Is this fantasy trade fair?

You Might Like

Asked By: blipper21

Who liked it? 9

Peytonrob (+)
Indianapolis Colts

msyroka3 (+)
Oakland Raiders

alsp1958 (+)
New England Patriots

donm454 (+)
Philadelphia Eagles

YankeeDudeL (+)
New York Giants

sueram (+)
New York Giants

EdSpeshel (+)
Minnesota Vikings

nykmac (+)
Buffalo Bills

paulbermingham (+)
Tennessee Titans

Skip to Next Poll »

Like it?

Is this fantasy trade fair?

Background: A team with a 2-3 record was offered Calvin Johnson, Jonathan Stewart, and Kyle Orton in exchange for Reggie Wayne. The Reggie Wayne owner has problems at RB, where he has Steven Jackson, Kevin Smith, and Lawrence Maroney. In this league's scoring system, all of those backs have fewer points than Stewart (though Jackson will likely finish with more). Each team starts exactly 2 RB's (no flex position). The Wayne owner has Drew Brees, but his backup is Vince Young; Orton plays the Lions' D during Brees' bye week. Wayne currently has about 9 more fantasy points than Johnson in this league's scoring format. Is this a fair offer for Wayne?

| Closed on 10/15/08 at 05:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | NFL | Multiple Choice Opinion Poll
Teams: *Fantasy
Tagged as: Fantasy

28 Fans
79%	a. Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
21%	b. No, the Wayne owner should hold.


7 Comments \| Sorted by Most Recent First \| Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 \| 54 days ago NYMets7ss (+)	+1 If I had Wayne and someone offered me that I would do it. Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
	Was this comment...? (1)
#2 \| 54 days ago theshrewdone (+)	+2 It's actually too much for Wayne. As far as value alone, Stewart for Wayne straight up would be about right...but that's just me talking. Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
	Was this comment...? (2)
#3 \| 52 days ago donm454 (+)	+2 If I'm tryin to get Wayne, I'm not givin all that up. If I'm trading Wayne, then I make the trade. Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
	Was this comment...? (2)
#4 \| 52 days ago NYMets7ss (+)	+1 For sure Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
	Was this comment...? (1)
#5 \| 50 days ago sportsnut27 (+)	I think it's a fair deal when you consider the teams these players are on. Johnson, Detroit averaging 75 yds a game giving an average of 7 pts a game not bad but...with Orlovsky at QB need I say more about that. Orton, Chicago. Averaging 231 yds and a TD for 11 pts a game. Stewart, Carolina. Easily the best player involved in that side of the deal. Yes he's gotten alot of the TD carries, but the only thing that hurting him is he's splitting carries, however averaging almost 9 pts a game. None of the three are huge offensive powers however, Indianapolis is always a threat to hang 35 a game as long as the offense is clicking like normal. Which makes Wayne a threat for 120 yds and 2 scores. Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
	Was this comment...?
#6 \| 50 days ago markwilhite (+)	I'd pull the trigger in a heartbeat. Elite WRs are so much more coveted! Stewart splits time with Williams and the Detroit offense is a joke. Those guys will have good days here and there, but I'm looking for consistency on my fantasy team. Wayne's bye week is behind him, so this trade is a no brainer in my opinion! Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
	Was this comment...?
#7 \| 49 days ago blipper21 (+)	Thanks to everyone who participated. I made that offer to get Wayne in my league, and I was somewhat frustrated by the rejection, perhaps in conjunction with some other difficulty I've had making trades. Though I've since made a deal, I had Peterson, Barber, Felix J, Chris Johnson, and Stewart on my roster and I was still having trouble moving an RB. I wanted to see what other people thought, and you guys have been helpful.
	Was this comment...?

Post a Comment Already a user? Sign in here

Join FanIQ - It's Free

FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.

•Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,631,926+ Comments

•Track your game picks - 38,670,156,617+ Sports Predictions

•Prove you know sports - 112,793+ Trivia Questions

•Find fans of your teams - 10,892,506+ New Friends

Start here >> Select your favorite teams. It's free.

Polls You Might Like
	Plasma TV Football Squares Contest Poll NFL Week 14 Asked by Pat \| NFL \| 15 questions asked Yesterday 1410 predictions \| 25 comments \| Last by Dr4usm
	Will Ben Roethlisberger be a Hall of Famer Asked by tomcatwhite \| NFL, PIT \| 1 questions asked 11/21/08 29 opinions \| 89 comments \| Last by beandeclan
	Which of these YOUNG quarterbacks is the most likely to make it to the NFL Hall of Fame? Asked by Rrbhaunoch \| NFL \| 3 questions asked Yesterday 66 opinions \| 5 comments \| Last by beandeclan
	The Eagles, Cowboys, Patriots, and Redskins all have a chance of upsetting teams on the road this we Asked by thomasmertz21 \| NFL, DAL, PHI \| 1 questions asked Today 2 opinions \| 1 comment \| Last by wyldePHX
	NFC Week 14 - Stat Poll Asked by Scott \| NFL \| 6 questions asked 12/02/08 270 predictions \| 5 comments \| Last by chev2222000

#	Name	FanIQ	Answer (Red= You Disagreed)
28	SoonerCane 10/15/2008 04:11PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
27	Disciple 10/15/2008 03:58PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
26	markwilhite 10/15/2008 03:58PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
25	Michael 10/15/2008 03:52PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
24	sportsnut27 10/15/2008 03:05PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
23	TRENT13 10/15/2008 12:42AM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
22	msyroka3 10/13/2008 09:18PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
21	kramer 10/13/2008 08:58PM		No, the Wayne owner should hold.
20	alsp1958 10/13/2008 03:05PM		No, the Wayne owner should hold.
19	donm454 10/13/2008 02:50PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
18	jtm25 10/13/2008 12:49PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
17	YankeeDudeL 10/13/2008 11:55AM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
16	EdSpeshel 10/12/2008 08:24AM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
15	Jahiegel 10/12/2008 12:52AM		No, the Wayne owner should hold.
14	dallasfan27 10/11/2008 10:54PM		No, the Wayne owner should hold.
13	tpowell25 10/11/2008 09:33PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
12	nykmac 10/11/2008 07:11PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
11	vindog 10/11/2008 06:22PM		No, the Wayne owner should hold.
10	mandisdad 10/11/2008 06:21PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
9	bookiebuster 10/11/2008 06:03PM		No, the Wayne owner should hold.
8	theshrewdone 10/11/2008 06:03PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
7	paulbermingham 10/11/2008 05:44PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
6	Michael G 10/11/2008 05:31PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
5	MarkTheShark 10/11/2008 05:29PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
4	BestofChicago 10/11/2008 04:29PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
3	NYMets7ss 10/11/2008 12:38PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
2	Pat 10/11/2008 12:16PM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.
1	Jester 10/11/2008 11:19AM		Yes, that's a fair offer for Wayne.