Which QB would you select as your starter for an NFL team?

You Might Like

More Polls By: Bravesfan23

Who liked it? 4

bookiebuster (+)
San Francisco Giants

JACKATTACK (+)
Louisville Cardinals

1001 (+)
New York Jets

Jahiegel (+)
Modern Pentathalon

Locker Room Results Skip to Next Poll »

Like it?

Which QB would you select as your starter for an NFL team?

I know that there are great QB's in the nation, but I am just going by the senior class for next year's NFL Draft. If you had to choose only one of these QBs, which one would it be to build your NFL franchise around or one that will make an immediate impact either next year or the year after.

| Closed on 12/31/07 at 05:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | Locker Room, Sports | Multiple Choice Opinion Poll
Teams: Sports

87 Fans
29%	a. Brian Brohm (Louisville)
9%	b. Andre' Woodson (Kentucky)
23%	c. Matt Ryan (Boston College)
18%	d. Colt Brennan (Hawaii)
17%	e. John David Booty (USC)
3%	f. Chad Henne (Michigan)
0%	g. Erik Ainge (Tennessee)

	&nbp;
TOP COMMENT
#4 \| 355 days ago Nick S (+)	(Edited by Nick S) +11 Matt Ryan runs a pro offense under Jeff Jags and Steve Logan. He is the prefect pro QB, he doesn't try to do too much, he hasn't had very good receivers and still produced. He throws the ball into a small area and completes passes. What ever pro team gets him should be happy. Matt Ryan (Boston College)
	Was this comment...? (5) (2) (4)


