Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
6/28/09
What Is Shaquille O'Neal's Legacy?
What Will Shaq's Legacy Be?
As you're probably well aware of, Shaq is now officially a Cavalier. The thought, at least on the Cavs' end, is that Shaq is the missing piece to the puzzle that can help LeBron win a championship.

As Deadspin points out, Shaq in recent years has become a big-man gun-for-hire, teaming up with Dwyane Wade for a championship in Miami, and trying to help a Suns team before they fell off a cliff. But it hasn't always been this way.

Shaq was the man in Orlando, and for the majority of his tenure in LA, he was the man there as well. Those teams were built around him, they didn't bring him in as some kind of stop-gap. The three NBA championships Shaq won with the Lakers, he was unquestionably the best player on two of those teams, and probably equal to Kobe in the third and final one.

But since Kobe pushed Shaq out of LA (this was primarily Kobe's fault, you'll never be able to convince me otherwise), Shaq has been turned into the missing link to take a team over the hump, even though he clearly isn't the player he used to be.

When the Miami Heat won the NBA championship in 2006, it was clear Shaq was the difference in pushing them to it. But he wasn't the best player on the team. That was Dwyane Wade. And to anyone who knows anything about basketball, it'll be readily apparent that Shaq won't be the best player on the Cavs either. That's easily LeBron James.

So what are we to make of all this? And how does this define Shaq's legacy? Even if Shaq wins a championship with LeBron and the Cavs, do we start to view Shaq as the guy who simply hopped around teams later on in his career to grab some more rings?

I'm not really sure Shaq cares anymore at this point in time. At 37, I think he's highly aware that his best days are behind him. He's all right with not being the best player on the team, or even the first option, just so long as he can make a large enough difference to push that team to a championship. And truthfully, I think that shows a rather high level of maturity. Some players never can get over the fact that they are no longer as great as they once were. You wonder if players like Wade, Kobe and LeBron will ever be able to deal with being a second banana some day.

Personally, I'll remember Shaq as one of the greatest players I ever saw play, but also as a guy who was able to make a successful career transition as well - all while still remaining a huge draw for the NBA. That's not nearly as easy to do as you'd think. Should he have won more NBA championships than he has? Yes, if he and Kobe had stayed together, no question. But he's done well enough outside of that relationship that it's not really worth much debate anymore.

The only real question now is, can he win one more? I don't know, but it'll be interesting to watch.

Shaq: Best Big Man Ever Or Perpetual Second Banana? [
Deadspin]
26 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

6/29/09
7
lleedubb wrote:
I LOVE SHAQ TO DEATH PEOPLE BUT TRUTH BE TOLD, HE WAS ONLY THE BEST PLAYER ON HIS CHAMPIONSHIP TEAMS TWO TIMES, KOBE WAS CLEARLY THE BEST PLAYER IN THE LEAGUE BY THE TIME THEY WERE ON RING NO. 3 , AND ALWAYS HAD THE BALL IN THE FOURTH(SEE GAMES 5& 6 IN THE FINALS AGAINST THE PACERS!!)  WADE WAS THE BEST IN MIAMI,  AND IF YOU CHECK STATS ,SHAQ AVERAGED BARELY 10 AND 7.  GO BACK AND WATCH 'ZO AND TELL ME WHO WAS MORE VALUEABLE.  HE'S CLEARLY BEEN CHASING NBA RINGS.  BUT I AINT MAD AT HIM,HE HAD A HELLAVA SEASON LAST YEAR AND MIGHT   GET ANOTHER ONE MESSIN' WITH THE KING!!
QUITE FRANKLY THAT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT THING SAID ABOUT SHAQUILLE O'NEAL EVER!

6/29/09
5
I LOVE SHAQ TO DEATH PEOPLE BUT TRUTH BE TOLD, HE WAS ONLY THE BEST PLAYER ON HIS CHAMPIONSHIP TEAMS TWO TIMES, KOBE WAS CLEARLY THE BEST PLAYER IN THE LEAGUE BY THE TIME THEY WERE ON RING NO. 3 , AND ALWAYS HAD THE BALL IN THE FOURTH(SEE GAMES 5& 6 IN THE FINALS AGAINST THE PACERS!!)  WADE WAS THE BEST IN MIAMI,  AND IF YOU CHECK STATS ,SHAQ AVERAGED BARELY 10 AND 7.  GO BACK AND WATCH 'ZO AND TELL ME WHO WAS MORE VALUEABLE.  HE'S CLEARLY BEEN CHASING NBA RINGS.  BUT I AINT MAD AT HIM,HE HAD A HELLAVA SEASON LAST YEAR AND MIGHT   GET ANOTHER ONE MESSIN' WITH THE KING!!

6/29/09
5
Shaq's legacy?  The most dominant player ever within 4 or 5 feet of the hoop and completely worthless outside of that.

