Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney

10/9/09
Umpire CB Bucknor And No Offense Led To Red Sox Loss
The Umpiring Was Terrible, But The Red Sox Have Their Offense To Blame For The Loss
If you watched Game 1 of the ALDS between the Red Sox and Angels, you probably are well aware that 1st base umpire CB Bucknor was pretty much terrible. In the play in the picture to the right, Bucknor called Howie Kendrick safe.

That's not the only play Bucknor blatantly screwed up. There's really no reason he should ever be umpiring a playoff game, and this game was proof of that.

Check out the animated gif of a play that was called an error on Red Sox shortstop Alex Gonzalez:

As you can see, Kendrick was tagged out in this one as well. Of course, despite having a perfect angle on the play, Bucknor missed the call, and called Kendrick safe.

As bad as the umpiring was, however, the Red Sox can't really blame them for their loss. In the end, the Sox scored zero runs. I don't know about you, but I've never seen a team win a game without scoring a single run.

If the Red Sox want to salvage a split in Anaheim, they'll need to bring their bats to Game 2 against Jered Weaver. The umpires can do whatever they want, but if the Sox only manage to get 4 hits, they'll probably lose again.
16 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

10/9/09
1
 If they can hit the ball and he dosn't ump again the sox should be okay


10/9/09
1
bo sox fans wasnt saying that the last series when they had the angels at home  umps made up

10/9/09
2
(Edited by spinalzo)
Joe West was behind the plate and if I am not mistaken, he would be the crew chief for this group as he is one of, if not, THE senior umps out there.  That jamoke should have found a tactful way to override ol' CB on the second, BLATANT, screw-up but ol' JW ain't got a tactful bone in his body and is firmly entrenched in the Umpire Old School of the umps against the world.
I thought that the umps were "awarded" post season play as a result of a stringent rating system.  Apparently, that is all show and no go like the NFL steroid program.
Also, I think that this is clearly a matter for the Commish to invoke the "best interest of the game" clause and jack CB's sorry butt outta there for the remainder of the play-offs regardless of any hissy-fit the Umps Union might (nay, most definitely will) make.  But we ain't got a real commissioner, do we?

10/9/09
1
They may want to see if that ump has money on the series, hate to bring up Donahy, but hay... Blatant calls like that do make you say - hmmmmmm.!!!!

10/9/09
0
I hate it when bad calls happen - but especially during the postseason - hopefully the BoSox can recover and take care of business in Game 2

10/9/09
0
A few bad calls are part of the game, but blatent ones are not.  Finally my Halos got a win, but if the blatent calls disappear and the Sox start playing well i think the Sox would win the series.  These blatent calls did not change the game in favor of the Angels so the calls are not too bad.  But they do need to be eliminated, but there are always bad calls.

10/9/09
0
spinalzo wrote:
Joe West was behind the plate and if I am not mistaken, he would be the crew chief for this group as he is one of, if not, THE senior umps out there.  That jamoke should have found a tactful way to override ol' CB on the second, BLATANT, screw-up but ol' JW ain't got a tactful bone in his body and is firmly entrenched in the Umpire Old School of the umps against the world.
I thought that the umps were "awarded" post season play as a result of a stringent rating system.  Apparently, that is all show and no go like the NFL steroid program.
Also, I think that this is clearly a matter for the Commish to invoke the "best interest of the game" clause and jack CB's sorry butt outta there for the remainder of the play-offs regardless of any hissy-fit the Umps Union might (nay, most definitely will) make.  But we ain't got a real commissioner, do we?
Correct!

10/9/09
0
I definitely agree, and some guys might approach their at bat different if they're only down by 1 or 2 runs, as opposed to 5. But at the same time, zero runs is zero runs. Calls like this are out of you their control. Hitting the baseball, on the other hand, is something that the Red Sox could have (and should have) done better.

10/9/09
0
maybe they were flustered after a few bad calls?

10/9/09
0
the angels have been the victims of bad calls the past years in the playoffs that have changed the game and some series so boston fans crying over 1 bad call that had nothing to do with the outcome is crazy lackey pitched a great game and boston could not hit the broad side of a barn last night still believe winning game one will be big for the halos and hopefully we can go back to boston up 2 games to 0 .... GO ANGELS!!!!!

10/9/09
0
packersangels wrote:
the angels have been the victims of bad calls the past years in the playoffs that have changed the game and some series so boston fans crying over 1 bad call that had nothing to do with the outcome is crazy lackey pitched a great game and boston could not hit the broad side of a barn last night still believe winning game one will be big for the halos and hopefully we can go back to boston up 2 games to 0 .... GO ANGELS!!!!!
That's 2 bad calls... but let's not let facts get in the way of your little rant.

10/9/09
1
daytonfly2 wrote:
A few bad calls are part of the game, but blatent ones are not.  Finally my Halos got a win, but if the blatent calls disappear and the Sox start playing well i think the Sox would win the series.  These blatent calls did not change the game in favor of the Angels so the calls are not too bad.  But they do need to be eliminated, but there are always bad calls.
uhmm... the first bad call lead to a 2-out 3-run blast to center... so are you sure? The inning would have closed 0-0, that seems like a favoring to an Angel victory. 0-0... 3-0... that is a big difference.

10/9/09
0
definitely he need glasses,  terrible night  for the Red Sox, hope tonite is different and better umpires.

10/13/09
0
Pat wrote:
That's 2 bad calls... but let's not let facts get in the way of your little rant.
guess it dose not really matter since the angels sweeped them

10/13/09
0
packersangels wrote:
guess it dose not really matter since the angels sweeped them
Swept. The word you're looking for is "swept".

 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
MLB GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
MLB TICKETS
Loading...
MEET OUR FANS
Doreen
Kimberly
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Detroit v. Chicago
New York v. LA
Seattle v. Portland
Utah v. Houston
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
cherrynaadja joined the NCAAF league MountainWestFans.
Just now!
cherrynaadja joined the NCAAF league WyomingFans(FB).
Just now!
sathyasai993 joined the Cricket league Fans of England.
Just now!
sathyasai993 joined the Cricket league CricketFans.
Just now!
sathyasai993 joined the Cricket league Fans of New Zealand.
Just now!
sathyasai993 joined the Cricket league CricketFans.
Just now!
sathyasai993 joined the Cricket league Fans of South Africa.
Just now!
sathyasai993 joined the Cricket league CricketFans.
Just now!
sathyasai993 joined the Cricket league Fans of Australia.
Just now!
sathyasai993 joined the Cricket league CricketFans.
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help