Who would you rather have on your team , Manny Ramirez or A-Rod ? - MLB, Los Angeles Dodgers, New York Yankees

You Might Like

More Polls By: AMAZINGGRACE

Who liked it? 10

raimondal (+)
Wales

Stephtlse (+)
Los Angeles Angels

big_baller2008 (+)
New York Yankees

hartley51592 (+)
Boston Red Sox

eletha65 (+)
Dale Earnhardt Jr.

kevinnd1 (+)
Chicago Cubs

Anthonyg7575 (+)
Florida Marlins

theshrewdone (+)
Seattle Mariners

Nick S (+)
Boston Red Sox

joebloom53 (+)
Boston Red Sox

Skip to Next Poll »

Like it?

Who would you rather have on your team , Manny Ramirez or A-Rod ?

| Closed on 09/27/08 at 05:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | MLB, Los Angeles Dodgers, New York Yankees | Multiple Choice Opinion Poll

45 Fans
40%	a. Manny Ramirez
60%	b. A-Rod

	&nbp;
TOP COMMENT
#1 \| 99 days ago joebloom53 (+)	+6 manny has come thru in the post-season while we all know how choke-rod fares. it's sorta like choosin' between bin-laden and hitler
	Was this comment...? (2) (4)


10 Comments \| Sorted by Most Recent First \| Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 \| 99 days ago joebloom53 (+)	+6 manny has come thru in the post-season while we all know how choke-rod fares. it's sorta like choosin' between bin-laden and hitler
	Was this comment...? (2) (4)
#2 \| 99 days ago kramer (+)	+4 I can't stand the Yankees, but I can't help but love A-Rod. He's not that great in the postseason, but he's one of, if not THE best baseball player of this generation along with Griffey Jr. A-Rod
	Was this comment...? (3) (1)
#3 \| 99 days ago r_surdam (+)	+2 Manny's got better hair. Manny Ramirez
	Was this comment...? (2)
#4 \| 99 days ago Anthonyg7575 (+)	joebloom53 wrote: manny has come thru in the post-season while we all know how choke-rod fares. it's sorta like choosin' between bin-laden and hitler +4 .279 / 7 / 17 in 39 postseason games isn't absolutely horrible.Look at Bonds in the playoffs, 48 games 9 HR 24 RBI and a .245 AVG. Ramirez has also had almost triple the games in the postseason than A-Rod. With 24 career HR's for Manny in the playoffs (13 of which were with the Indians. how many WS did they win?) his .269 AVG is really nothing special. I still go with A-Rod. A-Rod
	Was this comment...? (4)
#5 \| 98 days ago zskea01 (+)	+3 Now that Manny's not a Red Sox anymore and is playing great for the Dodgers, I'm going to have to go with him. He's great in the post-season! Unfortunately, I fear the Dodgers might not make the post-season if they don't help him with run support. Manny Ramirez
	Was this comment...? (3)
#6 \| 95 days ago kevin23864 (+)	Anthonyg7575 wrote: .279 / 7 / 17 in 39 postseason games isn't absolutely horrible.Look at Bonds in the playoffs, 48 games 9 HR 24 RBI and a .245 AVG. Ramirez has also had almost triple the games in the postseason than A-Rod. With 24 career HR's for Manny in the playoffs (13 of which were with the Indians. how many WS did they win?) his .269 AVG is really nothing special. I still go with A-Rod. +1 Sorry I will have to disagree with u totally on that comparison. First off no A-Rod team has never ever won. He has failed miserably ever time he had a chance to perform. The key here is clutch hitting not what overall avg and games u have played in. Maybe if A- rod would have done his job and come through in the clutch then he would have as many games as Ramirez in the postseason. Also Bonds has failed to come through in the playoffs too. Note also number of years he has played versus number of world series titles. Zero titles and in fact just 2 wins and 7 losses in the playoff matchups. Also A- rod is 3 and 7 in series matchups and no World Series appearances. While Ramirez has maintained a 12 win 7 loss in playoff matchups. While going 4 and 2 in the LCS and 2 and 2 in the World Series. You can have A- rod and Bonds becuase you will be watching us beat you while we celebrate winning. Manny Ramirez
	Was this comment...? (1)
#7 \| 94 days ago Anthonyg7575 (+)	kevin23864 wrote: Sorry I will have to disagree with u totally on that comparison. First off no A-Rod team has never ever won. He has failed miserably ever time he had a chance to perform. The key here is clutch hitting not what overall avg and games u have played in. Maybe if A- rod would have done his job and come through in the clutch then he would have as many games as Ramirez in the postseason. Also Bonds has failed to come through in the playoffs too. Note also number of years he has played versus number of world series titles. Zero titles and in fact just 2 wins and 7 losses in the playoff matchups. Also A- rod is 3 and 7 in series matchups and no World Series appearances. While Ramirez has maintained a 12 win 7 loss in playoff matchups. While going 4 and 2 in the LCS and 2 and 2 in the World Series. You can have A- rod and Bonds becuase you will be watching us beat you while we celebrate winning. +4 "Also A- rod is 3 and 7 in series matchups and no World Series appearances. While Ramirez has maintained a 12 win 7 loss in playoff matchups" That was one of the most ignorant comments that I have even seen. I didn't realize that both A-Rod and Ramirez both single handedly controlled their teams destiny. Since when did they pitch? Those are the only players that compile a win/loss record. I also notice that you are a Red Sox fan which obviously makes your answer correct. Let me bow down to you now. A-Rod
	Was this comment...? (4)
#8 \| 94 days ago RichmondSpider (+)	+1 A-Rod - in a New York minute... A-Rod
	Was this comment...? (1)
#9 \| 93 days ago cogito (+)	+1 take a-rod...better defense in a series. manny might hit the clutch shot, but a-rod will play the solid D to preserve a win. A-Rod
	Was this comment...? (1)
#10 \| 91 days ago raimondal (+)	not that i have a clue ,,,, i know I'm a learner but i will learn it's my pledge to all you Q guy's , i just picked the nicest name ????????? i think but i am trying xxx Manny Ramirez
	Was this comment...?

