Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney

9/19/08
Terrelle Pryor And Todd Boeckman Will Split Snaps Against Troy, But Jim Tressel Should Start Pryor
Why The Buckeyes Should Start Terrelle Pryor For The Rest Of The Season
One of the strange differences between college football and the NFL is that, for the most part, in college, quarterbacks have to produce instantly. Whereas in the NFL, most quarterbacks - especially high draft picks - are afforded some leniency in learning how to the play the game despite making mistakes on the field. Some pro quarterbacks get as many as three full years - or in Eli Manning's case, four - to prove themselves.

There's also probably another reason for this discrepancy as well. Fans, and boosters, of major college football programs don't like watching their team suffer through a 5-7 season while breaking in a new quarterback.

The only problem with that rationale though is that it may seriously hurt a program in the long run.

The reason why I bring this up is because on Saturday, Ohio State plans on splitting snaps between Terrelle Pryor and Todd Boeckman in their game against Troy and that who will start down the line is up in the air.

Anyone who follows college football knows that not only has Boeckman been less than awesome for a while now, but that Pryor is clearly Ohio State's future.

So here's my take. Just start Pryor now, and leave him in as the starter for the rest of the season.

Now, some of you may say, that's absurd, Ohio State should at least ease him to the starting job, and splitting snaps is a good way to do that.

Really? When was the last time you saw an NFL team have their rookie quarterback split snaps with a veteran backup during a single series to ease the rookie in? I don't remember having seen the Ravens do this with Joe Flacco in their first game of the NFL season.

If Ohio State is as committed to Pryor as they seem to be (just like an NFL team to a high draft pick), then it makes sense to just insert him as the starter now - especially against a team like Troy - and let him learn how to play the college game on the field, complete with all the bumps and bruises. And then keep starting him for the rest of the season. Does this mean that Ohio State will lose a few games in the process of Pryor's education? Certainly. But let's be honest here. Ohio State won't be winning the national championship this year. So why not run Pryor through the ringer right now so that by his sophomore year you can be fully confident that he's up to speed with the college game?

To me, if you had an NFL head coach at Ohio State, who wasn't paying attention to fans or boosters, there's no question you'd see Pryor starting this weekend. But unfortunately, Tressel isn't that gutsy. Instead he'll play by the old college rules, which admittedly make no sense.

Sure, I understand Tressel doesn't want to go 8-4 or 7-5 this season, but would one less than stellar season be better for his team and Pryor in the long run? I certainly think so.

Pryor, Boeckman to split snaps [Scout.com]
8 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

9/19/08
2
I'm going to disagree with you on a couple points.

First, I think it's actually the NFL where top draft are expected to produce immediately. At the college level, most of the top prospects come into a good situation where they sit behind an experience QB for a few years. Nothing was expected of Mark Sanchez on day 1.

Then there are those talented enough to be thrown into the mix. Despite my jokes about Jimmy Clausen, he's been given time to produce. Charlie Weis is being patient with him and by year four he'll be an exceptional quarterback.

Whereas in the NFL, if you're a top pick and aren't starting in your one you're automatically labeled a disappointment. Brady Quinn is disappointing. JaMarcus Russell is disappointing. The list goes on. Aaron Rodgers is successful because he's had time to sit back and learn behind Brett Favre, and avoided the pressure of most draft picks.

Secondly, if by Todd Boeckman "has been terrible for some time" means he threw a bad interception against USC last week and LSU last winter, then I agree with you. The guy is not entirely incompetent here and deserves to continue playing.

However, I am 100% behind playing Terrelle Pryor much more than Tressel has, particularly if he can prove to move the ball with his arm. Thus far he hasn't, which is why Boeckman still needs to play. Pryor has 87 yards passing in three games.

Pryor needs to play against Troy, but so does Boeckman. He needs his confidence back up, and the only way Ohio State is winning this year is with downfield passing. They can still split the snaps between both quarterbacks and no hurt their future. Pryor will continue to learn just as much from the sidelines as he will under center.

9/19/08
2
CriticalFanatic wrote:
I'm going to disagree with you on a couple points.

First, I think it's actually the NFL where top draft are expected to produce immediately. At the college level, most of the top prospects come into a good situation where they sit behind an experience QB for a few years. Nothing was expected of Mark Sanchez on day 1.

Then there are those talented enough to be thrown into the mix. Despite my jokes about Jimmy Clausen, he's been given time to produce. Charlie Weis is being patient with him and by year four he'll be an exceptional quarterback.

