Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney

6/30/09
It's Better to Be a Good Returner Than a Great Returner
Sometimes, It's Better to Be A Good Kick Returner Than A Great Kick Returner
READ MORE:



While it might seem ridiculous, it really is better to be just a good special teams returner, than a great one.

But how can this possibly be true?

Well let me start by saying that a special teams returner is the only position that can practically be completely taken out of the game by the other team.

The two greatest kick returners in my mind are Dante Hall and Devin Hester. As I was watching the top 10 kick returners of all-time, on the NFL network, I was surprised to see Dante Hall at number 10.

According to the NFL Network, Dante Hall was number 10 because his career as a great returner was so short. However, how can a man who is tied for second all-time in return touchdowns be number 10?

Dante Hall's 12 regular season return touchdowns (13 including postseason) are tied for the second most all-time. However, nine of these came in a three year period from 02-04.

It seemed as though, especially early in the 03 season when Dante Hall had four straight return touchdowns, and was even the front runner for the MVP award, that he was destined for greatness. Hall was on pace to shatter the career touchdown return record and it looked like nothing could stop him.

However, Dante Hall was so dominant that it backfired. For the rest of the season and the next few seasons, Dante Hall would rarely get any real opportunities to return the ball for a touchdown. Whenever he did get the opportunity to run the ball back, it was generally a very short kick, with no room to run.

You could blatantly see Dante Hall's frustrations after every play because he was no longer able to do the one thing he excelled so much at. Although, it was disappointing, the Chiefs didn't mind it that much because they were getting great field positions from all of the short punts and kickoffs.

Dante Hall, although not as dominant after his four game touchdown streak in 03, still did what a kick returner is suppose to do. He gave great field position to his team.

A returners' team's field position is a stat that truly tells how great a kick returner is. The problem is that this stat is virtually impossible to find.

After a couple years went by, Dante Hall eventually was no longer that "x factor" he once was. It seemed as though the lack of touches on the ball, and the frustrations of not being able to be the "x factor", had taken a toll on him.

Dante Hall didn't seem like he was having any fun anymore, and was putting too much pressure on himself. Teams realized that he was no longer as good as he was before, and people started kicking to him like they did before.

But by then, Dante Hall wasn't the same player he was once. He had lost his so called "Mojo".

In the past two seasons, injuries have kept Dante Hall, who is currently a St. Louis Ram, out for most of the last two seasons. At one time Dante Hall was destined for greatness, but now it seems as though he was robbed of it by being too great.

If he was not great, but was just good like the number two player on the top 10 list, Brian Mitchell, he wouldn't have been number 10 player on the list.

Brian Mitchell never had more than two touchdown returns in one season and never had to worry about not getting a good return. He lasted 13 years as a solid kick returner and ended it with 14 career return touchdowns, which is the most all-time.

Was Brian Mitchell really a more dominant return man then Dante Hall?

The answer is obviously no. Dante Hall is not getting the recognition he deserves as great return man, and you have to fear that Devin Hester who is number one on the NFL network list, may not in the future either.

Devin Hester, who currently is third behind Dante Hall for the most return touchdowns all time was number one on the list.

I can't really disagree with that, but his career is looking like it could shape up to be similar to Dante Hall's.

While Dante Hall may have had the greatest four game stretch ever, Devin Hester clearly had the best two year stretch of any returner with 11 return touchdowns in two seasons, despite having only 20 kickoff returns in his first season.

However, for the last season and a half, like Hall, Hester had stopped getting the ball as much, and when he did, just like Hall had, their was no room to run.

Hester had zero return touchdowns last year. I fear that Hester, like Hall, was too great in his first two seasons. Hester has a chance to redeem himself this year, but history tell us that Hester most likely won't ever be the "x factor" he once was.

Five years from now, it could be Hall at number 10 and Hester at number nine on that list, despite how unfair it may be.

Sometimes greatness really can be a curse.

23 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

6/30/09
9
I am in agreement with Devin Hester and Dante Hall! They are two great Kick Returners!!

6/30/09
8
This comment was voted poor quality by FanIQ (Show anyway)

6/30/09
3
I'm interested, who were the top 10 returners on this special? Was Josh Cribbs included?

6/30/09
7
I have seen everyone of Dante's returns, either in person or on tv (never miss a Chiefs game), and he was a great one 2 watch I can tell u that! During that stretch in 03 you could feel the excitement like a rush in the crowd when he was about 2 take a kick off or punt. Deon Sanders created that kind of excitement 2 as I'm sure Devin does in Chi town! You felt they could take one 2 the house at anytime 

6/30/09
5
Numbers-wise, it might be tough to quantify what these guys do. But let's not act like Hester wasn't worth a lot last season. Because of him, Chicago led the league in average starting field position.

6/30/09
9
I am in agreement with Devin Hester and Dante Hall! They are two great Kick Returners!!

6/30/09
3
garciabears54 wrote:
DEVON HESTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YEAH BABY!!!! HE IS GOING TO GET BACK INTO THE SWING OF THINGS THIS YEAR!!!! I GUARANTEE THAT HE TAKES MORE THAN 10 FOR THE END ZONE!!!! HE IS AND WILL ALWAYS BE THE BEST RETURN MAN EVER!!!! YOU KNOW WHY??? BECAUSE HE'S A BEAR!!!!! GO BEARS!!!
 YEAH MAN, TOTALLY

6/30/09
4
Surge wrote:
Numbers-wise, it might be tough to quantify what these guys do. But let's not act like Hester wasn't worth a lot last season. Because of him, Chicago led the league in average starting field position.
Amen Brother and this is why this coming up year we are going to WiN The SUpeRBowl!!!