25 Comments \| Sorted by Most Recent First \| Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 \| 355 days ago hskrdave (+)	it doesn't matter, snyder would find a way to eff it up. Matt Ryan (Boston College)
	Was this comment...?
#2 \| 355 days ago McNabbNumbaOne (+)	+3 brohm will be a falcon this time next year, so i pick him! Brian Brohm (Louisville)
	Was this comment...? (3)
#3 \| 355 days ago vindog (+)	(Edited by vindog) +2 Booty plays in a pro system right now- he would be the best bet! any questions? refer to Carson Palmer and Matt Leinart John David Booty (USC)
	Was this comment...? (2)
#4 \| 355 days ago Nick S (+)	(Edited by Nick S) +11 Matt Ryan runs a pro offense under Jeff Jags and Steve Logan. He is the prefect pro QB, he doesn't try to do too much, he hasn't had very good receivers and still produced. He throws the ball into a small area and completes passes. What ever pro team gets him should be happy. Matt Ryan (Boston College)
	Was this comment...? (5) (2) (4)
#5 \| 355 days ago skipandash (+)	vindog wrote: Booty plays in a pro system right now- he would be the best bet! any questions? refer to Carson Palmer and Matt Leinart +7 Sooo true. Leinart has just been lights out so far huh? Andre' Woodson (Kentucky)
	Was this comment...? (7)
#6 \| 355 days ago jeremiahmeek (+)	+3 I'm waiting for Booty to make plays like Palmer and Leinart but he hasn't! Colt Brennan (Hawaii)
	Was this comment...? (1) (2)
#7 \| 355 days ago donteisking20 (+)	+1 brohm will be a falcon Brian Brohm (Louisville)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#8 \| 355 days ago donteisking20 (+)	+1 im confident with trent edwards Brian Brohm (Louisville)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#9 \| 355 days ago vindog (+)	jeremiahmeek wrote: I'm waiting for Booty to make plays like Palmer and Leinart but he hasn't! +1 do you have to make plays like Palmer and Leinart when your offense runs for over 300 yards? John David Booty (USC)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#10 \| 355 days ago Michael (+)	+2 Brohm is really very good and could be "The" guy!!!! BUT, I have really found that Ryan out of B.C. is just about as good in the 'tools' area but his 'head' for the game could be better. He has every record that B.C. has ever had; he has done that without the very best WR's in the world; he is somewhat mobile, more a dropback and put it where it needs to be QB. He interception rate is very, very low. Brohm will go higher in the draft because he's had more hype; but, I think Ryan will be the sharper QB on the right team!!!! Matt Ryan (Boston College)
	Was this comment...? (2)
#11 \| 354 days ago skipandash (+)	Michael wrote: Brohm is really very good and could be "The" guy!!!! BUT, I have really found that Ryan out of B.C. is just about as good in the 'tools' area but his 'head' for the game could be better. He has every record that B.C. has ever had; he has done that without the very best WR's in the world; he is somewhat mobile, more a dropback and put it where it needs to be QB. He interception rate is very, very low. Brohm will go higher in the draft because he's had more hype; but, I think Ryan will be the sharper QB on the right team!!!! +1 I think if Ryan continues to play well this year, has a good showing in the bowl game and all star games, and performs well at the combine he may sneak into the first round. This reminds me of Michael Jenkins a few years ago. Andre' Woodson (Kentucky)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#12 \| 354 days ago Michael (+)	skipandash wrote: I think if Ryan continues to play well this year, has a good showing in the bowl game and all star games, and performs well at the combine he may sneak into the first round. This reminds me of Michael Jenkins a few years ago. I think, think, he's a first round now. It is just a matter of where... But, I could be wrong. Matt Ryan (Boston College)
	Was this comment...?
#13 \| 354 days ago johnladden24 (+)	+1 I think HENNE is gonna be a PRO BOWL caliber QB in the NFL! You heard it here first! Chad Henne (Michigan)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#14 \| 354 days ago 1001 (+)	+3 Does anyone remember Timmy Chang? Brian Brohm (Louisville)
	Was this comment...? (3)
#15 \| 354 days ago 1001 (+)	+6 Brian Brohm is the next Peyton Manning... Brian Brohm (Louisville)
	Was this comment...? (2) (4)
#16 \| 354 days ago CB810 (+)	1001 wrote: Brian Brohm is the next Peyton Manning... +4 You finally came around... Brian Brohm (Louisville)
	Was this comment...? (1) (3)
#17 \| 353 days ago Bravesfan23 (+)	1001 wrote: Brian Brohm is the next Peyton Manning... As much as I like and respect Brian Brohm, those are some VERY big words to say. I mean, Brohm is good and to say he is gonna be the next Peyton Manning is saying alot. I think we need to wait and see first and see how he does this year and what system he will be going to. If he gets put in a great system where they pass quite a bit, then he should fare well. But lets wait and see first how he does this year before proclaiming him the next Peyton Manning. Brian Brohm (Louisville)
	Was this comment...?
#18 \| 353 days ago CB810 (+)	Bravesfan23 wrote: As much as I like and respect Brian Brohm, those are some VERY big words to say. I mean, Brohm is good and to say he is gonna be the next Peyton Manning is saying alot. I think we need to wait and see first and see how he does this year and what system he will be going to. If he gets put in a great system where they pass quite a bit, then he should fare well. But lets wait and see first how he does this year before proclaiming him the next Peyton Manning. +3 The similarities between Brohm & Manning are interesting. Both come from football families. Both of their fathers were college quarterbacks. They each have brothers that played QB in college and the pros and they each have brothers that played WR in college. Brohm, like Manning, has been groomed to be a QB all his life. Saying he will be as good as Manning is bold, but not as unlikely as you may think. Brian Brohm (Louisville)
	Was this comment...? (2) (1)
#19 \| 353 days ago Sharp Square (+)	+1 Brohm definitely has the background and skill to become a quality nfl passer. But putting the tag on him of the next manning is a bit extreme i think as manning is a freak of nature. Will be interesting to see him develop a bit more and move onto the next level. I would say odds of being the next manning quite low but being a solid nfl qb fairly decent and there is nothing wrong with that. Brian Brohm (Louisville)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#20 \| 353 days ago ChristiSunshine (+)	+2 This kid, next Peyton Manning or not, plays football with a ton of poise and humility. He could have an inflated ego and an entourage, but he chooses not to (not to mention his family would not have it). That frees him up to play quality football and be the leader his team, his coach, and his family expect him to be. And I feel that is what will make him successful in the NFL. On a team that values it's passing game and a qb that remains cool in the pocket, Brohm will be the perfect fit. He's my starting qb any day of the week. Brian Brohm (Louisville)
	Was this comment...? (1) (1)
#21 \| 352 days ago skipandash (+)	Sharp Square wrote: Brohm definitely has the background and skill to become a quality nfl passer. But putting the tag on him of the next manning is a bit extreme i think as manning is a freak of nature. Will be interesting to see him develop a bit more and move onto the next level. I would say odds of being the next manning quite low but being a solid nfl qb fairly decent and there is nothing wrong with that. +2 Manning's success isn't entirely from God's gifts. He is the most well prepared athletes in the history of the game. A film room junkie rarely sees a situation on the field that he hasn't seen 100 times on tape. That kind of makes his line checks seem a little more "super human." Andre' Woodson (Kentucky)
	Was this comment...? (2)
#22 \| 352 days ago Sharp Square (+)	(Edited by Sharp Square) skipandash wrote: Manning's success isn't entirely from God's gifts. He is the most well prepared athletes in the history of the game. A film room junkie rarely sees a situation on the field that he hasn't seen 100 times on tape. That kind of makes his line checks seem a little more "super human." +1 agreed being a constant off the field workaholic definately helps , along with his understanding of the game. Its a perfect match of attitude and natural god given talent , and that combination makes the freak he is. Brian Brohm (Louisville)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#23 \| 331 days ago HoosierDaddy1 (+)	I went with Booty in the Booty vs Breasts poll, so I gotta be consistent. John David Booty (USC)
	Was this comment...?
#24 \| 250 days ago craign123 (+)	homer pick. but if Woodson can learn better clock management he will be very good. Andre' Woodson (Kentucky)
	Was this comment...?
#25 \| 249 days ago donteisking20 (+)	ok im still with trent edwards but if i had to chose 1 of these QBs the best in my mind is Brohm, even though i think very highly of both brennen and ryan. they are all very smart system QBs who if put in the right situation can all be very good. but the thing is that they will probably go to crappy teams like the ravens, falcons, jets, bears, (no offense cuz my team ain't much better) and if god really hates them...the dolphins:[ Brian Brohm (Louisville)
	Was this comment...?

