So Brett is gone again....but for how long?

You Might Like

Asked By: GeoGunz

Who liked it? 12

Jahiegel (+)
Green Bay Packers

jungleboy213 (+)
Philadelphia Eagles

GeoGunz (+)
New York Giants

dumpire5153 (+)
Seattle Seahawks

tradersr2004 (+)
Cleveland Browns

AmyMarz (+)
Tampa Bay Buccaneers

derms33 (+)
Cleveland Browns

Anthonyg7575 (+)
Miami Dolphins

azcardsfan (+)
Arizona Cardinals

MIKE! (+)
Green Bay Packers

... and 2 other fans

NFL Results Skip to Next Poll »

Like it?

So Brett is gone again....but for how long?

| Closed on 04/26/08 at 12:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | NFL, Green Bay Packers | Multiple Choice Opinion Poll

50 Fans
86%	a. He'll stay retire for good
2%	b. 1 month
2%	c. 2 month
0%	d. 3 month
0%	e. 4 month
10%	f. he'll be back just before pre-season

	&nbp;
TOP COMMENT
#15 \| 184 days ago vindog (+)	azcardsfan wrote: Now Packer fans don't kill me but I think its been overkill by ESPN with this Favre retirement, he is definitely a hall of fame QB, but they are making it out that its like Tiger, or MJ retireing, yea he has great career numbers but its more to do with longevity, he has only won 1 super bowl, and I do not believe he is even a top 10 career QB, but the guy was exciting to watch, and his streak alone deserves him to be in hall of fame, but every time I turn on ESPN its something about Brett +5 Uh Oh, you shouldn't have given your opinion- I bet the immature PQers will be out in force now!!! LOL He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...? (5)


