Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
1/8/09
Trading Tom Brady And Investing The Future In Matt Cassel Would Work For The New England Patriots
As Zany As It Sounds, Brady Isn't Worth It To The Pats. He Should Be Traded.
There are two things you need to know, and the order of them is vital:

1. I was not dropped on my head as a child.

2. The Patriots need to trade Tom Brady.

This is not a wacky proposition, but it is laden with risk and it is unprecedented.  True, Eric Dickerson, Marshall Faulk, Herschel Walker, and the draft rights to Cannabis Williams were all part of NFL mega deals.  Dickerson and Faulk went on to enjoy great individual success after being traded, whereas Herschel and Ricky became two of the league’s most infamous duds in recent memory.  All of this is immaterial, however.  Consider that these four players are running backs, Faulk was the only one to become a catalyst for a deep playoff run on his new team, and none were coming off of massive surgery prior to their trades.  The NFL has had mega deals, but no such deal has involved a record shattering, Super Bowl winning quarterback in the prime of his career.  To be sure, New England imperils its dynasty by shipping him.  But they could just as easily miss out on the opportunity of the century by doing nothing.

Brady’s shredded knee ligaments leave the Patriots in uncharted territory.  Theismann is an unfair comparison, because he never had the opportunity to rehab.  Carson Palmer is, perhaps, more apropos given the nature of his injury, but his successful recovery, immediate return to top form, and subsequent decline have seemed to be the product of a poorly assembled team and not a poorly assembled leg.  By all accounts, Brady’s injury is worse than Palmer’s.  Palmer rehabbed in his 20s; Brady will not be able to make his return until 32 at best.  In short, Brady’s situation is all his own.  The Pats roll the dice by keeping him.  They roll the dice by dealing him.  It’s a crapshoot either way.

The fact that Matt Cassel proved his worth in such convincing fashion this past year should be enough to convince New England’s top brass to invest the franchise’s future in him.  There is no reason to believe that individual success on this roster is a fluke.  The team is always well-stocked with talent.  The team is always well-coached.  The team has always shown a penchant for unearthing “finds”—it would seem that Cassel is just another.  Will he post positively meteoric stats along the lines of those that Brady registered in ‘07?  Likely not.  Then again, Brady is the only option available to the Patriots that is capable of sniffing them.  The numbers should not be the concern, anyway.  The winning should be the concern.  The economics should be the concern.

With a complete neophyte under center who hadn’t seen a snap since Nickelodeon was actually cool, New England amassed 11 wins and missed the playoffs this year by virtue of a fluke and little else.  That neophyte put up 21 TDs and 11 INTs.  That neophyte completed 64% of his passes and narrowly missed 4,000 yards.  That neophyte is no longer a newbie.  He is a capable starter.  He may never become a Pro Bowler, but the Patriots may never need him to be one.  Keep in mind that the prevalent debate of years past was “Manning vs. Brady,” a.k.a., “Manning’s numbers vs. Brady’s wins.”  It was only in 2007 that Brady emerged as a supreme stat-filler.  Before he was “Brady the Leader” and “Brady the Champion.”  His intangible qualities set him apart.  To be fair, those intangibles may be more important to his team than ever in the coming years.

But according to the Boston Herald, New England is prepared to franchise Cassel for the suggested retail price of $14 million in 2009.  Brady is set to make only a shade more than that amount over the next two seasons.  Although this isn’t “writing on the wall” in any way, it does reflect the need for the Pats to remain ahead of the curve.  Moss and Welker, who form one of the NFL’s top flight receiving duos, each signed contract extensions within the past two years.  Several quarterbacks can make-do with such a tandem.  Cassel, as we have seen, is one of them.  If he can post 24 TDs, 12 INTs and roughly 3,750 yards per season over the course of the next few years, he will have almost done exactly as Brady did in his Super Bowl-winning seasons.  It’s not that unreasonable.

Brady’s contract expires at the end of the 2010 season.  There are multiple teams in the NFL that would jump at the opportunity to acquire him given his relatively modest price tag ($8 million per).  There’s no telling what New England could acquire in a trade, but it’s difficult to imagine a scenario that wouldn’t involve several top draft picks.  We all know what the Pats would do with them—reload and win.  Using the draft effectively is always one of the best ways to ensure that a franchise's stability projects to the future.

