Who would have a better season Brett Favre or Aaron Rodgers?

You Might Like

More Polls By: UltimateSureno

Who liked it? 12

schmidtj (+)
Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Fubu77 (+)
Pittsburgh Steelers

kizzlep (+)
Pittsburgh Steelers

derms33 (+)
Cleveland Browns

Bucky's Badgers (+)
Green Bay Packers

majikmanseven (+)
Green Bay Packers

Peytonrob (+)
Indianapolis Colts

bhopp4p1 (+)
Buffalo Bills

infector2 (+)
Green Bay Packers

theshrewdone (+)
Arizona Cardinals

... and 2 other fans

Skip to Next Poll »

Like it?

Who would have a better season Brett Favre or Aaron Rodgers?

Now that Brett Favre is a memeber of the NY Jets & Aaron Rodgers can now focus. So I want to know who you guys think would have the better season with there team! Favre or Rodgers?

| Closed on 09/08/08 at 05:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | NFL, Green Bay Packers, New York Jets | Multiple Choice Opinion Poll

42 Fans
31%	a. Aaron Rodgers GB Packers
69%	b. Brett Favre NY Jets

	&nbp;
TOP COMMENT
#1 \| 119 days ago Anthonyg7575 (+)	+4 Rodgers will get eaten up his first year as a starter. Brett Favre NY Jets
	Was this comment...? (3) (1) (1)