6/29/09
7
lleedubb wrote:
I LOVE SHAQ TO DEATH PEOPLE BUT TRUTH BE TOLD, HE WAS ONLY THE BEST PLAYER ON HIS CHAMPIONSHIP TEAMS TWO TIMES, KOBE WAS CLEARLY THE BEST PLAYER IN THE LEAGUE BY THE TIME THEY WERE ON RING NO. 3 , AND ALWAYS HAD THE BALL IN THE FOURTH(SEE GAMES 5& 6 IN THE FINALS AGAINST THE PACERS!!)  WADE WAS THE BEST IN MIAMI,  AND IF YOU CHECK STATS ,SHAQ AVERAGED BARELY 10 AND 7.  GO BACK AND WATCH 'ZO AND TELL ME WHO WAS MORE VALUEABLE.  HE'S CLEARLY BEEN CHASING NBA RINGS.  BUT I AINT MAD AT HIM,HE HAD A HELLAVA SEASON LAST YEAR AND MIGHT   GET ANOTHER ONE MESSIN' WITH THE KING!!
QUITE FRANKLY THAT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT THING SAID ABOUT SHAQUILLE O'NEAL EVER!

6/29/09
4
I don't think so. I think he is such a dominant player in the league that he will be remembered for his size and personal appeal. Obviously he is a good player, but he also has a flair for dealing with the public. This will endear him to fans and bring him accolades when he is through. I like him. He's a real character.

6/29/09
1
Kobe Bryant... He would have never gotten this far without Shaq! And Kobe is still not as good, gracious or as humble as Shaq!

6/29/09
1
Misb44 wrote:
Kobe Bryant... He would have never gotten this far without Shaq! And Kobe is still not as good, gracious or as humble as Shaq!
how r u?? kobe is the BEST":)

6/29/09
1
(Edited by djjfrench)
Simple...Winner. Dominant.  Champion. Entertainer.

6/29/09
0
Yes offcourse and in the first place he is making money for a living

6/29/09
0
whaah! this season, we'll see hus the best teamate 4 shaq... first, KOBE, then WAdE and Now, KiNg JaMeS.. I ThInK ShaQ WiLl HaVe MuCh BeTTeR SeAsOn ThIs ComMing 09-10 season...

6/29/09
0
lleedubb wrote:
I LOVE SHAQ TO DEATH PEOPLE BUT TRUTH BE TOLD, HE WAS ONLY THE BEST PLAYER ON HIS CHAMPIONSHIP TEAMS TWO TIMES, KOBE WAS CLEARLY THE BEST PLAYER IN THE LEAGUE BY THE TIME THEY WERE ON RING NO. 3 , AND ALWAYS HAD THE BALL IN THE FOURTH(SEE GAMES 5& 6 IN THE FINALS AGAINST THE PACERS!!)  WADE WAS THE BEST IN MIAMI,  AND IF YOU CHECK STATS ,SHAQ AVERAGED BARELY 10 AND 7.  GO BACK AND WATCH 'ZO AND TELL ME WHO WAS MORE VALUEABLE.  HE'S CLEARLY BEEN CHASING NBA RINGS.  BUT I AINT MAD AT HIM,HE HAD A HELLAVA SEASON LAST YEAR AND MIGHT   GET ANOTHER ONE MESSIN' WITH THE KING!!
i like shaq,but next year i think that he will retire,.because he is old now,i think

6/29/09
0
sixteen1twenty wrote:
whaah! this season, we'll see hus the best teamate 4 shaq... first, KOBE, then WAdE and Now, KiNg JaMeS.. I ThInK ShaQ WiLl HaVe MuCh BeTTeR SeAsOn ThIs ComMing 09-10 season...
shaq he is a very good player,i like him,but  now he is old now,

6/29/09
0
sabers wrote:
how r u?? kobe is the BEST":)
ur ryt,kobe s d bst

6/29/09
0
shaq & lebron,nice team mate,

6/29/09
1
i love lakers.....

6/29/09
0
i am the fan of la lakers

6/29/09
2
SHAQ WILL GO DOWN AS ONE OF THE BEST PLAYERS TO HAVE EVER PLAYED THE GAME SIMPLE AS THAT.

6/29/09
1
hi this is om

6/29/09
1
kantwistaye wrote:
Shaq's legacy?  The most dominant player ever within 4 or 5 feet of the hoop and completely worthless outside of that.
I have to completely agree. Nobody has ever been so dominant inside, yet, so worthless outside 5 feet.

Personally, I always preferred the game of guys like Olajuwon,Robinson, and Ewing.

6/29/09
1
Maybe post-retirement he will market a new candy bar called "My Azz" so he can ask everyone how his azz taste?

