Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
9/4/08
NFL Season Opener: New York Giants vs Washington Redskins Reactions
With the Giants Win, Are They Still Among the Elite? And is it Panic Button Time in Washington?
The season opener could have been more exciting, although for Giants fans, I'm sure it was exciting enough, as the Giants defeated the Redskins 16-7.

Let the over-reactions begin.

Heading into the game, many people had started dismissing not only the Giants returning to the Super Bowl, but even the playoffs.  With the many losses on the defense, it was important to see how the defense would play, and they looked pretty good.  The Redskins never were able to get a consistent passing game, and Clinton Portis was limited in their effectiveness.   The Giants were able to get a lot of yards offensively, as Brandon Jacobs ran wild, Plaxico Burress caught every pass in sight, and the offensive line overpowered the Washington defense.

Of course, this means that many of those downing the Giants will instantly flip flop back to the Giants being great, but not all was positive in the win.  Despite many yards gained, they still only managed 16 points, and Washington's offense looked more bad than the Giants.

And many of those who had high expectations for the Redskins will be concerned.  The D gave up many yards, and the offense just seemed lost, and new coach Jim Zorn's playcall was mediocre at best.  They kept going to ineffective short passes, and the runs were predictable.  Of course, I'm sure many will already be calling for Zorn's head.

But what does this game really mean for these two teams?

It means the Giants are 1-0, and the Redskins are 0-1.

After the first games, we always tend to over-react.  And while you can learn things from the first game, we must remember, that in one game, anything can happen.  It usually takes 3-5 weeks before you really have a good idea of what each team will bring. 

In the end, it's a win for the Giants and a loss for the Redskins.  One down, 15 more to go.
29 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

9/4/08
1
While Jim Zorn's offense is less than impressive, I see this game having boiled down to a slow reaction on defense.

Once the Skins had Laron Landry shadow Plaxico Burress, the Giants didn't move the ball. Plax had 98 yards receiving in the first half and 7 receptions. Just 3 and about 35 yards in the second. Fred Smoot's injury certainly didn't help.

That said, wasn't all that impressed with the Giants, but a win is a win.

9/4/08
2
Who the hell had high expectations for the Redskins?

9/5/08
0
100%InjuryRate wrote:
Who the hell had high expectations for the Redskins?
I must say I did... would have rather seen the roles reversed but this is the first game - lets call it rookie coach gitters.

9/5/08
1
WTF was Zorn doing?  Does he know there is no 9 pt. play in the NFL?  Horrible Game and seriously a bad coach in Zorn..PRACTICE THE 2-MINUTE DRILL!!!!

9/5/08
1
I don't think Campbell had any idea where the first down marker was all game. That's about the only reason i can think of for why he continually threw 2-yard dump passes on 3rd and 10.

9/5/08
0
(Edited by Pat)
Man... I wonder what they're going to do about the QB situation if Campbell keeps this up...


9/5/08
0
100%InjuryRate wrote:
I don't think Campbell had any idea where the first down marker was all game. That's about the only reason i can think of for why he continually threw 2-yard dump passes on 3rd and 10.
he had no choice....pressure....PREssure......PRESSURE. Plus I beliee Madden pointed out that Jason Cambell has been through like 7 Off Coord in College and the NFL and everyone is differant...hell of a thing to adapt to.. 

9/5/08
0
Pat wrote:
Man... I wonder what they're going to do about the QB situation if Campbell keeps this up...

hey nice slap at all the bandwagon riders pat!!!

9/5/08
0
CriticalFanatic wrote:
While Jim Zorn's offense is less than impressive, I see this game having boiled down to a slow reaction on defense.

Once the Skins had Laron Landry shadow Plaxico Burress, the Giants didn't move the ball. Plax had 98 yards receiving in the first half and 7 receptions. Just 3 and about 35 yards in the second. Fred Smoot's injury certainly didn't help.

That said, wasn't all that impressed with the Giants, but a win is a win.
what

9/5/08
0
CriticalFanatic wrote:
While Jim Zorn's offense is less than impressive, I see this game having boiled down to a slow reaction on defense.

Once the Skins had Laron Landry shadow Plaxico Burress, the Giants didn't move the ball. Plax had 98 yards receiving in the first half and 7 receptions. Just 3 and about 35 yards in the second. Fred Smoot's injury certainly didn't help.

That said, wasn't all that impressed with the Giants, but a win is a win.
hi

9/5/08
0

But the BEST preseason game youve ever seen...thats what it looked more like to me.


9/5/08
0
I gotta say, neither team looked all that impressive to me.     First, the Giants.    Jacobs looked good, and luckily Washington didn't adjust over to put more coverage on Burress, for Eli was able to hit Plax any time he wanted / needed to.    However, the G-men tried a few screens that went nowhere, and Eli didn't have a lot of success with other receivers (Toomer & Smith each caught a few, but Toomer was blanketed anytime he went past 10 yards).    The G-men will need some semblance of a deep threat (Moss ?) to stretch the defense.

