• join now
  • login
  • Login
8/27/08
Ranking College Football Strongest Conferences Before Kickoff
Little Doubt Who Belongs On Top, The Rest Is More Complicated
READ MORE:
It's one of the most debated topics every college football season, although the conversation should only address the order in which conferences follow the SEC.

Who's the strongest football conference as we head into the 2008 season? It's the Southeastern. I'm a Big Ten guy, but I won't let my bias blind me from the obvious. Frankly, I'm getting tired of the Big Televen vs SEC debates, because right now the Pacific 10 is a much more viable competitor. And as we head into this season, the Big XII has plenty to offer.

Here's my ranking of college football conferences before we kickoff. We'll do this each Tuesday of the regular season, when we have real results to compare. Share your rankings below.

1. SEC
Home to the defending national champions, who are likely going to take a step back this season, but LSU is still one of the nation's five most talented teams. The most talented also belongs to the Southeastern Conference in Athens, Georgia. Combined with Florida and Auburn, you have four teams that could be favored to win to compete with the best team in each of the major power conferences. Tennessee, Alabama and South Carolina are hardly slouches and show the extreme depth of the preeminent collegiate football conference.

One exercise I try to keep in mind when ranking conferences is taking a couple of the middle to bottom tier teams from one and sizing it up against the other. For instance, I think Mississippi State could finish in the top three in the Big East, and have a legit shot to win the ACC's Coastal Division this year. That says it all.

2. Big XII
At the end of last season this spot belonged to the Pac-10. The departure of Dennis Dixon and DeSean Jackson moved Oregon and Cal a step back, albeit small. That's enough though for me to move the Big XII up a notch with a bevy of good teams to go with a couple national title contenders. The Pac-10 has just one viable BCS contender in USC. The Big XII offers Missouri, Oklahoma and Texas with that kind of potential, while Kansas and Texas Tech are dangerous. Teams like Nebraska and Kansas State would finish in the top half of the Pac-10.

3. Pac-10
We know what to expect from USC every year. Last year, Cal, Oregon and Arizona State were all tough competition. This year, the gap is pretty large in my mind between the Trojans and the next best team. With Nate Costa basically out for the season for the Ducks, I remain even more convinced that the Trojans will have an easy run. So how would the Ducks, Bears and Sun Devils fair against other conferences top tier? Each would compete with Clemson for the ACC title and compete favorably against Michigan, Wisconsin and Penn State. However, I don't like their odds against the likes of Florida, LSU and Auburn. Maybe not even Tennessee, Alabama and South Carolina.


4. Big Ten
OK, maybe my bias comes through here, but I don't think the conference is as down as most would like to believe. Despite their National Championship struggles, Ohio State is, FYI, a pretty damn good football team. Last season was supposed to be a slightly down year, while this year's Buckeyes are a more legitimate BCS contender. The biggest question, and one that will be answered during the first few weeks of the season, is how strong are the 2nd place challengers. Michigan State pays a visit to California Saturday night would which should tell us a lot. Purdue visits Oregon, Illinois takes on Missouri, and Penn State host Oregon State. All road teams will obviously be underdogs. Big Ten needs to win three of those four games to prove they've got depth to compete against the top three conferences. The conference needs Iowa and Northwestern to take step forward.

5. Big East
The margin between these final three BCS conferences is small. West Virginia remains the team to beat, but South Florida, Cincinnati, Rutgers and Pittsburgh are all strong. In fact, I'm fully aboard the Pitt bandwagon this season and think they'll compete for the title. What concerns me about the Big East is that Connecticut was a co-champion last year. That's not good. I'm admittedly always down on the Big East and with expectations low they tend to impress. Key games I'm watching early: Cincinnati at Oklahoma, Connecticut vs. Virginia, Louisville vs Kansas State, South Florida vs Kansas and Rutgers vs North Carolina.

6. ACC
Clemson is a very, very good team. On paper. Boston College and Virginia Tech take steps backward. Florida State remains shaky, but dangerous, as is Miami. Those two teams' success will define this conference. Wake Forest remains one of the most underrated teams in the country, but as a whole, besides Clemson, the top teams just don't match up with the rest of the country. Key games: Clemson vs Alabama, Wake Forest vs Ole Miss, Georgia Tech vs Mississippi State, North Carolina at Rutgers. Four wins there and I'll move the ACC up.