6/29/09
0
lleedubb wrote:
I LOVE SHAQ TO DEATH PEOPLE BUT TRUTH BE TOLD, HE WAS ONLY THE BEST PLAYER ON HIS CHAMPIONSHIP TEAMS TWO TIMES, KOBE WAS CLEARLY THE BEST PLAYER IN THE LEAGUE BY THE TIME THEY WERE ON RING NO. 3 , AND ALWAYS HAD THE BALL IN THE FOURTH(SEE GAMES 5& 6 IN THE FINALS AGAINST THE PACERS!!)  WADE WAS THE BEST IN MIAMI,  AND IF YOU CHECK STATS ,SHAQ AVERAGED BARELY 10 AND 7.  GO BACK AND WATCH 'ZO AND TELL ME WHO WAS MORE VALUEABLE.  HE'S CLEARLY BEEN CHASING NBA RINGS.  BUT I AINT MAD AT HIM,HE HAD A HELLAVA SEASON LAST YEAR AND MIGHT   GET ANOTHER ONE MESSIN' WITH THE KING!!
Shaq's almost 10 yrs older than Kobe too.  If Kobe wasn't such a bif ball hog, and cry baby Shaq may have never left the team..  I guess we would have found out then who's the best huh?  Shaq's the best NO MATTER where they put him, or what team he plays for...  Can Kobe say the same???

6/29/09
0
(Edited by robertmalbrough)
radioatka3 wrote:
I don't think so. I think he is such a dominant player in the league that he will be remembered for his size and personal appeal. Obviously he is a good player, but he also has a flair for dealing with the public. This will endear him to fans and bring him accolades when he is through. I like him. He's a real character.
I luv him too, but he has no damn character, he has a history of doing things, behind the scenes, and until recently he has demanded to be the man, but really he's been reading his own clippings to much, without as he puts it, that 2nd fiddle, he would never have had a championship, it was Kobe & D Wade, who actually lead the way to the Diamonds, he's a great player, but by never staying in shape year round, deciding to have surgery within a month of the season starting, that was just plain old selfish of him, he showed no leadership, so why look upon him as if he did, he did very good granted, but he forced himself out of L.A & Miami. now he's riding the coattails of LeBronze, cause he'll never get that ring with them together, why put a Ferrari & an old broken down wreck together? I think they will finish further out of the East, then they think.

6/29/09
1
After what Kobe and his teammates have done, Shaq will return to Lakers. Now you see, Kobe and Shaq are friends again. With Shaq Lakers will have another championship
 

6/29/09
1
sixteen1twenty wrote:
whaah! this season, we'll see hus the best teamate 4 shaq... first, KOBE, then WAdE and Now, KiNg JaMeS.. I ThInK ShaQ WiLl HaVe MuCh BeTTeR SeAsOn ThIs ComMing 09-10 season...
Honey could you speak english please???  I'm old and can't figure all that who ha you just blurbed all over the page.  Thank you

6/29/09
1
Shaqs legacy will be great player, but big mouth

6/29/09
1
Its funny that people still think Kobe "pushed" Shaq out of LA. Where as it was Shaq who pushed himself out. He demanded a contract extension, Ran down the court during a preseason game yelling at the owner, Dr Buss, who was in attendance for that game to "pay me!"  while rubbing his fingers together signifying more money, added to the fact he never came into training camp in shape. Not really demostratiing a desire to stay with the team. It was his statement that the Lakers " didn't need his services anymore"

6/29/09
2

I think he will be remembered as being a force of nature and a master showman. His current vagabond ways and his current track record of throwing people under the bus may tarnish it a shade, but he will be remember as one of the greats. 

Yeah I have some qualms with Shaq, but I will get over them and remember the man who was MVP and won three titles for the Lakers.


6/29/09
3
Aren't all basketball players "Big Men For Hire?"

6/29/09
0
sixteen1twenty wrote:
whaah! this season, we'll see hus the best teamate 4 shaq... first, KOBE, then WAdE and Now, KiNg JaMeS.. I ThInK ShaQ WiLl HaVe MuCh BeTTeR SeAsOn ThIs ComMing 09-10 season...
duh..

6/29/09
0
If Shaq and Lebron dont get a ring this year, then its no hope for the Cavs and Lebron will definitely bounce his way out of  Cleveland to another team.. and Shaq, well he'll just be a has been..

6/29/09
0
Shaq will go down as one of the greatest centers of all time...and a decent comedian as well.

6/29/09
0
He will not go down as beasketball's greatest film presence. Kazaam!!!

6/29/09
0
He'll be remembered as a dominant player, but I think that will ultimately be outshined by other things. He's been strangely petty and ungracious at times, plus he'll  be a rent-a-Shaq for longer than a member of a team that was built around him. No doubt he's a legend and a hall of famer, but certain players get more respect because they stayed with a team and evolved and made it work. Hakeem, Russell, Wilt...

 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
NBA GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
MEET OUR FANS
Jodhvir
Myka
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
Utah v. Houston
New York v. LA
Detroit v. Chicago
Seattle v. Portland
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
nabnit007 joined the Formula One league Fans of Lewis Hamilton.
Just now!
nabnit007 joined the Formula One league Formula One Fans.
Just now!
ashiq_for_ashiqi joined the Soccer league 2006 World Cup.
Just now!
Just now!
debcocoa chest bumped Bronco_Fan_Man
Just now!
debcocoa chest bumped sactownhero
Just now!
debcocoa high fived sactownhero
Just now!
debcocoa chest bumped sactownhero
Just now!
Just now!
pushmipullu joined the Martial Arts league Fans of Aikido.
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help