6/30/09
4
Was there a link to an article ?    I'm not sure who's in the Top 10.

Great kick returners (in no order....other than how the pop into my head):

- Devin Hester
- Dante Hall
- Billy 'White Shoes' Johnson
- Gale Sayers
- Terry Metcalf
- Eric Metcalf
- Tim Brown (punt returns)
- Stump Mitchell
- Rick Upchurch
- Mel Gray
- Herschel Walker (look it up)

I'll think of some others..........

7/1/09
7
Keeter wrote:
Was there a link to an article ?    I'm not sure who's in the Top 10.

Great kick returners (in no order....other than how the pop into my head):

- Devin Hester
- Dante Hall
- Billy 'White Shoes' Johnson
- Gale Sayers
- Terry Metcalf
- Eric Metcalf
- Tim Brown (punt returns)
- Stump Mitchell
- Rick Upchurch
- Mel Gray
- Herschel Walker (look it up)

I'll think of some others..........
niiiiiiiiice list....

7/1/09
3
(Edited by CalBoomer)
Good analysis but not all that profound. Why do you think Babe Ruth and Barry Bonds drew so many walks? Or Shaq so many fouls? Defenses simply try to take away what you are good at.

7/1/09
1
Ya but it's not better to be a good baseball player than a really good one?

7/1/09
2
arihoring1 wrote:
Ya but it's not better to be a good baseball player than a really good one?
Everything is relative. If people had pitched to Ruth and Bonds, they might have hit a thousand home runs each, putting them in a class well beyond even immortally good.

7/1/09
2
Keeter wrote:
Was there a link to an article ?    I'm not sure who's in the Top 10.

Great kick returners (in no order....other than how the pop into my head):

- Devin Hester
- Dante Hall
- Billy 'White Shoes' Johnson
- Gale Sayers
- Terry Metcalf
- Eric Metcalf
- Tim Brown (punt returns)
- Stump Mitchell
- Rick Upchurch
- Mel Gray
- Herschel Walker (look it up)

I'll think of some others..........
Travis Williams, "Bullet" Bob Hayes, Leroy Kelly, to name a few more -- but the best I ever saw was Sayers, before he blew out his knee.  He was the first guy I ever remember giving me a "How on earth did he do that??" moment watching him on TV.

7/1/09
3
One thing that Hall and Hester have in common is, once they became great returners, their teams started trying to get them involved in the offense a lot to get the ball in their hands. I always figured it had something to do with fatigue as well. Because I've noticed that as soon as that started happening, their production went down.

7/1/09
2
Hester never should have been asked to be a WR. IT has taken his spark away from his return game. I think Daniel Manning will top the league again this year.

7/3/09
2
garciabears54 wrote:
DEVON HESTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YEAH BABY!!!! HE IS GOING TO GET BACK INTO THE SWING OF THINGS THIS YEAR!!!! I GUARANTEE THAT HE TAKES MORE THAN 10 FOR THE END ZONE!!!! HE IS AND WILL ALWAYS BE THE BEST RETURN MAN EVER!!!! YOU KNOW WHY??? BECAUSE HE'S A BEAR!!!!! GO BEARS!!!
Why do people put poor on my score??? Don't be mad because the Bears are going to win the Superbowl this year....Acceptance is the key to happiness..

7/3/09
1
garciabears54 wrote:
Why do people put poor on my score??? Don't be mad because the Bears are going to win the Superbowl this year....Acceptance is the key to happiness..
Alfred, I think I did on One, but luckily it let me go back, and change it to smart. Can't see lic without me bifocals....lol

7/8/09
0
I do not agree with this article at all.  Any GM would tell you he would rather have a great return man than just a good one.  Opposing coaches have to spesifically gameplan for players like Hall and Hester.  Most return guys touch the ball even less recievers; Hester or Hall might only touch the ball 4 or 5 times in a game.  Kickers and Punters are told to kick away from these special players and can make costly mistakes or penalties.  Special teams is all about field position and big plays and when players like Hall or Hester get the ball, at any time or any place on the field, they are dangerous.

8/9/09
0
torie wrote:
I do not agree with this article at all.  Any GM would tell you he would rather have a great return man than just a good one.  Opposing coaches have to spesifically gameplan for players like Hall and Hester.  Most return guys touch the ball even less recievers; Hester or Hall might only touch the ball 4 or 5 times in a game.  Kickers and Punters are told to kick away from these special players and can make costly mistakes or penalties.  Special teams is all about field position and big plays and when players like Hall or Hester get the ball, at any time or any place on the field, they are dangerous.
Good point - eventually, the opponents have to decide how much field position they want to sacrifice by kicking away from a great returner.

 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
NFL GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
NFL TICKETS
Loading...
MEET OUR FANS
Caty
Stacey
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Detroit v. Chicago
Utah v. Houston
New York v. LA
Seattle v. Portland
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
nickolasgentry joined the NFL league New Orleans Saints.
Just now!
nickolasgentry joined the NFL league NFL Fantasy Football.
Just now!
nickolasgentry joined the NFL league NFL Draft League.
Just now!
nickolasgentry joined the NBA league HeatFans.
Just now!
nickolasgentry joined the NBA league NBA Fantasy.
Just now!
Just now!
nickolasgentry joined the NBA league Denver Nuggets Fans.
Just now!
nickolasgentry joined the NBA league NBA Fantasy.
Just now!
Just now!
nickolasgentry joined the NBA league Cav Fans.
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help