| Rank | Correct Answer | 134 Fans | Pts | 26 Experts | Pts |
| 1. | Greg Oden (C), Ohio State | Greg Oden (C), Ohio State | 2.9 | Greg Oden (C), Ohio State | 3.0 |
| 2. | Kevin Durant, (SF), Texas | Kevin Durant, (SF), Texas | 2.9 | Kevin Durant, (SF), Texas | 3.0 |
| 3. | Al Horford, (PF), Florida | Al Horford, (PF), Florida | 2.2 | Al Horford, (PF), Florida | 2.6 |
| 4. | Mike Conley, (PG), Ohio State | Mike Conley, (PG), Ohio State | 1.7 | Mike Conley, (PG), Ohio State | 2.0 |
| 5. | Jeff Green, (SF), Georgetown | Corey Brewer, (SG), Florida | 1.7 | Brandan Wright, (PF), North Carolina | 1.3 |
| 6. | Yi Jianlian, (PF), China | Yi Jianlian, (PF), China | 1.3 | Joakim Noah, (PF), Florida | 1.4 |
| 7. | Corey Brewer, (SG), Florida | Brandan Wright, (PF), North Carolina | 0.8 | Corey Brewer, (SG), Florida | 1.8 |
| 8. | Brandan Wright, (PF), North Carolina | Joakim Noah, (PF), Florida | 1.4 | Yi Jianlian, (PF), China | 1.0 |
| 9. | Joakim Noah, (PF), Florida | Jeff Green, (SF), Georgetown | 0.8 | Jeff Green, (SF), Georgetown | 1.1 |
| 10. | Spencer Hawes, (C), Washington | Julian Wright (SF), Kansas | 0.5 | Spencer Hawes, (C), Washington | 1.3 |
| 11. | Acie Law (PG), Texas A&M | Acie Law (PG), Texas A&M | 1.3 | Al Thornton, (SF), Florida State | 1.2 |
| 12. | Thaddeus Young, (SF), Georgia Tech | Al Thornton, (SF), Florida State | 0.9 | Acie Law (PG), Texas A&M | 1.9 |
| 13. | Julian Wright (SF), Kansas | Spencer Hawes, (C), Washington | 1.2 | Julian Wright (SF), Kansas | 0.7 |
| 14. | Al Thornton, (SF), Florida State | Nick Young, (SG), USC | 0.6 | Nick Young, (SG), USC | 0.3 |
| 15. | Rodney Stuckey, (SG), Eastern Washington | Thaddeus Young, (SF), Georgia Tech | 0.5 | Javaris Crittenton, (PG), Georgia Tech | 0.8 |
| 16. | Nick Young, (SG), USC | Javaris Crittenton, (PG), Georgia Tech | 0.5 | Thaddeus Young, (SF), Georgia Tech | 0.4 |
| 17. | Sean Williams, (C), Boston College | Josh McRoberts, (PF), Duke | 0.0 | Rodney Stuckey, (SG), Eastern Washington | 1.7 |
| 18. | Marco Belinelli, (SG), Italy | Jason Smith (PF), Colorado State | 0.7 | Jason Smith (PF), Colorado State | 0.4 |
| 19. | Javaris Crittenton, (PG), Georgia Tech | Rodney Stuckey, (SG), Eastern Washington | 1.5 | Josh McRoberts, (PF), Duke | 0.0 |
| 20. | Jason Smith (PF), Colorado State | Tiago Splitter, (PF), Brazil | 0.5 | Tiago Splitter, (PF), Brazil | 0.3 |
| 21. | Daequan Cook, (SG), Ohio State | Daequan Cook, (SG), Ohio State | 1.1 | Rudy Fernandez, (SG), Spain | 0.8 |
| 22. | Jared Dudley, (SF), Boston College | Rudy Fernandez, (SG), Spain | 0.5 | Derrick Byars, (SF), Vanderbilt | 0.0 |
| 23. | Wilson Chandler, (SF), DePaul | Marco Belinelli, (SG), Italy | 0.2 | Sean Williams, (C), Boston College | 1.1 |
| 24. | Rudy Fernandez, (SG), Spain | Derrick Byars, (SF), Vanderbilt | 0.0 | Morris Almond (SG), Rice | 1.2 |
| 25. | Morris Almond (SG), Rice | Arron Afflalo, (SG), UCLA | 0.8 | Marco Belinelli, (SG), Italy | 0.3 |
| 26. | Other Player Not on list (Pick 1) | Sean Williams, (C), Boston College | 0.7 | Daequan Cook, (SG), Ohio State | 0.9 |
| 27. | Arron Afflalo, (SG), UCLA | Alando Tucker, (SF), Wisconsin | 0.4 | Wilson Chandler, (SF), DePaul | 2.6 |
| 28. | Tiago Splitter, (PF), Brazil | Glen Davis, (PF), LSU | 0.0 | Gabe Pruitt, (PG), USC | 0.0 |
| 29. | Alando Tucker, (SF), Wisconsin | Morris Almond (SG), Rice | 0.9 | Other Player Not on list (Pick 1) | 0.6 |
| 30. | Other Player Not on list (Pick 2) | Aaron Gray (C), Pittsburgh | 0.0 | Glen Davis, (PF), LSU | 0.0 |
| Also receiving votes: | Nick Fazekas, (PF), Nevada | | Marcus Williams, (SF), Arizona | |
Gabe Pruitt, (PG), USC | | Nick Fazekas, (PF), Nevada | | Marc Gasol, (C), Spain [Pau Gasol's brother] | | Alando Tucker, (SF), Wisconsin | | Wilson Chandler, (SF), DePaul | | Jared Dudley, (SF), Boston College | | Jared Dudley, (SF), Boston College | | Arron Afflalo, (SG), UCLA | | Marcus Williams, (SF), Arizona | | Other Player Not on list (Pick 2) | | Taurean Green, (PG), Florida | | Marc Gasol, (C), Spain [Pau Gasol's brother] | | Other Player Not on list (Pick 1) | | DeVon Hardin, (C), California | | Demetris Nichols, (SF), Syracuse | | Taurean Green, (PG), Florida | | DeVon Hardin, (C), California | | Other Player Not on list (Pick 3) | | Kyrylo Fesenko, (PF), Ukraine | | Aaron Gray (C), Pittsburgh | | Renaldas Seibutis, (SG), Lithuania | | Dominic McGuire, (SF), Fresno State | | Jared Jordan, (PG), Marist | | Kyrylo Fesenko, (PF), Ukraine | | Other Player Not on list (Pick 2) | | Other Player Not on list (Pick 4) | | Zabian Dowdell, (PG), Virginia Tech | | | Dominic McGuire, (SF), Fresno State | | | Ali Traore, (PF), France | | | Other Player Not on list (Pick 3) | | | Trey Johnson, (SG), Jackson State | | | Other Player Not on list (Pick 4) | | |