Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
10/8/08
Junichi Tazawa Inspires Japanese Baseball To Place 3-Year Ban On Players Who Jump Straight To The MLB
Can You Imagine The Backlash If They Tried This In The United States?

The Japanese pro baseball league has decided that it's tired of the best Japanese players leaving for the United States, and doesn't want to see it happening any more. At least, not unless they can squeeze a couple years and a couple million dollars out of them, first.

Taking $51 million to allow Daisuke Matsuzaka to speak with a Major League team is perfectly fine. If Ichiro Suzuki wants to move to America after playing 9 years in Japan, that's fine too. But if the next young Japanese phenom wants to go straight to the States after high school, then he should be prepared to suffer the consequences.

An executive committee representing Japan's pro baseball teams announced that they will institute a 3-year ban on all players who go straight from high school to a non-Japanese pro league, and a 2-year ban on players who go overseas after college or after playing on a company team.

The decision came after Junichi Tazawa, a pitcher for Nippon Oil Corps, wrote letters to the various Japanese teams, announcing his intention to play in the United States, and requesting that they not draft him in the upcoming Japanese baseball draft. The ban would likely apply to Tazawa, forcing him to sit out for 2 years, if he were ever to decide to return to Japan.

While it might seem like this could help Japanese baseball, it's hard to believe that they'll stick with it. If Tazawa becomes a star in the Major Leagues here in America, and wants to do a "victory tour" late in his career with a Japanese team, are they really going to make him sit out 2 years, or will they seize the opportunity, and take advantage of the revenue that they will gain from having him pitch for them?

The other question is, how the hell is this sort of thing allowed to happen? Aren't there employment and discrimination laws in Japan? If this rule were even proposed in the US, people would be screaming racism, and unfair hiring practices. And those people would be right.

Hopefully the people in charge of Japanese pro baseball reconsider, and treat their young players a bit more fairly. If not, hopefully the good ones come over here, make their money, and go back to Japan and preach the virtues of fair business practices until the baseball executives come to their senses.

David Stern's age limit is ridiculous enough, but Brandon Jennings still won't get blackballed if he ever wants to play in the NBA. Guys like Junichi Tazawa should get the same courtesy from his country.


Japan baseball execs to introduce ban to curb drift to major leagues [The Mainichi Daily News]
11 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

10/9/08
3
   Japan, please force Fukudome to come back.  PLEASE!

10/8/08
1
After this one, our owners look like brilliant idiots.

10/8/08
1
I'm not sure how to describe this, but absurd seems to be the word. There's no way this stands though, especially if these guys become stars.

10/8/08
1
This will hurt Japan more in the long run, than help them.  It's like telling a kid he can't have something.  He will just want it that much more.  If they go through with this rule, most of the young stars will sit around waiting for their 3-year "probation period" to expire so they can pursue other avenues.  More and more players will be leaving Japan because it's ok, as long as they wait 2-3 years.

It made sense in my head before I wrote it.  Promise.

10/8/08
1
tpowell25 wrote:
This will hurt Japan more in the long run, than help them.  It's like telling a kid he can't have something.  He will just want it that much more.  If they go through with this rule, most of the young stars will sit around waiting for their 3-year "probation period" to expire so they can pursue other avenues.  More and more players will be leaving Japan because it's ok, as long as they wait 2-3 years.

It made sense in my head before I wrote it.  Promise.
Actually, the ban is when they come back. So they won't have to worry about it initially.

10/8/08
0
100%InjuryRate wrote:
Actually, the ban is when they come back. So they won't have to worry about it initially.
At least it made sense in my head.

I still think it will hurt Japan's baseball market more, instead of helping it.  I'm sticking with the "they'll want it more if you tell them they can't have it" theory.  Regardless of the facts, I bet that works in this situation some how.

10/8/08
1

I don't think too many kids coming out of high school will give a crap about this.  Most will probably seek out the money that they can earn right away, and be relatively uneffected by something that will be way down the road.  How many people at 20 are making career decisions based on what they will feel like doing when they are 35?  I don't think most high school graduates are at that level of maturity...and I'm not sure they should care if they have to sit out of 2 years of Japanese baseball anyway.


10/8/08
0
SoxandCards39 wrote:

I don't think too many kids coming out of high school will give a crap about this.  Most will probably seek out the money that they can earn right away, and be relatively uneffected by something that will be way down the road.  How many people at 20 are making career decisions based on what they will feel like doing when they are 35?  I don't think most high school graduates are at that level of maturity...and I'm not sure they should care if they have to sit out of 2 years of Japanese baseball anyway.

That's a very good point. Plus, there's no guarantee that when you make the decision at 18 or 19 that this stupid rule will be in place when you come back at age 35.

It's a tremendously weird rule, and one that seemingly wouldn't impede players from heading to the states at all.

10/8/08
0
Maybe it is supposed to be a way of "losing face" having your country look down on you for leaving.  The whole idea of "losing face" may just be something that Hollywood has over-stressed about Japan though.  I really don't know, having not been there myself.  I don't claim to understand cultural decisions made there, but this does seem pretty silly.

10/8/08
0
I'm pretty sure these guys that are coming over form Japan are making more over here than they would over there. Plus the endorsements and the upfront contract money that they get is absolutlely insane. If they want to try the market over here then fine, and by the time they go back (if it at all) the rule really won't effect them too much cause they'll probably be past their playing age anyway.

10/8/08
0
 yea...ridiculous,i cant see this move holdng up fo very long....but its also true....how much backlash would there be if this were reversed and american players were banned from leaving here....curious to see what comes of this whole situation!!!

10/9/08
3
   Japan, please force Fukudome to come back.  PLEASE!

 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
MLB GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
MLB TICKETS
Loading...
MEET OUR FANS
Lindsey
Elisha
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Detroit v. Chicago
Utah v. Houston
Seattle v. Portland
New York v. LA
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
vijaykumar19762012 created a new Cricket trivia question. Click here to answer it.
Just now!
Just now!
chandumenon created a new India trivia question. Click here to answer it.
Just now!
musdi54 joined the Soccer league 2006 World Cup.
Just now!
musdi54 joined the Soccer league Fans of Brazil (Soccer).
Just now!
sushmamacwan joined the Soccer league Barclay's Premiere Fans.
Just now!
sushmamacwan joined the Soccer league Manchester United Fans.
Just now!
bharatkmr02 joined the Cricket league Fans of Australia.
Just now!
bharatkmr02 joined the Cricket league CricketFans.
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help