98 Comments \| Sorted by Most Recent First \| Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 \| 185 days ago DiabloLoco (+)	+3 I think he's done....Quick prediction...GB in 2008....5-11 He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...? (2) (1) (2)
#2 \| 185 days ago GeoGunz (+)	DiabloLoco wrote: I think he's done....Quick prediction...GB in 2008....5-11 Yeah I think this is it too. He was kind of upset that the Pack didn't get Moss. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#3 \| 185 days ago vindog (+)	DiabloLoco wrote: I think he's done....Quick prediction...GB in 2008....5-11 +1 I'll give them 8-8 just because they have a decent defense!! Aaron Rodgers aint leading them to the playoffs though!!! Hey, I heard that Culpepper is still looking for a job????? He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...? (1)
#4 \| 185 days ago MIKE! (+)	:'( He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#5 \| 185 days ago Bucky's Badgers (+)	must be a 17-year cycle. My first 17 years as a Packers fan...dreadful. The last 17...joyful. The next 17.......TBD. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#6 \| 184 days ago mandisdad (+)	+1 I think he got the records he wanted and will stay retired now. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...? (1)
#7 \| 184 days ago luciddreamer99 (+)	DiabloLoco wrote: I think he's done....Quick prediction...GB in 2008....5-11 I don't know about that. The defense is pretty good and Rogers is serviceable. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#8 \| 184 days ago luciddreamer99 (+)	vindog wrote: I'll give them 8-8 just because they have a decent defense!! Aaron Rodgers aint leading them to the playoffs though!!! Hey, I heard that Culpepper is still looking for a job????? I play Madden football video game and in the 2005 version when Favre retires after the 2005 season I signed Culpepper as a free agent and won the Super Bowl. haha Yeah, Moss wants to sign where Daunte signs, too, so there you go. Favre wouldn't be happy about that. "Oh, so you wait for me to leave to sign Moss. I see how it is." He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#9 \| 184 days ago Huisman (+)	The poll is Titled Brett is gaone again, but when did he first leave? He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#10 \| 184 days ago GeoGunz (+)	Huisman wrote: The poll is Titled Brett is gaone again, but when did he first leave? I lost count somewhere, but if I'm right I believe this would be his third time retiring. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#11 \| 184 days ago azcardsfan (+)	+2 Now Packer fans don't kill me but I think its been overkill by ESPN with this Favre retirement, he is definitely a hall of fame QB, but they are making it out that its like Tiger, or MJ retireing, yea he has great career numbers but its more to do with longevity, he has only won 1 super bowl, and I do not believe he is even a top 10 career QB, but the guy was exciting to watch, and his streak alone deserves him to be in hall of fame, but every time I turn on ESPN its something about Brett he'll be back just before pre-season
	Was this comment...? (1) (1) (1)
#12 \| 184 days ago GeoGunz (+)	(Edited by GeoGunz) azcardsfan wrote: Now Packer fans don't kill me but I think its been overkill by ESPN with this Favre retirement, he is definitely a hall of fame QB, but they are making it out that its like Tiger, or MJ retireing, yea he has great career numbers but its more to do with longevity, he has only won 1 super bowl, and I do not believe he is even a top 10 career QB, but the guy was exciting to watch, and his streak alone deserves him to be in hall of fame, but every time I turn on ESPN its something about Brett +1 Good poll idea. I don't think they have that one yet. Where do you rank Favre among the best? Your idea. Go do that AZ. So I could have something to answer. In my opinion he's in the top 5 of all-time. His heart for the game brought enough excitment alone. And the man has produce numerous amazing plays. Too many to count. I ain't no Pack fan.....but he'll be miss on my end. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...? (1)
#13 \| 184 days ago luciddreamer99 (+)	azcardsfan wrote: Now Packer fans don't kill me but I think its been overkill by ESPN with this Favre retirement, he is definitely a hall of fame QB, but they are making it out that its like Tiger, or MJ retireing, yea he has great career numbers but its more to do with longevity, he has only won 1 super bowl, and I do not believe he is even a top 10 career QB, but the guy was exciting to watch, and his streak alone deserves him to be in hall of fame, but every time I turn on ESPN its something about Brett +2 He is one of the best of all time and certainly one of the funnest to watch. I think any story is overkill beyond reporting the facts, but I think this is a big deal. I would put him in the top five of players I've watched myself, but I don't know about for all-time where I would place him. He won MVP three times in a row, too, and that's pretty significant in any sport. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...? (1)
#14 \| 184 days ago MIKE! (+)	azcardsfan wrote: Now Packer fans don't kill me but I think its been overkill by ESPN with this Favre retirement, he is definitely a hall of fame QB, but they are making it out that its like Tiger, or MJ retireing, yea he has great career numbers but its more to do with longevity, he has only won 1 super bowl, and I do not believe he is even a top 10 career QB, but the guy was exciting to watch, and his streak alone deserves him to be in hall of fame, but every time I turn on ESPN its something about Brett +1 the only thing wrong with that, is that super bowls are a TEAM sport, not a 1 player sport. Dan Marino never won a SB but that doesnt mean he is a bad QB or doesnt deserve 2 be in the Top 10. Now, just out of curiosity. Who ARE your top 10 QB's?? (not trying 2 sound like a bitch or anything haha. i just threw me off a LOT when u said not even a Top 10) He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...? (1)
#15 \| 184 days ago vindog (+)	azcardsfan wrote: Now Packer fans don't kill me but I think its been overkill by ESPN with this Favre retirement, he is definitely a hall of fame QB, but they are making it out that its like Tiger, or MJ retireing, yea he has great career numbers but its more to do with longevity, he has only won 1 super bowl, and I do not believe he is even a top 10 career QB, but the guy was exciting to watch, and his streak alone deserves him to be in hall of fame, but every time I turn on ESPN its something about Brett +5 Uh Oh, you shouldn't have given your opinion- I bet the immature PQers will be out in force now!!! LOL He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...? (5)
