Who is the most overrated comedian?

Asked By: truejester

Who liked it? 8

PhattyAlfrado (+)
Boston Bruins

ImmortallEyesz (+)
Arizona Diamondbacks

beatles4sancho (+)
New York Yankees

js166 (+)
Milwaukee Brewers

bhopp4p1 (+)
Bernard Hopkins

BigJunk (+)
San Francisco 49ers

YankeeDudeL (+)
New York Giants

PeacefulDave (+)
North Carolina Tar Heels

Skip to Next Poll »

Like it?

Who is the most overrated comedian?

I was asking myself this while I wasn't laughing at Carlos Mencia the other night. Please feel free to give other suggestions.

| Closed on 02/08/08 at 10:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | Media | Opinion List

Rank	48 Fans	Avg (1st)
1.	Carlos Mencia	6.8 (12)
2.	Margaret Cho	6.4 (5)
3.	Gallagher	6.3 (4)
4.	Tyler Perry	6.0 (2)
5.	Wanda Sykes	5.6 (4)
6.	Larry the Cable Guy	5.3 (7)
7.	Ben Stiller	5.1 (1)
8.	Jerry Seinfeld	5.0 (8)
9.	Tracy Morgan	4.5 (1)
10.	Robin Williams	4.1 (4)

	&nbp;
TOP COMMENT
#2 \| 333 days ago YankeeDudeL (+)	+13 Dane Cook is highly overrated. 1. Margaret Cho 2. Larry the Cable Guy 3. Jerry Seinfeld 4. Carlos Mencia 5. Tyler Perry 6. Ben Stiller 7. Wanda Sykes 8. Gallagher 9. Tracy Morgan 10. Robin Williams
	Was this comment...? (12)