Post a Comment Already a user? Sign in here

Join FanIQ - It's Free

FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.

•Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,367,994+ Comments

•Track your game picks - 15,061,845+ Sports Predictions

•Prove you know sports - 81,306+ Trivia Questions

•Find fans of your teams - 3,529,642+ New Friends

Start here >> Select your favorite teams. It's free.

Polls You Might Like
	Palin's speech Asked by mandisdad \| Locker Room \| 2 questions asked Yesterday 94 opinions \| 71 comments \| Last by irbe38
	The Official Sarah Palin Poll Asked by Shrugging Atlas \| Locker Room, Politics \| 1 questions asked 08/29/08 67 opinions \| 111 comments \| Last by derms33
	Would you rather 9-03 Asked by cbreezylvr \| Locker Room \| 1 questions asked 09/03/08 42 opinions \| 16 comments \| Last by JBrenn
	Who Is Your Favorite Motown Artist - Group from the 1960's? Asked by NittanyJon \| Locker Room \| 10 questions asked 08/08/08 230 opinions \| 4 comments \| Last by JBrenn
	Caption this 8/8/08 Asked by RunningDawg \| Locker Room \| 1 questions asked 08/08/08 34 opinions \| 26 comments \| Last by JBrenn

#	Name	FanIQ	Answer (Red= You Disagreed)
87	craign123 12/30/2007 06:47PM		Andre' Woodson (Kentucky)
86	tpowell25 12/30/2007 06:44PM		John David Booty (USC)
85	towsongirl12 12/27/2007 10:45AM		John David Booty (USC)
84	wgrn11 12/26/2007 08:28PM		Matt Ryan (Boston College)
83	BestofChicago 12/26/2007 08:14PM		Colt Brennan (Hawaii)
82	Rockchawk13 10/23/2007 02:08PM		Matt Ryan (Boston College)
81	Big_Country78 10/23/2007 12:37PM		Brian Brohm (Louisville)
80	r8derman26 10/23/2007 11:44AM		Chad Henne (Michigan)
79	CantBBeat 10/23/2007 07:02AM		Matt Ryan (Boston College)
78	YankeeDudeL 10/16/2007 05:58AM		Brian Brohm (Louisville)
77	Mutedfaith07 10/12/2007 02:31PM		Brian Brohm (Louisville)
76	HoosierDaddy1 10/10/2007 05:03PM		John David Booty (USC)
75	NYR22 10/10/2007 04:36PM		Matt Ryan (Boston College)
74	ABAC 09/28/2007 01:15PM		Brian Brohm (Louisville)
73	baldntan 09/26/2007 09:49AM		Colt Brennan (Hawaii)
72	theshrewdone 09/26/2007 09:39AM		John David Booty (USC)
71	kappafla211 09/26/2007 09:14AM		Brian Brohm (Louisville)
70	Flousc 09/26/2007 09:05AM		Andre' Woodson (Kentucky)
69	isolpj 09/25/2007 06:29PM		Brian Brohm (Louisville)
68	woody77 09/19/2007 12:43PM		Andre' Woodson (Kentucky)