end up with like 18 Recievers anyway so that wouldn't even help.

2/20/09
0
(Edited by Eric)
I watched this kid play in HS... matter of fact... I played against him 3 years when he started at Highland Park in Dallas. He kicked our asses all 3 years. The kid can scramble. The system he was in at Georgia wouldn't allow for that. I doubt being in Detroit will make it much better, but he can. While he may not have shown all of his skills in college, give him 3-4 years in the NFL, and he'll be better than Roethlisberger. He's probably most comparable to Big Ben. Also, in his Sophomore year, he beat Ennis in the 4th round of the playoffs (state semifinals)... who did Ennis have at QB... A guy by the name of Graham Harrell. He was a Senior while Stafford was a Sophomore.


2/20/09
0
(Edited by Eric)
Well, it won't let me edit my post...

But I will also add this... and maybe I'm just to high on the guy.

In his sophomore year of high school, he beat Ennis HS (yes, HE beat Ennis) in the state semi-finals (round 4)... Who was QB at Ennis you ask? Graham Harrell. Graham was a senior that year.

2/25/09
1
They should defineately take a tackle. Ande Smith or Eugene Monroe. Stafford looks like he MAY develop into a good QB, but that's not a sure thing. Sanchez smells like a bust. Anyone else see him underthrow half a dozen routes at the combine? How many games has he played in 16? How many games did he come from behind in? Oh wait, he plays for USC where there's a dozen all americans around him every year he never had to worry about coming from behind.

The Lions need a line first. The have Cullpeper who is capable of a .500 season if he has a line. There are several good QB's available next season, and no one is expecting a great season from Detroit anyway so they could get a better QB next year.

If they are dead set on getting a rookie QB and grooming him up for later, Pat White would be a better choice. Not in the first round don't get me wrong. But they could take him late, for less money, use him as a slot reciever/ returner while he learns the system for a year or two, and finally when he does play, if the line isn't great he can use his legs to buy some time.

Pat White is not Mike Vick. Watch some game film from the last two seasons. White is pass first run later the opposite of Vick. I'm not saying that he would be a better QB than Stafford or Sanchez, but he would offer the Lions more opportunities for millions less in the long run. Plus, if he ends up a wide out, like i said, there are alot of good QB's coming out next year. They will still have their shot at a franchise QB and possibly the perfect "Wildcat" leader as a backup.

 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
NFL GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
NFL TICKETS
Loading...
MEET OUR FANS
Stacey
Narada
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Utah v. Houston
New York v. LA
Seattle v. Portland
Detroit v. Chicago
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
swapna_pcc joined the Minor League Baseball league Fans of AAA Baseball.
Just now!
swapna_pcc joined the Minor League Baseball league Fans of Nashville Sounds.
Just now!
swapna_pcc joined the Cricket league Fans of India.
Just now!
swapna_pcc joined the Cricket league CricketFans.
Just now!
shikhs_narula joined the NCAA Women's BB league Fans of Akron Zips (NCAA Women's BB).
Just now!
Just now!
bustedora joined the NBA league NBA Fantasy.
Just now!
Just now!
JohnGlenn09 heckled BigJunk as he passed you in the Trivia rankings
Just now!
JohnGlenn09 heckled nateabogdan as he passed you in the Trivia rankings
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help