Now for Washington (who I thought would cover.....ugh !).     They had nothing on offense at all.    I counted 8 or 9 times when the snap occurred and the O-line was still in their stance; very, very slow getting off the ball.    Campbell looked lost, and he looks more like Tony Banks (old Ram QB) now....which is NOT good for the 'West Coast offense'.    (side note - can we come up with a different name for that style of offense???)    I thought Wash would keep it close by running, for the Redskins are (were?) good at running the ball, and the Giants D-line & LB'ers are not what they were last year.     However, they never really tried running the ball, and when they did it was a simple dive behind the guard.     How 'bout a misdirection, or the old 'counter-trey' to get the defense leaning the wrong way ?     (can you tell I have Portis in my Fantasy pool ?!?!)

What concerned me the most about Wash (and I'm not even a fan of theirs!) is general leadership & management.     No halftime adjustments (at least what I could see), especially with regards to Burress.     Man, he could've caught 20 passes last night if the Giants really wanted to.     Landry didn't slide over until late in the 4th, and I'll bet that was him doing that on his own instead of coming from the coaches (Greg Blache....oh my !).    And on their last drive, they needed 2 scores, but kept dinking-and-dunking, doing nothing but falsifying Campbell's stats.

If last night was indicative, Wash is starting at a 4-12 (3-13 ?) season, while my jury is still out on the G-men....mainly because of Washington's ineptness.     But, maybe the Giants deserve a little more credit, Eli looked sharp & composed, and Jacobs, Plax, and Tuck certainly played well.

9/5/08
0
You didn't see Dolphins/Steelers in the mud last year.  THAT game was just brutal.

9/5/08
0
It's not defensive games that are bad, I've seen field goal fests that are great defensive battles.  That Steelers/Dolphins game was awful weather, awful field, and awful play all around.

9/5/08
0
Detroit/Atlanta.  That one will probably be brutal.  Good thing I have Sunday Ticket now so I'm not forced to watch it on Fox.

9/5/08
0
They claim the Lions are to move to a run heavy, so we'll see.

The national Brett Favre fest Jets/Miami I don't see being too great either.

9/5/08
0
MrNFL wrote:
Detroit/Atlanta.  That one will probably be brutal.  Good thing I have Sunday Ticket now so I'm not forced to watch it on Fox.
 The game might suck, but I think it'd be interesting to get a look at Matt Ryan, and by the looks of things Calvin Johnson will be worth the price of admission for every game.

9/5/08
1
In reference to the title... I realize the Giants won the Super Bowl last year, but there was really only 1 day in which I would have considered them to be "elite". Their status as "elite" began and ended on Super Bowl Sunday. There wasn't much else that could be considered elite about that team. Good, maybe. Elite, no.

9/5/08
0
Pat wrote:
In reference to the title... I realize the Giants won the Super Bowl last year, but there was really only 1 day in which I would have considered them to be "elite". Their status as "elite" began and ended on Super Bowl Sunday. There wasn't much else that could be considered elite about that team. Good, maybe. Elite, no.
Hey, a Championship is a championship.

9/5/08
0
Pat wrote:
In reference to the title... I realize the Giants won the Super Bowl last year, but there was really only 1 day in which I would have considered them to be "elite". Their status as "elite" began and ended on Super Bowl Sunday. There wasn't much else that could be considered elite about that team. Good, maybe. Elite, no.
 In their defense, they won AT Dallas, At Green Bay, and then the Patriots.  Throw in their great week 17 game and I'd say they were among the elite for at least a month.

9/5/08
1
 I'll conveniently ignore that last part.

9/6/08
0
MrNFL wrote:
Hey, a Championship is a championship.
i bet Cambell was impressed with the giants .....

 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
NFL GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
NFL TICKETS
Loading...
MEET OUR FANS
Narada
Stacey
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Detroit v. Chicago
Utah v. Houston
Seattle v. Portland
New York v. LA
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
anex_bayot joined the NCAA Women's Volleyball league Fans of UTSA Roadrunners.
Just now!
anex_bayot joined the NCAA Women's Volleyball league NCAA Volleyball Fans.
Just now!
talal2561969 joined the Olympics league Fans of Summer Olympics.
Just now!
talal2561969 joined the Olympics league Fans of Swimming.
Just now!
talal2561969 joined the Olympics league OlympicsFans.
Just now!
sunny_notty77 joined the Tennis league Fans of Nadal, Rafael.
Just now!
sunny_notty77 joined the Tennis league Tennis Fans.
Just now!
hazelmarian joined the Soccer league Barclay's Premiere Fans.
Just now!
hazelmarian joined the Soccer league Liverpool Fans.
Just now!
vigneshhgsl joined the X Games league Fans of Ski.
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help