NFL players not in the Hall of Fame

You Might Like

Asked By: CrazyC

Who liked it? 18

kramer (+)
Pittsburgh Steelers

Yossarian (+)
Indianapolis Colts

woody77 (+)
New York Giants

sportsgnork (+)
Green Bay Packers

YankeeDudeL (+)
New York Giants

mavsoccer23 (+)
Detroit Lions

Nick S (+)
New England Patriots

RichmondSpider (+)
Washington Redskins

mooser58 (+)
Pittsburgh Steelers

wyldePHX (+)
Arizona Cardinals

... and 8 other fans

NFL Results Skip to Next Poll »

Like it?

NFL players not in the Hall of Fame

Should these players be inducted into the Hall of Fame or are the sports writers correct in not voting them in?

| Closed on 08/30/08 at 05:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | NFL | Multiple Choice Opinion Poll

37 Fans
	1. Should Jerry Kramer be inducted into the Hall of Fame? (0 points)
11%	a. Heck yes!
22%	b. Sure
8%	c. Heck no!
11%	d. Good call not inducting him
24%	e. I don't know
14%	f. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet?
11%	g. Other
	2. Should Derrick Thomas be inducted into the Hall of Fame? (0 points)
49%	a. Heck yes!
11%	b. Sure
3%	c. Heck no!
8%	d. Good call not inducting him
3%	e. I don't know
16%	f. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet?
11%	g. Other
	3. Should Ricky Watters be inducted into the Hall of Fame? (0 points)
8%	a. Heck yes!
19%	b. Sure
46%	c. Heck no!
14%	d. Good call not inducting him
14%	e. I don't know
0%	f. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet?
0%	g. Other
	4. Should Cris Carter be inducted into the Hall of Fame? (0 points)
65%	a. Heck yes!
19%	b. Sure
5%	c. Heck no!
3%	d. Good call not inducting him
5%	e. I don't know
3%	f. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet?
0%	g. Other
	5. Should Jim Marshall be inducted into the Hall of Fame? (0 points)
24%	a. Heck yes!
19%	b. Sure
3%	c. Heck no!
16%	d. Good call not inducting him
22%	e. I don't know
11%	f. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet?
5%	g. Other
	6. Should Bob Hayes be inducted into the Hall of Fame? (0 points)
16%	a. Heck yes!
30%	b. Sure
5%	c. Heck no!
11%	d. Good call not inducting him
24%	e. I don't know
8%	f. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet?
5%	g. Other

	&nbp;
TOP COMMENT
#5 \| 115 days ago scottraven (+)	+4 Kinda funny, considering a number of those guys were listed on the NFL top 10...and you left of Ken Stabler, Steve Tasker, or Ray Guy.
	Was this comment...? (4)