Whereas in the NFL, if you're a top pick and aren't starting in your one you're automatically labeled a disappointment. Brady Quinn is disappointing. JaMarcus Russell is disappointing. The list goes on. Aaron Rodgers is successful because he's had time to sit back and learn behind Brett Favre, and avoided the pressure of most draft picks.

Secondly, if by Todd Boeckman "has been terrible for some time" means he threw a bad interception against USC last week and LSU last winter, then I agree with you. The guy is not entirely incompetent here and deserves to continue playing.

However, I am 100% behind playing Terrelle Pryor much more than Tressel has, particularly if he can prove to move the ball with his arm. Thus far he hasn't, which is why Boeckman still needs to play. Pryor has 87 yards passing in three games.

Pryor needs to play against Troy, but so does Boeckman. He needs his confidence back up, and the only way Ohio State is winning this year is with downfield passing. They can still split the snaps between both quarterbacks and no hurt their future. Pryor will continue to learn just as much from the sidelines as he will under center.
"Boeckman has been terrible for a long time" means I can't remember the last time he played well. In his last 7 games against legit and semi-legit opponents he's got 6 TD passes and 8 picks. He apparently has trouble throwing touchdowns against teams not named Youngstown State.

9/19/08
2
(Edited by kantwistaye)
If I'm Tressell its Pryor and only Pryor from here on out.  Call passing plays and keep Pryor in the pocket against Troy and allow him to grow as a QB.  The next game after that is Minnesota at home, which should be slightly tougher than Troy but still very easy.  That gives Pryor two relatively easy games as being the man before being thrown into the fire at Madison on national tv (night game on top of that).

9/19/08
2
(Edited by CriticalFanatic)
100%InjuryRate wrote:
"Boeckman has been terrible for a long time" means I can't remember the last time he played well. In his last 7 games against legit and semi-legit opponents he's got 6 TD passes and 8 picks. He apparently has trouble throwing touchdowns against teams not named Youngstown State.
Boeckman best career game was late last October at Penn State, where very few QB's have ever played well. I don't know if you needs stats, but it was far and away his best game and stellar one at that. 3 TD passes, etc.

He actually played OK in the rain storm last November at Michigan, but if we're just look at stats, that won't show.

He has played poorly in the last two big games, so there's that. I wouldn't just flat out leave the guy on the pine though. There's a difference between being terrible and making a bad pass here and there.

9/19/08
3
Ravens and Flacco is a bad comparison.  Who were they gonna have start?  Troy Smith had a tonsil infection and Kyle Boller was IR'd.  I am not sure if Todd Collins ever signed but I 'd still go Flacco over anyone else

9/19/08
0
The Buckeyes have Pryor taking the snaps with the first team this week, so expect a heavy dose v. Troy.  They can say splitting snaps but I expect rotating series to start then Pryor takes over.  The Fans will be calling for Pryor for every game from here on out.

9/19/08
2
I have trouble even giving Boeckman benefit of the doubt, since I think OSU's first two games showed that they looked past their first two opponents - they practiced solely to beat USC, and they managed three measly points!   Boeckman looked like a chicken without its head in that game, and couldn't really seem to do anything right.  That game was basically the OSU season - I imagined that was the majority of summer practice and film study, and Boeckman blew it, simple as that.

9/19/08
2
I agree with derms about the baltimore thing. the ravens had no choice to start flacco. Although I would like to see Pryor play more, I think Boeckman should still be the starter. OSU still has a Big Ten championship to play for, even if it doesn't mean as much now.

 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
NCAAF GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
MEET OUR FANS
Myka
Doreen
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Utah v. Houston
Detroit v. Chicago
New York v. LA
Seattle v. Portland
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
talder joined the Soccer league 2006 World Cup.
Just now!
talder joined the Soccer league Fans of Australia (Soccer).
Just now!
vikaskappana joined the Golf league Tiger Woods Fans.
Just now!
vikaskappana joined the Golf league Golf Fans.
Just now!
jordanmuzio joined the NCAABB league SienaFans(BB).
Just now!
jigar_ezi joined the Tennis league Fans of Sharapova, Maria.
Just now!
jigar_ezi joined the Tennis league Tennis Fans.
Just now!
1 minute ago
hsehmbi joined the Soccer league Barclay's Premiere Fans.
1 minute ago
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help