Ivan Rodriguez announces retirement as a Texas Ranger

Time for another Hall of Fame debate, now that Pudge Rodriguez is officially retiring

4/20/12 in MLB   |   Pat   |   5234 respect

June 15, 2011; Washington, D.C., USA; Washington Nationals catcher Ivan Rodriguez (7) in the first inning against the St. Louis Cardinals at Nationals Park. Mandatory Credit: Joy R. Absalon-US PRESSWIREIvan Rodriguez hasn't been the most impressive player in baseball over the past few years, but there's no denying that he made a huge impact on the game earlier in his career, and was definitely the best catcher in all of baseball for at least a decade.

Rodriguez will announce his retirement from baseball on Monday in Texas, as a member of the Texas Rangers. He played 12 seasons with the Rangers, and that's where he became one of the best players in baseball, including winning the AL MVP in 1999.

As we tend to do when great players announce their retirement, it's time to debate his Hall of Fame worthiness.

Based on numbers alone, he's a virtual lock. He'll retire with 2,844 hits, 311 HR, 14 All-Star selections, 13 Gold Gloves (including 10 straight from 1992-2001), and 7 Silver Sluggers. As mentioned before, he was the 1999 AL MVP, and finished in the top 10 three more times.

As great as he was at the plate (.296 career average, 7 straight seasons with an OPS+ of 120 or more), Rodriguez' real skill was behind the plate. His 13 Gold Gloves were no mistake. Aside from the Molina brothers, very few (if any) catchers in recent memory have been as outstanding defensively as Rodriguez.

Rodriguez led the league in caught stealing percentage 9 times, and is the active leader with 45.68% for his career. The next best active catcher is Yadier Molina, with 44.34%. Rodriguez is the all-time leader in putouts for a catcher, and also has the record for most games as a catcher, with 2,427. He's the Cal Ripken Jr. of catchers.

One major problem with Rodriguez' Hall of Fame candidacy is the same problem many HOF-eligible players are battling right now: Performance enhancing drugs.

Rodriguez was named in the Mitchell Report as one of the many MLB players who used PEDs. When asked whether or not he took them, he said "only God knows."

For those of you who can't read between the lines, that means he absolutely did.

Is that enough to keep the greatest catcher of our era out of the Hall of Fame? If you ask me, I think it's not. He should definitely be inducted as soon as he's eligible, PEDs or not.

Congrats to Pudge Rodriguez for a truly amazing career. What do you think... Hall of Fame... right?
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine. Preview

4/22/12   |   derms33   |   17653 respect

why he can't catch in Cleveland right now behind Santana is a wonder...backup catchers in MLB are a joke. Except in Milwaukee

4/22/12   |   derms33   |   17653 respect

No debate..No Doubt

4/21/12   |   ohwell_   |   16533 respect

   Giants/Marlins NL Championship, his running over the catcher is a play I was fortunate to
see live,  My son still talks about it.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xgr7aeFjNFk 

4/20/12   |   Dream_Machine   |   13448 respect


4/20/12   |   Eric_   |   7716 respect

I had forgotten he was named in the Mitchell Report. Since he wasn't one of the originally demonized players, he'll probably be fine.

4/20/12   |   ML31   |   3675 respect

Pudge is a no-brainer.  It is difficult at best to make a compelling argument NOT to put him in the Hall.  He was the best catcher in the last 30 years.  Perhaps even longer.