Trading Brady makes sense.  And it makes cents.
20 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

1/8/09
5
snbslugger wrote:
I'll take "One year wonders and knee-jerk reactions" for 100, Alex.
Jeopardy! no longer has $100 answers.  The lowest dollar value is $200.

1/8/09
1
If Tom Brady is truly healthy, and will play in 2009, then the Patriots can have the Lions #1 pick...and we will throw in William Clay Ford Sr. and the right's to Matt Millen.

1/8/09
0
Christ you want to trade Tom Brady Bill   pull your head out of your A@@ ok

1/8/09
2
Has Pat seen this article ????

"I'm Pat.....and I approve of this message"        <NOT !!!!>             

1/8/09
3
riwats wrote:
Christ you want to trade Tom Brady Bill   pull your head out of your A@@ ok
Just remember that Brady's knee probably looks like a pile of mangled brains right now.

1/8/09
2
 Let's face it if you saw Cassel and Brady in a passing workout with no names on their jerseys you'd notice one guy was a more athletic and had a slightly stringer arm.  The more physically impressive of the two is Matt Cassel.  The real question is whether Cassel is a Rob Johnson/Scott Mitchell styled mirage or is he more like, oh say,  a 6th round pick from Michigan who had a good but not great college career and blossomed when an injury opened the door for him?  

1/8/09
2
I'll take "One year wonders and knee-jerk reactions" for 100, Alex.

1/8/09
5
snbslugger wrote:
I'll take "One year wonders and knee-jerk reactions" for 100, Alex.
Jeopardy! no longer has $100 answers.  The lowest dollar value is $200.

1/8/09
0
I applaud you for stepping out, Chris.  I would take someone's first round draft pick and give Brady another year.  The Patriots have already proven that they can develop quarterbacks, so there's no need to keep Cassel.  If they deal Cassel, along with the other high draft picks the Pats already have, they'll be in good shape for another Super Bowl appearance next year.

1/8/09
0
Hmmm... Maybe Ed Reed and a first-round pick? Just dreaming. 

1/8/09
0
bennyprofane wrote:
Jeopardy! no longer has $100 answers.  The lowest dollar value is $200.
Shows you how long it's been since I've watched it.

"I'll take famous titties for 800"

1/8/09
0
snbslugger wrote:
Shows you how long it's been since I've watched it.

"I'll take famous titties for 800"
Anal Bum Cover

1/8/09
0
Get off your dadburncottonpickin' meth man there's no way on God's green earth that Brady is going to be traded! Who can be dadburncottonpickin' stupid enough to trade a future HOF? The team needs Brady. If he is traded, Pats fans would scream dadburncottonpickin' bloody murder and call for Kraft's head! Trading Brady? Are you dadburncottonpickin' kidding me???

1/8/09
1
MrNFL wrote:
Anal Bum Cover
FEBTOBER!

1/8/09
0
Just the way coach BB likes 'em!  

1/8/09
0
(Edited by kawazr7000)
The question isn't "is Cassel as good as Brady". We all know the answer to that. The question is, how far could the Pats go with Cassel, a major DB upgrade, some extra draft picks and a resurgent rushing attack? vs. Will Brady ever play or be the same again?

1/8/09
1
With Cassel at the helm and the upgrades they'll receive for the massive price of Tom Brady, shoots them right back into the Super Bowl.

1/9/09
0
snbslugger wrote:
FEBTOBER!
The day is mine, Trebek!

 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
NFL GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
NFL TICKETS
Loading...
MEET OUR FANS
Jodhvir
Kimberly
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Detroit v. Chicago
Seattle v. Portland
New York v. LA
Utah v. Houston
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
cpowers joined the Fishing league the test.
Just now!
javkha4 joined the Soccer league 2006 World Cup.
Just now!
javkha4 joined the Soccer league Fans of France (Soccer).
Just now!
javkha4 joined the Soccer league Barclay's Premiere Fans.
Just now!
shrenikshah18 joined the Cricket league Fans of India.
Just now!
shrenikshah18 joined the Cricket league CricketFans.
Just now!
javkha4 joined the Soccer league Arsenal Fans.
Just now!
javkha4 joined the Soccer league MLS Fans.
Just now!
javkha4 joined the Soccer league Los Angeles Fans (MLS).
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help