Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
4/7/08
NBA Draft 1st Pick: Derrick Rose or Michael Beasley?
READ MORE:
NBA
Last year the Portland Trailblazers had the difficult, but enviable situation of deciding between Kevin Durant and Greg Oden. This year the lucky NBA Draft Lottery winner will have an even tougher decision: Derrick Rose or Michael Beasley.

That's basically the equivalent of a blogger deciding to post about Marisa Miller or Brooklyn Decker. Tough call. You win either way.

At the midseason point, I suggested that regardless of team needs (Heat w/ D-Wade already) that Derrick Rose is the choice and nothing the Memphis point guard has done this last month has made me change my mind. Rose's biggest weakness, if you could even call it that, was his ability to consistently hit a jump shot. He can already get to the rim when he chooses, put his teammates in perfect position to score and play excellent defense. But the consistent perimeter shot? Against the best defensive teams he's had to play against in the tournament, Michigan State and UCLA, Rose has been hitting his jumper. The Simeon High School (Chicago) product also provides the necessary court leadership you want from a point guard. If there's a weakness, it's clearly his diet. You don't exactly want to invest millions in an athlete who's diet consists of candy, liquid candy, syrup, more candy and did I mention candy.
 
With Michael Beasley you're getting a legit 6'10 big man who has all the necessary post-moves, athleticism and three-point shot to score aplenty in the pros. With the pick and pop becoming NBA team's regular offensive play, Beasley size and ability to shoot is invaluable.

So why do I still prefer Rose?

A do-everything point guard with size and court vision can effect a game more than a high scoring post player, which is why I'd still take Rose if I were the Miami Heat. Dwyane Wade will instantly become more effective at the 2 spot. In fact, Rose will be much better than Wade in just two short years.

Beasley can score, but his defense vanishes from time to time. Does he want to be one of the greatest? I know that answer is yes with Rose, but I haven't seen the same fire with Beasley. The dude is going to score 25+ a game, no doubt. Is he going to bring the effort needed every night to turn around the New York Knicks or Heat? I'm not saying he won't, but when making the decision between these two there's more questions with the Kansas State forward, however small they may be, when it comes to attitude. There's been a lot of talented players drafted high, what's between their ears separates the good from the great.

I'll stick with Rose. Who do you think should go first?
10 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment
Top comment earns 300 Points!
454 days ago
2
VOTE:
 
+2
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
(Edited 04/07/08 4:27PM by kantwistaye)

All season I would've gone with Beasley, but as I've seen more of Rose he is the obvious answer.  His combination of size, speed, and skills has been unmatched by any PG I've seen. 

 

Beasley's game against Wisconsin really concerned me.  He was able to be taken out of his game by guys far less athletic far too easily.  He's going to face far better players than Joe Krabbenhoft and Greg Stiemsma in the NBA.  It was only one game, but I just didn't like it.

 

By the way, Marisa Miller >>> Brooklyn Decker.

 
454 days ago
1
VOTE:
 
+1
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
So because Rose shot well in a few tournament games he's suddenly a solid shooter? I had a decent Friday down at the Y, maybe I should throw my name into the draft.

He can't hit a three to save his life, which doesn't necessarily mean he can't learn how to. But right now, if you're a pro team, there are ways to defend him because his jumper is suspect.

If I drafted him, I'd have him shooting about 1000 jumpers a day.
 
454 days ago
0
VOTE:
 
+0
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
100%InjuryRate wrote:
So because Rose shot well in a few tournament games he's suddenly a solid shooter? I had a decent Friday down at the Y, maybe I should throw my name into the draft.

He can't hit a three to save his life, which doesn't necessarily mean he can't learn how to. But right now, if you're a pro team, there are ways to defend him because his jumper is suspect.

If I drafted him, I'd have him shooting about 1000 jumpers a day.
If you're not going to judge performance in big games ... then what are you going to judge?

I bet Beasley is dominating the post right now by himself in some gym.
 
454 days ago
0
VOTE:
 
+0
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
If Miami lands the 1st pick,  Pat Riley has issued his interests in Beasley.
 
453 days ago
0
VOTE:
 
+0
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
Too bad these great freshman can't stick around.  I'll take Beasley by a nose
 
453 days ago
0
VOTE:
 
+0
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
Everything I've read says that Riley is in love with Rose. As a fan, I am as well. However Rose is a similar player to Wade. It wouldn't make sense for Miami to draft Rose, and history would state that if they had the pick it would go to the best big man available anyway. Either way, whoever gets Rose is lucky.
 
453 days ago
0
VOTE:
 
+0
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
kantwistaye wrote:

All season I would've gone with Beasley, but as I've seen more of Rose he is the obvious answer.  His combination of size, speed, and skills has been unmatched by any PG I've seen. 

 

Beasley's game against Wisconsin really concerned me.  He was able to be taken out of his game by guys far less athletic far too easily.  He's going to face far better players than Joe Krabbenhoft and Greg Stiemsma in the NBA.  It was only one game, but I just didn't like it.

 

By the way, Marisa Miller >>> Brooklyn Decker.

Also remember, he's 19. He'll be drafted out of potential. I've watched many of his games though, and agree that I see many flaws. I would never disagree that Beasley COULD be an amazing player with development, however.
 
453 days ago
0
VOTE:
 
+0
 
+0
 
+0
 
-0
100%InjuryRate wrote:
So because Rose shot well in a few tournament games he's suddenly a solid shooter? I had a decent Friday down at the Y, maybe I should throw my name into the draft.

He can't hit a three to save his life, which doesn't necessarily mean he can't learn how to. But right now, if you're a pro team, there are ways to defend him because his jumper is suspect.

If I drafted him, I'd have him shooting about 1000 jumpers a day.
D-Wade is proof that a guy with no jumper can make it in the NBA. 
 
 
Preview
HOTTEST ARTICLES
NBA GEAR
Loading...
MEET OUR FANS
Caty
Elisha
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Foam
Rubber
Cork
Plastic
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
Anthonyg7575's comment was voted top comment in the MLB poll Are you going to read Joe Torre new book ?.
Just now!
Just now!
towerman gave a thumbs up (5/5) to the trivia question How hot was it for the 2007 Labor Day race at California Speedway?.
Just now!
ChargerJim warned Nick S that he is climbing towards Nick S in the rankings. He is 5837.4 points behind Nick S.
Just now!
knpaulson gave a thumbs up (5/5) to the trivia question Ric Ocasek was the lead vocalist for this Rock Band.
Just now!
Just now!
teja131192 joined the Cricket league Fans of India.
Just now!
teja131192 joined the Cricket league CricketFans.
Just now!
dimpufriends0011 joined the Tennis league Fans of Roddick, Andy.
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help