#16 \| 183 days ago azcardsfan (+)	MIKE! wrote: the only thing wrong with that, is that super bowls are a TEAM sport, not a 1 player sport. Dan Marino never won a SB but that doesnt mean he is a bad QB or doesnt deserve 2 be in the Top 10. Now, just out of curiosity. Who ARE your top 10 QB's?? (not trying 2 sound like a bitch or anything haha. i just threw me off a LOT when u said not even a Top 10) Jim Hart, Neil Lomax,.... just kidding, no he is one of the best all time as far as excitement, but for me he just throws to many INTs, and maybe he would of had super bowl #2 if he was more under control, because he totally blew that NFC championship game, with 2 horrible passes, that got picked, and both were balls that should have never been thrown, I think he is a top 10 guy though, I was wrong when I said he wasn't a top 10 QB. Hey its just my opinion anyway, no matter what anybody says he is a H.O.F QB. he'll be back just before pre-season
	Was this comment...?
#17 \| 183 days ago mandisdad (+)	azcardsfan wrote: Jim Hart, Neil Lomax,.... just kidding, no he is one of the best all time as far as excitement, but for me he just throws to many INTs, and maybe he would of had super bowl #2 if he was more under control, because he totally blew that NFC championship game, with 2 horrible passes, that got picked, and both were balls that should have never been thrown, I think he is a top 10 guy though, I was wrong when I said he wasn't a top 10 QB. Hey its just my opinion anyway, no matter what anybody says he is a H.O.F QB. +1 I have to agree that the big knock on him is not nly the number of INT's, but they always seemed to come at a very critical time. I would still likely put him in my top 10 QB's though. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...? (1)
#18 \| 183 days ago Indydave (+)	I think GB will be fine without Brett-- maybe they might lose a couple more games with Rodgers as QB, but if they get a solid veteran backup QB, they won't see that much of a drop-off. This is not a knock on Brett, but instead what I think they have as far as the rest of the team in place at GB. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#19 \| 183 days ago Huisman (+)	azcardsfan wrote: Now Packer fans don't kill me but I think its been overkill by ESPN with this Favre retirement, he is definitely a hall of fame QB, but they are making it out that its like Tiger, or MJ retireing, yea he has great career numbers but its more to do with longevity, he has only won 1 super bowl, and I do not believe he is even a top 10 career QB, but the guy was exciting to watch, and his streak alone deserves him to be in hall of fame, but every time I turn on ESPN its something about Brett +1 His heart for the game kept him in it so long, that and, every other team in the NFL went through more quarterbacks than the Packers over the last 20 years, 16 with Brett. Brett's three straight MVP awards will make him a first ballot hall-of-famer, not only is he the only three time winner, but, he also won them consecutively He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...? (1)
#20 \| 183 days ago kantwistaye (+)	azcardsfan wrote: Now Packer fans don't kill me but I think its been overkill by ESPN with this Favre retirement, he is definitely a hall of fame QB, but they are making it out that its like Tiger, or MJ retireing, yea he has great career numbers but its more to do with longevity, he has only won 1 super bowl, and I do not believe he is even a top 10 career QB, but the guy was exciting to watch, and his streak alone deserves him to be in hall of fame, but every time I turn on ESPN its something about Brett Well statistically speaking... this is Tiger or MJ retiring. Just sayin'. Overall I agree because I'm kind of sick of being reminded of him retiring everytime I turn on the tv. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#21 \| 183 days ago mandisdad (+)	kantwistaye wrote: Well statistically speaking... this is Tiger or MJ retiring. Just sayin'. Overall I agree because I'm kind of sick of being reminded of him retiring everytime I turn on the tv. +2 He has great stats, but Tiger and MJ brought their sport to another level. I don't think the same can be said of Favre. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...? (2)
#22 \| 183 days ago kramer (+)	Favre had a hell of a career, but it's time to go. Happy trails, Brett, see you in Canton. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#23 \| 183 days ago azcardsfan (+)	kantwistaye wrote: Well statistically speaking... this is Tiger or MJ retiring. Just sayin'. Overall I agree because I'm kind of sick of being reminded of him retiring everytime I turn on the tv. +1 I wouldn't take it to that extreme, maybe in Green Bay, Brett stats are a lot to do with his era and longevity, he does not have any single season records except maybe ints, and if Peyton or Brady play another 7-10 those records are long gone again except the ints, But Brett was great and is a hall of famer no doubt. he'll be back just before pre-season
	Was this comment...? (1)
#24 \| 183 days ago kantwistaye (+)	mandisdad wrote: He has great stats, but Tiger and MJ brought their sport to another level. I don't think the same can be said of Favre. True, although nobody is going to be raising football to another level anytime soon. It'll be #1 in our nation regardless of the players and what they do. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#25 \| 183 days ago mandisdad (+)	(Edited by mandisdad) kantwistaye wrote: True, although nobody is going to be raising football to another level anytime soon. It'll be #1 in our nation regardless of the players and what they do. I didn't really mean in popularity. I meant the way they played the game. They played at a level above anyone before them. He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#26 \| 182 days ago Soxfest (+)	He'll stay retire for good
	Was this comment...?
#27 \| 182 days ago azcardsfan (+)	Soxfest wrote: I am still pissed at the hawk for trying to make Fisk a left fielder, when he was GM he'll be back just before pre-season
	Was this comment...?
#28 \| 182 days ago azcardsfan (+)	Soxfest wrote: I am still pissed at the hawk for trying to make Fisk a leftfielder, he'll be back just before pre-season
	Was this comment...?