22 Comments \| Sorted by Most Recent First \| Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 \| 333 days ago kantwistaye (+)	+1 If we could rid the world of Mencia's, Larry the Cable Guy's, and Wanda Syke's "comedy" we'd solve world peace... or at least make me more at peace. 1. Carlos Mencia 2. Larry the Cable Guy 3. Wanda Sykes 4. Tracy Morgan 5. Tyler Perry 6. Gallagher 7. Margaret Cho 8. Ben Stiller 9. Robin Williams 10. Jerry Seinfeld
	Was this comment...? (1)
#2 \| 333 days ago YankeeDudeL (+)	+13 Dane Cook is highly overrated. 1. Margaret Cho 2. Larry the Cable Guy 3. Jerry Seinfeld 4. Carlos Mencia 5. Tyler Perry 6. Ben Stiller 7. Wanda Sykes 8. Gallagher 9. Tracy Morgan 10. Robin Williams
	Was this comment...? (12)
#3 \| 333 days ago DiabloJones (+)	YankeeDudeL wrote: Dane Cook is highly overrated. +2 Dane is a BAMF! 1. Margaret Cho 2. Larry the Cable Guy 3. Carlos Mencia 4. Wanda Sykes 5. Tyler Perry 6. Ben Stiller 7. Jerry Seinfeld 8. Gallagher 9. Robin Williams 10. Tracy Morgan
	Was this comment...? (2)
#4 \| 333 days ago YankeeDudeL (+)	DiabloJones wrote: Dane is a BAMF! +2 Basks Among Monkey Feces? Not familiar w/ the term, but I like my acronym. I'm guessing it's Bad @$$ Mutha eFFer? 1. Margaret Cho 2. Larry the Cable Guy 3. Jerry Seinfeld 4. Carlos Mencia 5. Tyler Perry 6. Ben Stiller 7. Wanda Sykes 8. Gallagher 9. Tracy Morgan 10. Robin Williams
	Was this comment...? (1) (1)
#5 \| 333 days ago DiabloJones (+)	YankeeDudeL wrote: Basks Among Monkey Feces? Not familiar w/ the term, but I like my acronym. I'm guessing it's Bad @$$ Mutha eFFer? +2 Indeed. Me and DC go rolling in the CT2000 all the time. SuFi! 1. Margaret Cho 2. Larry the Cable Guy 3. Carlos Mencia 4. Wanda Sykes 5. Tyler Perry 6. Ben Stiller 7. Jerry Seinfeld 8. Gallagher 9. Robin Williams 10. Tracy Morgan
	Was this comment...? (2)
#6 \| 333 days ago bhopp4p1 (+)	Robin Williams stand up is great but he has made some awful movies. I like Sykes, Morgan, and Seinfeld. 1. Larry the Cable Guy 2. Carlos Mencia 3. Ben Stiller 4. Tyler Perry 5. Margaret Cho 6. Robin Williams 7. Gallagher 8. Wanda Sykes 9. Tracy Morgan 10. Jerry Seinfeld
	Was this comment...?
#7 \| 332 days ago dallas78 (+)	+1 Wouldn't it be hilarious if I smashed this watermelon....lame 1. Gallagher 2. Margaret Cho 3. Tyler Perry 4. Carlos Mencia 5. Wanda Sykes 6. Robin Williams 7. Tracy Morgan 8. Ben Stiller 9. Jerry Seinfeld 10. Larry the Cable Guy
	Was this comment...? (1)
#8 \| 332 days ago truejester (+)	dallas78 wrote: Wouldn't it be hilarious if I smashed this watermelon....lame Yeah I guess people laughed at most anything back then. 1. Carlos Mencia 2. Larry the Cable Guy 3. Gallagher 4. Tyler Perry 5. Wanda Sykes 6. Margaret Cho 7. Robin Williams 8. Tracy Morgan 9. Ben Stiller 10. Jerry Seinfeld
	Was this comment...?
#9 \| 332 days ago beatles4sancho (+)	+3 Hmm, no mention of Jim Breuer. I think he should be on the list before Robin Williams. And yes, prop comics should die (e.g. carrot top) 1. Larry the Cable Guy 2. Margaret Cho 3. Carlos Mencia 4. Ben Stiller 5. Gallagher 6. Jerry Seinfeld 7. Tyler Perry 8. Wanda Sykes 9. Robin Williams 10. Tracy Morgan
	Was this comment...? (1) (2)
#10 \| 332 days ago Anthonyg7575 (+)	I can't understand how Jerry Seinfeld is sitting at #8 on this list. I saw him about 3 years ago and he suuuuucked. His routine is just plain dry. 1. Jerry Seinfeld 2. Gallagher 3. Ben Stiller 4. Carlos Mencia 5. Wanda Sykes 6. Tracy Morgan 7. Tyler Perry 8. Margaret Cho 9. Robin Williams 10. Larry the Cable Guy
	Was this comment...?
#11 \| 332 days ago McNabbNumbaOne (+)	+6 most of mencia's material, the stuff thats actually funny, was good the first time i heard it... when it came out of george lopez's mouth 1. Jerry Seinfeld 2. Carlos Mencia 3. Larry the Cable Guy 4. Gallagher 5. Ben Stiller 6. Tyler Perry 7. Wanda Sykes 8. Tracy Morgan 9. Margaret Cho 10. Robin Williams
	Was this comment...? (3) (3)
#12 \| 332 days ago bodai808 (+)	+1 There are alot of over-rated comedians out there, but there are also under-rated ones too. I don't think Ben Stiller should be on here, he's more of an actor in comedy movies, not a comedian. And Tracy Morgan is hilarious!!!!! I think Aries Spears is over-rated, I seen him live 3 times in 10 years and they were all the exact same bit. 1. Carlos Mencia 2. Gallagher 3. Jerry Seinfeld 4. Larry the Cable Guy 5. Tyler Perry 6. Ben Stiller 7. Wanda Sykes 8. Margaret Cho 9. Robin Williams 10. Tracy Morgan
	Was this comment...? (1)
#13 \| 332 days ago truejester (+)	bodai808 wrote: There are alot of over-rated comedians out there, but there are also under-rated ones too. I don't think Ben Stiller should be on here, he's more of an actor in comedy movies, not a comedian. And Tracy Morgan is hilarious!!!!! I think Aries Spears is over-rated, I seen him live 3 times in 10 years and they were all the exact same bit. Compared to most, Tracy Morgan's comedy is very weak. He tries way too hard and usually ends up falling on his face. I only put Ben Stiller on here because of his steady decline over the last few years. Maybe I should replace him with Carrot-top. 1. Carlos Mencia 2. Larry the Cable Guy 3. Gallagher 4. Tyler Perry 5. Wanda Sykes 6. Margaret Cho 7. Robin Williams 8. Tracy Morgan 9. Ben Stiller 10. Jerry Seinfeld
	Was this comment...?
#14 \| 332 days ago McNabbNumbaOne (+)	truejester wrote: Compared to most, Tracy Morgan's comedy is very weak. He tries way too hard and usually ends up falling on his face. I only put Ben Stiller on here because of his steady decline over the last few years. Maybe I should replace him with Carrot-top. it would be hard to put carrot top on this list because he gets absolutely NO respect... and its a shame, because i have heard he is one funny mother f'er from people who have been to his shows tracy morgan is funny with his skit comedy, his stand up is pretty weak 1. Jerry Seinfeld 2. Carlos Mencia 3. Larry the Cable Guy 4. Gallagher 5. Ben Stiller 6. Tyler Perry 7. Wanda Sykes 8. Tracy Morgan 9. Margaret Cho 10. Robin Williams
	Was this comment...?
#15 \| 332 days ago truejester (+)	Well I've only seen his skit comedy, so I can only imagine how painful his stand up must be. 1. Carlos Mencia 2. Larry the Cable Guy 3. Gallagher 4. Tyler Perry 5. Wanda Sykes 6. Margaret Cho 7. Robin Williams 8. Tracy Morgan 9. Ben Stiller 10. Jerry Seinfeld
	Was this comment...?