24 Comments \| Sorted by Most Recent First \| Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 \| 119 days ago Anthonyg7575 (+)	+4 Rodgers will get eaten up his first year as a starter. Brett Favre NY Jets
	Was this comment...? (3) (1) (1)
#2 \| 119 days ago UltimateSureno (+)	+1 Feel that Brett Favre made the right move cuz I feel that GB Packers dont want him there! Favre would make the Jets very good team! Aaron Rodgers wouldnt ever come close to Favre. Bad move by the GB Packers! Brett Favre NY Jets
	Was this comment...? (1)
#3 \| 118 days ago tntsk8er (+)	+3 I think that we're gunna see some fun highlights of Brett to Laverneus Coles this year Brett Favre NY Jets
	Was this comment...? (3) (1)
#4 \| 118 days ago pogoowner (+)	+1 Favre is completely overrated. Aaron Rodgers GB Packers
	Was this comment...? (1) (3)
#5 \| 117 days ago bhopp4p1 (+)	+3 Green Bay has a better over all team and may end up with a better record, but Favre will have better numbers then Rodgers. Brett Favre NY Jets
	Was this comment...? (3)
#6 \| 117 days ago M3881 (+)	+2 Brett Favre will have a better season and you already know that the Jets is a better team Brett Favre NY Jets
	Was this comment...? (2)
#7 \| 116 days ago UltimateSureno (+)	I think that Favre would be a great fit to the NY Jets & feel that NY Jets may have a better offense then GB Packers! I feel that L. Coles & J. Cotchery are better then G. Jennings & D. Driver. Thomas Jones would be a great fit for Favre & make it alot easy for Favre because Thomas Jones is a great pass catcher in the back field but Ryan Grant would have a soild season! Chris Baker would have a break out season with Favre at QB & dont forget about Bubba Franks who I think Favre may know pretty good LoL & dont forget about Tony Richardson who is one of the best FB of all-times in my mind& who a great blocker would easy it up for Favre. Brett Favre NY Jets
	Was this comment...?
#8 \| 116 days ago pogoowner (+)	M3881 wrote: Brett Favre will have a better season and you already know that the Jets is a better team +2 Please... the Packers are a far superior team at this point in time. Aaron Rodgers GB Packers
	Was this comment...? (1) (1) (1)
#9 \| 116 days ago M3881 (+)	pogoowner wrote: Please... the Packers are a far superior team at this point in time. no there not Aaron Rodgers is wack come he is not better then Brett Favre and the only WR GREEN BAY HAS is DONALD DRIVER and the JETS have got better this season we will see who is the better team Brett Favre NY Jets
	Was this comment...?
#10 \| 116 days ago Peytonrob (+)	+3 the problem here is that before the Jets gained Favre they were building a run dominant team. this is where they moved off season. left guard, right tackle, outside linebacker, nose tackle and tight end. this is the 26 ranked offense last year! laverneous coles can catch balls when hes not on his back from injury hes also 30. they passed on a Devin thomas to take a blocking tight end. their best bet is brad smith whos fast but cant run routes well. Also, of the the first 4 games, theyre against SD and NE. Plus we forget about Thomas Jones!! his line was horrible last year and he still made over a thousand rushing. This is all against pretty much the same favreless playoff team last year. my opinion favre will be handing off, Rodgers will be passing. you make the call Aaron Rodgers GB Packers
	Was this comment...? (3)
#11 \| 116 days ago pogoowner (+)	M3881 wrote: no there not Aaron Rodgers is wack come he is not better then Brett Favre and the only WR GREEN BAY HAS is DONALD DRIVER and the JETS have got better this season we will see who is the better team Donald Driver and Greg Jennings have both shown themselves to be more reliable and productive than Coles or Cotchery, and Ryan Grant was far more productive than Thomas Jones last season. Also, the Green Bay defense is miles ahead of New York's. There's simply NOTHING to suggest that New York is the better team, aside from signing an arrogant old man at quarterback who will likely go back to throwing an unacceptable number of interceptions now that he's out of McCarthy's system. Aaron Rodgers GB Packers
	Was this comment...?
#12 \| 116 days ago tntsk8er (+)	pogoowner wrote: Donald Driver and Greg Jennings have both shown themselves to be more reliable and productive than Coles or Cotchery, and Ryan Grant was far more productive than Thomas Jones last season. Also, the Green Bay defense is miles ahead of New York's. There's simply NOTHING to suggest that New York is the better team, aside from signing an arrogant old man at quarterback who will likely go back to throwing an unacceptable number of interceptions now that he's out of McCarthy's system. I dunno i think if laverneus coles had a more consistant qb then he can easily be just as effective as both of GB's WR's Brett Favre NY Jets
	Was this comment...?
#13 \| 116 days ago godofwar1994 (+)	Peytonrob wrote: the problem here is that before the Jets gained Favre they were building a run dominant team. this is where they moved off season. left guard, right tackle, outside linebacker, nose tackle and tight end. this is the 26 ranked offense last year! laverneous coles can catch balls when hes not on his back from injury hes also 30. they passed on a Devin thomas to take a blocking tight end. their best bet is brad smith whos fast but cant run routes well. Also, of the the first 4 games, theyre against SD and NE. Plus we forget about Thomas Jones!! his line was horrible last year and he still made over a thousand rushing. This is all against pretty much the same favreless playoff team last year. my opinion favre will be handing off, Rodgers will be passing. you make the call uhh.........actually, they passed on devin thomas to take dustin keller, the most pass-savvy tight end in the draft....hell, hes horrible at blocking....where do you get your information?.... Brett Favre NY Jets
	Was this comment...?
#14 \| 116 days ago M3881 (+)	pogoowner wrote: Donald Driver and Greg Jennings have both shown themselves to be more reliable and productive than Coles or Cotchery, and Ryan Grant was far more productive than Thomas Jones last season. Also, the Green Bay defense is miles ahead of New York's. There's simply NOTHING to suggest that New York is the better team, aside from signing an arrogant old man at quarterback who will likely go back to throwing an unacceptable number of interceptions now that he's out of McCarthy's system. u said GB defense is better then theJet's no there not this year the Jets are going to the playoff's while GB will seat back and lose like 10 games come on the Packer's better then the Jets your funny now that Favre is gone GB is going no where and u know it Brett Favre NY Jets
	Was this comment...?
#15 \| 116 days ago pogoowner (+)	M3881 wrote: u said GB defense is better then theJet's no there not this year the Jets are going to the playoff's while GB will seat back and lose like 10 games come on the Packer's better then the Jets your funny now that Favre is gone GB is going no where and u know it +1 Way to back up your position with... oh, wait.... nothing at all. The Packers have arguably the best cornerback tandem in the league (along with Bailey/Bly), one of the NFL's best DEs in Aaron Kampman, and a very solid group of linebackers with Barnett and Hawk. What do the Jets have to offer? Kerry Rhodes is very good, and David Harris looks very solid, but their defense simply isn't on the same level. Aaron Rodgers GB Packers
	Was this comment...? (1)