Tom Coughlin still disputes referees over Victor Cruz’s fumble

11/25/13 in NFL   |   Mia781   |   953 respect

Nov 24, 2013; East Rutherford, NJ, USA; New York Giants wide receiver Victor Cruz (80) reacts after catching a long pass against the Dallas Cowboys during the fourth quarter of a game at MetLife Stadium. The Cowboys defeated the Giants 24-21. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-USA TODAY SportsThe New York Giants were already in a tight contest against the Dallas Cowboys and couldn’t let the Cowboys get another touchdown. Unfortunately, that was what happened 10 minutes into the match when a non offensive touchdown was scored by the Cowboys. To top it off, Giants defence that match wasn’t good and they failed to catch up to the Cowboys, eventually losing the match 21-24.
The play occurred when Giants wide receiver Victor Cruz was on the right sideline and looking to add some yards. Cowboys cornerback Orlando Scandrick tackled him and safety Jeff Heath took control of the ball and scored a touchdown, making it 7-0. That proved to eb the game changer as the Giants tried to recover and came close, but never broke the lead the Cowboys had set.
Giants coach Tom Coughlin is also dissatisfied with the play that set the lead which eventually cost the game and still sticks to his guns that the whistle should have blown to call it off. As the play was folding out, he was continuously gesturing, screaming and finally jumping around in disbelief as the ball made it to the end zone and still no whistle was called.
Following the 21-24 loss, Coughlin said that the whistle should have been blown to call it off.
“For them to have a touchdown on a play like that is, unbelievable,” he said.
The play itself wasn’t easy to judge. The call would have been complicated to make. It was difficult to see whether Cruz was still going for a few more yards or had stopped. Depending on that, the whistle would have been blown or not. Even after watching the replay a few times, it is still tough to say what would have been the right call.
“I don’t know what the officials were … It was four of them battling one guy. He was up in the air,” Coughlin said about the play which set the winning lead for Cowboys. “He’s still spinning and you can look at it either way.”
“We know that we started the year off knowing full well that the officials were going to blow the whistle this season for every play,” Coughlin said. “So you hope that the whistle should blow.”
Cruz was still uncertain if not blowing the whistle was the right call on the referees behalf and thought that it was pretty close.
“I don’t know. It was tough for me. I was just out there making plays. Things happen. When you’re in the moment, you don’t really know what should be called or what happened,” Cruz said. “So it was tough for me to call.”
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine. Preview

11/25/13   |   Pat   |   5232 respect

Unfortunately for Coughlin and the Giants, I think the refs made the right call. It kinda sucks, but Cruz kept making forward progress, so they shouldn't have blown the play dead. If he had let the defenders push him back at all, he would have been ruled down and it wouldn't have been a fumble. Unfortunately, this was a case of too much effort.