Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
10/21/08
Is Jimmie Johnson Too Dominant For The Sprint Cup Chase?
If NASCAR Does This, They'll Have At Least One Less Fan


Jimmie Johnson appears to be well on his way to his record tying third consecutive NASCAR Sprint Cup title.  With a 149 point lead over 2nd place Greg Biffle and only four races to go, its going to take a major mistake on Johnson's part to make this Chase interesting.  Johnson's dominance of the 10 race Chase is now leading some to suggest that the Chase needs to be "Jimmie-proofed", much like Augusta National has tried (and failed) to do with Tiger Woods.

The idea is to select certain tracks that Jimmie Johnson struggles at, and put them in the Chase in order to make it more exciting.  The belief is that the ten tracks that are in the Chase favor Johnson.  There might be some reason to believe this as Johnson has an average finish of 10.03 at those tracks and has won 13 out of 46 Chase races overall.  However, this idea has a pretty large hole in it.  Who says that Johnson and crew chief Chad Knaus aren't just holding back until the Chase?  Most of the 10 Chase tracks are raced at earlier in the year, and yet he isn't as dominant at those tracks before the Chase.  To me, this would show that Johnson and crew are holding something back until the Chase when they need it.  If that's true, what makes NASCAR think that Johnson wouldn't just dominate a new slate of Chase racetracks?

The real problem for NASCAR right now is that they are selling out to marketing. The Chase idea was implemented to create more exciting championship races down the stretch.  As a fan, I wasn't comfortable with 10 races deciding the championship in a 36 race season.  It just didn't make good racing sense.  However, fans ended up giving in as the first Chase led to the closest championship finish in the NASCAR history.  The problem with this is that the best guy doesn't necessarily win the title.  In fact, in two of the four Chases so far that hasn't happened.  Jeff Gordon was without a doubt the best driver in both 2004 and 2007 but Kurt Busch and Jimmie Johnson took those respective titles. 

"Jimmie-proofing" the Chase would just be a continuation of the selling out.  Picking and choosing racetracks in order to manipulate a close championship race takes the competition and sport right out of NASCAR.  If NASCAR actually goes through with this, they could essentially pick who would win a title from year to year by picking that driver's 10 best racetracks and putting them in the Chase.  Its a bad road to go down and a road that will ruin the trust between the sport and its fans.

NASCAR already made a race-changing marketing decision earlier this year when they chose Tony Stewart as the winner of the Talladega race even though he crossed the finish line second.  If NASCAR knows what's best for their sport, they won't choose to again manipulate results and won't choose to "Jimmie-proof" the Chase.

13 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

10/21/08
5
NASCAR has no clue what they want to do with the Chase.  They keep tweaking it constantly, and they just don't know how they want to set it up.  They continue to show me the Chase was a mistake.  The old points system was in place for a very long time, and wasn't changed as they went along.

10/21/08
5
NASCAR has no clue what they want to do with the Chase.  They keep tweaking it constantly, and they just don't know how they want to set it up.  They continue to show me the Chase was a mistake.  The old points system was in place for a very long time, and wasn't changed as they went along.

10/21/08
2
I've always thought that the Chase was an effort to help appeal to the casual fan or people who have only a passing interest in NASCAR. In regards to appealing to those people, I do think it helps on some level. People like "playoffs" regardless of however oddly they're defined by a sport.

The Chase definitely needs some tweaks though, no question. But here's the counterpoint to the "driver who's the best should win" argument. Did anyone think the Giants were the best team in the NFL last year? I sure didn't, even though they won the Super Bowl. But that doesn't bother me. Should we really be that bothered by someone who didn't finish the NASCAR season with the points lead winning the Chase? I don't think so. Our opinions on this are primarily the result of history. Because when we actually stop and think about it, many sports have a champion who wasn't necessarily the best team during the regular season.

10/21/08
0
kramer wrote:
NASCAR has no clue what they want to do with the Chase.  They keep tweaking it constantly, and they just don't know how they want to set it up.  They continue to show me the Chase was a mistake.  The old points system was in place for a very long time, and wasn't changed as they went along.
 thanks for the comments


10/21/08
0
NASCAR continues to get stupider by the year.  Just 4 or 5 years ago it was a much better product IMO.

10/21/08
4
Jimmie Johnson and Chad Knaus know that they are good enough year in and year out to get into the chase, so they use the first 35 races exactly how they are suppose to be used.....as "seeding".  Johnson and Knaus admittedly test different setups and strategies in anticipation for what's to come when it matters most.  They take that information, apply it during the chase and the result has been back to back to back championships.  To me, that not only makes them dominant, that makes them smart and Johnson and company shouldnt be penalized for being smarter then the system

10/22/08
1
MrNFL wrote:
NASCAR continues to get stupider by the year.  Just 4 or 5 years ago it was a much better product IMO.
   That first sentence pretty much throws your credibility out of the window my friend!

10/22/08
2
jeradshaw wrote:
   That first sentence pretty much throws your credibility out of the window my friend!
I miss a having a legitimate champion.  I miss the "Gentleman's agreement" and hate the worthless "Freeze the field" which has ruined many races.  I miss exciting tracks like Rockingham and two Darlington's, and not extra worthless races like California.  I miss the days when phantom cautions weren't thrown every 20 laps for "debris" so that the pack is bunched.

Yes, NASCAR was great a few years ago.  Now it's unwatchable.

10/22/08
0
I'm starting to think it was probably a good thing Mike wrote this instead of me.  There may have been a record amount of profanities strewn about in disgust of NASCAR's recent fudge-ups if I had written this.

10/25/08
0
kramer wrote:
I'm starting to think it was probably a good thing Mike wrote this instead of me.  There may have been a record amount of profanities strewn about in disgust of NASCAR's recent fudge-ups if I had written this.
I'm just glad that I kept my  complaining about JG's two non-championships to about a couple of sentences.

11/2/08
0
well don' t look like he is that dominent now does it.. he can be beat.. and I hope the hell he does.. his ass has been put up on the pedistal too long.. time someone come along and chop him down like the rest of the big redwoods.. lol...

11/2/08
3
viper_dad1966 wrote:
well don' t look like he is that dominent now does it.. he can be beat.. and I hope the hell he does.. his ass has been put up on the pedistal too long.. time someone come along and chop him down like the rest of the big redwoods.. lol...

Just because Johnson doesnt win every race doesnt mean he suddenly isnt so dominant.  I bet Dale Jr. would kill to be in Johnson's position right now, up by 100+ points with 2 races left on his way to back to back to back championships


 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
NASCAR GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
NASCAR TICKETS
Loading...
MEET OUR FANS
Elisha
Caty
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Utah v. Houston
Detroit v. Chicago
Seattle v. Portland
New York v. LA
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
sinceresweetme high fived 0PETE1
Just now!
williamstewart81 joined the NFL league Dolfans Hangout.
Just now!
williamstewart81 joined the NFL league NFL Fantasy Football.
Just now!
williamstewart81 joined the NFL league NFL Draft League.
Just now!
Just now!
Just now!
williamstewart81 joined the MLB league The Oriole Way.
Just now!
Just now!
williamstewart81 joined the NFL league New Orleans Saints.
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help