Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
3/30/08
Who is the Greatest...NFL Coach?
As you can probably tell from the blogs that I've already written on this subject (which are below), my philosophy is to write about the easy picks first. And the topic of the greatest NFL coach starts and ends with one name: Bill Walsh.

Even though they aren't as important with Walsh, I'll give you the accolades:

- 3-time Super Bowl champion (XVI, XIX, XXII)
- 3 NFC championship titles
- 1981 coach of the Year (NFL, Sporting News, Pro Football Weekly, UPI); 1984 Coach of the Year (UPI)
- 102-63-1 overall record (92-59-1 regular season, 10-4 postseason)



But the real story with Walsh is the coaching tree. It's just incredible how many coaches have some sort of connection to the legendary coach from the Niners. The reason that Walsh had such a wide reach is because of the fact that he always had fresh, young assistants. He didn't keep the same assistants for years and years, which would have led his system to get old. Some even say that Bill Belichick has a similar system and philosophy, and that it will lead him to have a legacy on the level of Walsh. In pro football coaching, that is the greatest compliment that one can receive.

The Bill Walsh coaching tree can be found here, but I'll break it down for you right now (coaches in blod are first generation, red is the second generation and green is the third generation). Six current or former coaches have direct links to Walsh, which means that they were his assistants; they are Mike Holmgren, Jim Fassel, Paul Hackett, Sam Wyche, George Seifert, Dennis Green. From the Holmgren branch are Mike Sherman, Andy Reid (Brad Childress), Ray Rhodes, and Steve Mariucci (Marty Mornhinwheg). John Fox is on the Jim Fassel branch. Paul Hackett has added Mike McCarthy and John Gruden (Bill Callahan). Sam Wyche contributed Mike Mularky and Bruce Coslet. George Seifert had Mike Shanahan (Gary Kubiak) and Jeff Fisher as assistants. But the Denny Green branch is the really impressive one: Brian Billick (Jack Del Rio), Tony Dungy (Lovie Smith, Mike Tomlin, Rod Marinelli), and Mike Tice (Scott Linehan) were all his assistants. In case you weren't counting, that's 28 head coaches with some sort of connection to Bill Walsh!

The other thing that you have to talk about when you mention Walsh is the West Coast Offense. This offense, developed by Walsh, focuses on short screen passes, quick slants, and zone blocking. Every team in the NFL today runs at least part of its offense this way, and the fact that it keeps evolving is one of the ways to tell how great it is.

Basically, the legacy of Walsh is what sets him apart from others. He was a helluva coach, but he was an even better teacher. Let the discussion begin.

Others might say:

2. George Halas - Sure, the "Papa Bear" was the most beloved man to ever be part of the NFL, but that doesn't make him number one on my list. He was an amazing coach for 40 years with the Bears, and the fact that he also owned and played for the Bears means that I hope no Bears fans are reading this blog. Trust me, I thought about making him number one.

3. Chuck Noll - I hate the Steelers. I hate Chuck Noll. But I also respecthttp://www.sportingnews.com/post/
Sporting News - Your expert source for MLB Baseball, NFL Football, NBA Basketball, NHL Hockey, NCAA Football, NCAA Basketball and Fantasy Sports scores, blogs, and articles
Chuck Noll. He never gets the credit that he deserves outside of Pittsburgh, but he was a great coach. I can't deny that, and neither should anybody else. He won four Super Bowls in four years and was a great evaluator of talent. Nothing more needs to be said.

4. Paul Brown - It would have been easy, seeing as how I am sometimes called an "Ohio homer," to pick Brown for my top spot. Brown designed the coaching position as we know it today (with a full-time, year-round staff and college scouting), and he contributed not one, but two teams to the NFL (Browns and Bengals).

5. Vince Lombardi - Yeah, yeah. Lombardi equals excellence. Lombardi won the first Super Bowl. Lombardi got the trophy named after him. He's a legend in Green Bay. That gets him the number five spot on my list.

Other Sports

CBB Player - Lew Alcindor
CBB Coach - John Wooden
6 comments
Vote!
Comment!
Your votes determine top comment

3/31/08
0
Belichick should at least be on the list. His accomplishments are right up there with any of these guys.

3/31/08
1
Pat wrote:
Belichick should at least be on the list. His accomplishments are right up there with any of these guys.
Not necessarily disagreeing, but you have to admit that a lot of people are going to withhold judgement on his legacy until this whole Spygate thing plays out.

3/31/08
0
kantwistaye wrote:
Not necessarily disagreeing, but you have to admit that a lot of people are going to withhold judgement on his legacy until this whole Spygate thing plays out.
I agree 1000 percent.

3/31/08
1

John Madden, 103-32-7, in 10 seasons. Won one Super Bowl .763 winning percentage. About the only knock against him, is the post season, with several curious calls against the team....ie, Immaculate reception, the Bob Lytle fumble against Denver.

7 Division Championships, 1 AFC Championship, and put in the groundwork for future wins, in 1980, and 1983.

Oh, and only 71 games over .500 any questions?


4/1/08
0
Pat wrote:
Belichick should at least be on the list. His accomplishments are right up there with any of these guys.
LMAO....the other guys up there never cheated. bellicheat couldnt hold a candle to any of these coaches...

4/1/08
0

Air out one more comment, on this, that is pretty obvious.

A lot of the discussion will come down to balancing out things. If you base it off wins, you have Shula. If you base it off the super bowl, you have Chuck Noll. If you base it off of percentages, you have Guy Chamberlain, who only coached 6 seasons, just ahead of Madden, with 10.

And even then, you've got guys who built up titles, like Paul Brown, who only had 7 titles, before the Super Bowl came along.

The fun part, is trying to get everyone to decide, out of these guys, does wins mean more than super bowls? Does winning a lot mean more than longevity?

How about the length of service, with Shula sticking around until the cheese went bad?

It'll make for a lot of aguments. But hey.....it's all for the fun of our sport.


 
Notify me by email about comments that follow mine.
Preview


BEST OF THE WEB
SHOP
NFL GEAR
Reebok NFL Equipment New E..
$79.95
New Era New York Yankees N..
$33.95
adidas Los Angeles Lakers ..
$24.95
NFL TICKETS
Loading...
MEET OUR FANS
Narada
Kimberly
 more
12,798,192+
ANSWER TODAY'S POLL
 more
PLAY NEVER-ENDING TRIVIA
New York v. LA
Seattle v. Portland
Utah v. Houston
Detroit v. Chicago
 more

TAKE A QUIZ
 more

PREDICT THE SCORE
NFL
NBA
NHL
NCAABB
Soccer
 more
2,555,658+
Just now!
marcus_nyce answered the poll Word Association.
Just now!
asap1995 joined the NCAABB league SECFans(BB).
Just now!
asap1995 joined the NCAABB league Big Blue Nation.
Just now!
diggydawg7 high fived nena4j
Just now!
diggydawg7 celebrated with indiagirl97
Just now!
sosa commented on Dodge#9's poll Thong of the Day 11/23/09.
Just now!
wani_junpyo joined the Cricket league Fans of New Zealand.
Just now!
wani_junpyo joined the Cricket league CricketFans.
Just now!
 

Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help