16 Comments \| Sorted by Most Recent First \| Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 \| 115 days ago DABULL43 (+)	+2 KRAMER IS ONE OF THE GREATEST GUARDS OF ALL TIME.....HE IS A VICTEM OF PLAYING ON A GREEN BAY DYNASTY THAT HAS MANY HALL OF FAMERS..... 1. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet? 2. Heck yes! 3. Heck no! 4. Heck no! 5. Heck no! 6. I don't know
	Was this comment...? (2)
#2 \| 115 days ago c9303000 (+)	The only one on the list that doesn't belong in the HOF is Watters. 1. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet? 2. Heck yes! 3. Heck no! 4. Heck yes! 5. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet? 6. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet?
	Was this comment...? (1)
#3 \| 115 days ago wyldePHX (+)	+2 Running the wrong way for a safety is probably what's keeping Jim Marshall out of the Hall of Fame. He played for 20 years, which is a long time for a defensive player. He still has multiple NFL records that have yet to be broken. 1. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet? 2. Heck yes! 3. Sure 4. Heck yes! 5. Sure 6. Sure
	Was this comment...? (2)
#4 \| 115 days ago danny_n94 (+)	+1 Bullet Bob Hayes should be in. He was the first game breaking WR. A gold medal in 1964 and a Super Bowl (VI) ring. 1. Sure 2. Sure 3. Heck no! 4. I don't know 5. I don't know 6. Sure
	Was this comment...? (1)
#5 \| 115 days ago scottraven (+)	+4 Kinda funny, considering a number of those guys were listed on the NFL top 10...and you left of Ken Stabler, Steve Tasker, or Ray Guy.
	Was this comment...? (4)
#6 \| 115 days ago RichmondSpider (+)	(Edited by RichmondSpider) scottraven wrote: Kinda funny, considering a number of those guys were listed on the NFL top 10...and you left of Ken Stabler, Steve Tasker, or Ray Guy. +2 Kenny will never make it in, and I am not sure he deserves to be in, but I LOVED him as a kid - my idol - loved to watch him play - there is something about watching a leftie throw the ball - he had an effortless pass, the smoothest release - of course he was probably tanked at the time but... yea - he was one sweet QB before being sweet was cool... 1. Sure 2. Good call not inducting him 3. Good call not inducting him 4. Good call not inducting him 5. Sure 6. Sure
	Was this comment...? (2)
#7 \| 113 days ago scottraven (+)	RichmondSpider wrote: Kenny will never make it in, and I am not sure he deserves to be in, but I LOVED him as a kid - my idol - loved to watch him play - there is something about watching a leftie throw the ball - he had an effortless pass, the smoothest release - of course he was probably tanked at the time but... yea - he was one sweet QB before being sweet was cool... +1 I know....a lot of the flak people give him was his rep, but his rep also gave them a swagger, that kept the silver and black in contention during the 70s. Just a shame they traded him before he could do it again.
	Was this comment...? (1)
#8 \| 113 days ago turfeater77 (+)	+4 Ricky Watters shouldnt even be brought up in the conversation of the Hall of Fame! Derrick Thomas should've been in there as soon as his chance was there. Just goes to show you how much sports writers know! I think the fans should be in charge of voting Hall of Fame inductees!!!! 1. Sure 2. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet? 3. Heck no! 4. Sure 5. Sure 6. Sure
	Was this comment...? (4)
#9 \| 113 days ago wyldePHX (+)	scottraven wrote: I know....a lot of the flak people give him was his rep, but his rep also gave them a swagger, that kept the silver and black in contention during the 70s. Just a shame they traded him before he could do it again. They didn't need him once Plunkett (another player not yet inducted into the HoF) was in the picture. 1. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet? 2. Heck yes! 3. Sure 4. Heck yes! 5. Sure 6. Sure
	Was this comment...?
#10 \| 112 days ago scottraven (+)	wyldePHX wrote: They didn't need him once Plunkett (another player not yet inducted into the HoF) was in the picture. Actually, for the sake of irony, Plunkett wasn't part of the picture, though. When the trade went off, it was Stabler for Dan Pastorini, who became the starter for the Raiders. Of course, two other pieces of the old guard left too, Dave Casper, and Jack Tatum. But, as the history goes, about 3 or 4 games into the 1980 season, Dan went down with a leg injury, and in stepped Plunkett. For good measure, Plunkett beat Stabler and the Oilers, in the first round of the playoffs, before going on to win the Super Bowl that year....and ya, Plunkett is another name that never gets the respect, because of all his picks....even though he was a great after 30 QB.
	Was this comment...?
#11 \| 112 days ago wyldePHX (+)	The NFL Network ran a countdown today of Ten Best Players not in the Hall of Fame (all 6 players in this poll made the list) 1. Jerry Kramer 2. Derrick Thomas 3. Cris Carter 4. Jim Marshall 5. Bob Hayes 6. Ken Stabler 7. Ricky Watters 8. Alex Karras 9. Steve Tasker 10. Ken Anderson 1. Why isn't he in the Hall of Fame yet? 2. Heck yes! 3. Sure 4. Heck yes! 5. Sure 6. Sure
	Was this comment...?
#12 \| 101 days ago Yossarian (+)	1- Don't know much about Kramer, way before my time. 1. Other 2. Heck yes! 3. Heck no! 4. Heck yes! 5. Heck yes! 6. Heck yes!
	Was this comment...?
#13 \| 89 days ago RichmondSpider (+)	They all deserve to be in - Ken Anderson - there was a great QB with an average team... 1. Sure 2. Good call not inducting him 3. Good call not inducting him 4. Good call not inducting him 5. Sure 6. Sure
	Was this comment...?
#14 \| 85 days ago