Post a Comment Already a user? Sign in here

Join FanIQ - It's Free

FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.

•Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,631,926+ Comments

•Track your game picks - 38,670,156,617+ Sports Predictions

•Prove you know sports - 112,793+ Trivia Questions

•Find fans of your teams - 10,892,506+ New Friends

Start here >> Select your favorite teams. It's free.

Polls You Might Like
	Was it a good move for the Yankees to get Nick Swisher ? Asked by AMAZINGGRACE \| MLB, CWS, NYY \| 2 questions asked 11/13/08 54 opinions \| 6 comments \| Last by oaklandmc20
	Does George Steinbrenner belong in the Hall of Fame ? Asked by AMAZINGGRACE \| MLB, NYY \| 1 questions asked 11/23/08 31 opinions \| 10 comments \| Last by oaklandmc20
	Does Mike Mussina belong in the hall of fame? Asked by AMAZINGGRACE \| MLB, NYY \| 1 questions asked 11/20/08 25 opinions \| 8 comments \| Last by ML31
	Will Alfonso Soriano ever be a 40/40 man again? Asked by jasonluvscubs \| MLB, CHC \| 1 questions asked Today 0 opinions \| Last by -
	The Best Hitter & Pitcher Right Now Asked by joshhulling \| MLB \| 2 questions asked 11/05/08 232 opinions \| 43 comments \| Last by 1001 \| 11 hours left

#	Name	FanIQ	Answer (Red= You Disagreed)
45	Jahiegel 09/26/2008 07:50PM		A-Rod
44	tpowell25 09/08/2008 04:06PM		Manny Ramirez
43	turfeater77 09/05/2008 09:35PM		Manny Ramirez
42	BestofChicago 09/05/2008 06:38PM		A-Rod
41	raimondal 09/05/2008 05:05PM		Manny Ramirez
40	Stephtlse 09/05/2008 01:09PM		A-Rod
39	kantwistaye 09/05/2008 01:07PM		A-Rod
38	mrmickeys46 09/05/2008 12:37PM		A-Rod
37	cogito 09/03/2008 01:25PM		A-Rod
36	Chryno1316 09/03/2008 03:22AM		A-Rod
35	big_baller2008 09/03/2008 02:53AM		A-Rod
34	dallasfan27 09/03/2008 12:41AM		Manny Ramirez
33	RichmondSpider 09/02/2008 09:46AM		A-Rod
32	HOOTERHOUND 09/01/2008 11:41PM		Manny Ramirez
31	d94e59b6 09/01/2008 09:29PM		Manny Ramirez
30	hartley51592 09/01/2008 08:40PM		Manny Ramirez
29	kevin23864 09/01/2008 06:58PM		Manny Ramirez
28	DJ_Kickflip 09/01/2008 06:49PM		Manny Ramirez
27	eletha65 09/01/2008 01:59PM		A-Rod
26	ABAC