7. Mountain West - BYU, BYU, BYU. Utah could pull off an upset at Michigan on week 1.
8. WAC - Hawaii is down and out, but Fresno State and Boise State are always strong and much better than the top of these two conferences below.
9. Mid-American - Miami U and Central Michigan have two big games against the SEC early on.
10. Sun Belt - Troy is competitive, and on its way up as is Florida Atlantic.
READ MORE: NCAAF, SEC, Big East, ACC, Pac 10, Rankings
Advertisement
27 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

8/27/08
1
You think the ACC is better than the Big East? and the Pac 10? Whoa! NC stinks Virginia stinks Georgia Tech stinks NC St REALLY stinks Miami and FSU are trying to find their legs Wake Forest will come back to earth Clemson hasn't proved anything these last two years and that leaves us with VaTech and BC who came from.....the Big East

8/27/08
0
MarkTheShark wrote:
You think the ACC is better than the Big East? and the Pac 10? Whoa! NC stinks Virginia stinks Georgia Tech stinks NC St REALLY stinks Miami and FSU are trying to find their legs Wake Forest will come back to earth Clemson hasn't proved anything these last two years and that leaves us with VaTech and BC who came from.....the Big East
And as much as I hate to admit it, BC will not be very good this year. I love them, but Matt Ryan WAS their team last year. Without him, I honestly believe they would have lost 8 games. And now he's gone. It's shaping up to be a long year, IMO.

8/28/08
0
What about WVU? Last time I checked, they were a pretty good team. Pitt has a shot this year, and South Florida is still on the rise. You can talk about Rutgers and Louisville all you want, but those are middle-of-the-road Big East teams... why don't you talk about the top teams?

Oh yeah... because they blow your argument out of the water...

8/28/08
0
East Coast bias? Are you kidding me? How about you check the facts about the Big East playing the Big 12. You throw out the "east coast bias" argument like it's cool, but I haven't even said a single thing yet that could even remotely be considered biased.

Last year:
WVU beat Oklahoma (Big 12) and Mississippi State (SEC)
South Florida beat Auburn (SEC), lost to Oregon (Pac-10)
Cincinnati beat Oregon State (Pac-10)

Most Big East teams didn't play a lot of great out-of-conference games, but when they did, they did pretty well.

YOU are the one making biased statements that you can't possibly back up, because they have zero facts behind them.

Oklahoma won the Big 12 last year... WVU beat Oklahoma. Their ONLY losses last year were to OTHER Big East teams. So how do you figure they would be a middle of the pack team in the rest of the conferences? That makes literally no sense at all.

8/28/08
0
You are saying my opinion is biased, because I disagree with you. But my opinion is solely based on facts. There is no room whatsoever for bias.

I'm not saying that the Big East is better than the SEC, but I think that it's competitive with most of the other conferences, and if you threw Texas in there, they would be somewhere between 2nd and 4th, just like they are in the Big 12.

8/28/08
0
This isn't a fact, but it's my prediction: Texas will finish this year out of the top 25.

8/28/08
0
I know Texas played Central Florida really tough last year, winning by THREE whole points. That's a C-USA team brother: What happened to UCF when they played South Florida? ....64-12
You rightly pointed out Louisville was disappointing last year.....BUT they still whipped the crap out of NC State IN RALEIGH....USF hammered UNC   ...BIG EAST> ACC
Polls mean nothing, results count.......
I'm sure you are a Big 12 honk that will be humbled by USF's victory over Kansas in three weeks.
Texas will stumble home with an Alamo Bowl bid.
Matt Grothe > Colt McCoy

8/28/08
1
MarkTheShark wrote:
I know Texas played Central Florida really tough last year, winning by THREE whole points. That's a C-USA team brother: What happened to UCF when they played South Florida? ....64-12
You rightly pointed out Louisville was disappointing last year.....BUT they still whipped the crap out of NC State IN RALEIGH....USF hammered UNC   ...BIG EAST> ACC
Polls mean nothing, results count.......
I'm sure you are a Big 12 honk that will be humbled by USF's victory over Kansas in three weeks.
Texas will stumble home with an Alamo Bowl bid.
Matt Grothe > Colt McCoy
Well I am a B12 honk and I think KU is gonna lose big to USF. I am hoping for CU to upset WVU in Boulder this year.
Plus MCcraig and his typing is giving me a freaking headache I cant stand to read crap like that.

8/28/08
1
Honestly, it's a lot easier to read when it's written properly... but that's just me.

8/28/08
2
Personally, I think it just makes you look ignorant when you type like that. No offense, that's just how I feel.

9/26/09
0
Alabama was tested: they beat a very good VT team at a neutral site to open the college football weekend.

9/26/09
0
"as good as" Florida? NO. ..."as good as" Arkansas? Better. Here's the thing, this whole conference argument isn't applicable in today's college football: Cincinnati is as good as any team in the country. So is Boise State. Conferences can still be debated as a whole, but I think the days are long gone where you can use a blanket statement like oh the WAC sucks or the Big Ten or SEC will always win out-of-conference games...cause they don't.

 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


12,798,192+
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Vince Coleman
Billy Hamilton
Ty Cobb
Tim Raines
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PREDICT THE SCORE
Soccer
Cricket
NBA
MLB
NHL
 more

MEET OUR FANS
Jodhvir
Kimberly
 more