You Might Like


Asked By: absolut0314


Who liked it? 11
Jahiegel (+)
Milwaukee Brewers

JKB37 (+)
Baltimore Orioles

DetroitMadman (+)
Detroit Tigers

Anthonyg7575 (+)
Florida Marlins

JKSWAMI (+)
Detroit Tigers

woody050681 (+)
Detroit Tigers

Nick S (+)
Boston Red Sox

bubwagon (+)
Atlanta Braves

ImmortallEyesz (+)
Arizona Diamondbacks

theshrewdone (+)
Seattle Mariners

... and 1 other fan
 MLB ResultsSkip to Next Poll »
11
Like it?
thumbs up
Who's your Tiger?: 1984 vs. 2006
Tiger fans lets debate our last 2 World Series teams even though like you I love all my Tigers but, who would be your starting lineup?  Pick one player from either the '84 or '06 teams for each position.
| Closed on 08/03/08 at 05:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | MLB, Detroit Tigers, Detroit Tigers | Opinion List
Team Breakout:
Rank19 FansAvg (1st)
1.RF-Kirk Gibson 19846.5 (3)
2.SS-Alan Trammell 19845.8 (1)
3.CF-Curtis Granderson 20065.4 (3)
4.2B-Lou Whitaker 19845.4
5.LF-Larry Herndon 19844.8 (8)
6.CF-Chet Lemon 19843.2
7.RF-Magglio Ordonez 20063.1
8.1B-Darrell Evans 19842.8
9.3B-Brandon Inge 20062.3
10.MGR-Sparky Anderson 19842.2 (2)
Also receiving votes:3B-Tom Brookens 19842.1
LF-Craig Monroe 20062.0 (2)
P-Morris,Petry,Wilcox,Lopez,Hernandez 19841.7
C-Pudge Rodriguez 20061.6
P-Bonderman,Rogers,Verlander,Zumaya,Jones 20061.5
C-Lance Parrish 19841.3
SS-Carlos Guillen 20061.1
1B-Sean Casey 20060.9
2B-Placido Polanco 20060.8
MGR-Jim Leyland 20060.5

 &nbp;
TOP COMMENT * * * * * * * * * * * *
#4 | 62 days ago

 +4 thumbs upI went with all of the 1984 guys because they actually won the World Series.  I know guys like Mags and Pudge are better than the "other" guys at those positions but obviously they(the '84 Tigers) had the chemistry and talent to win it all in '84.

I know... I'm a buzzkill.
1. RF-Kirk Gibson 1984  2. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  3. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  4. LF-Larry Herndon 1984  5. CF-Chet Lemon 1984  6. 1B-Darrell Evans 1984  7. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  8. P-Morris,Petry,Wilcox,Lopez,Hernandez 1984  9. C-Lance Parrish 1984  10. 3B-Tom Brookens 1984  
Was this comment...? Smart(4) Funny Bold Poor
  
12 Comments | Sorted by Most Recent First | Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 | 63 days ago

 well the poll didn't turn out exactly how i wanted it to, but you get the general idea.....I certainly don' think Craig Monroe is the greatest Tiger on the list.....lol
1. LF-Craig Monroe 2006  2. CF-Curtis Granderson 2006  3. RF-Magglio Ordonez 2006  4. 3B-Brandon Inge 2006  5. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  6. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  7. 1B-Darrell Evans 1984  8. C-Lance Parrish 1984  9. P-Morris,Petry,Wilcox,Lopez,Hernandez 1984  10. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  
Was this comment...? Smart Funny Bold Poor
#2 | 62 days ago

 +2 thumbs upI am not a Tiger's fan, although I think they are heading back in the right direction after their bad start. I think that if they pick up Hank Greenberg & Charlie Gehringer they will be World Champs !!!!!
1. LF-Larry Herndon 1984  2. CF-Chet Lemon 1984  3. RF-Kirk Gibson 1984  4. 3B-Tom Brookens 1984  5. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  6. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  7. 1B-Darrell Evans 1984  8. C-Lance Parrish 1984  9. P-Morris,Petry,Wilcox,Lopez,Hernandez 1984  10. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  
Was this comment...? Smart(1) Funny(1) Bold Poor
#3 | 62 days ago

 +3 thumbs upI'd drop both LF's and keep Gibson AND Magglio. That's a no-brainer.
1. RF-Kirk Gibson 1984  2. RF-Magglio Ordonez 2006  3. CF-Curtis Granderson 2006  4. 3B-Brandon Inge 2006  5. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  6. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  7. 1B-Darrell Evans 1984  8. C-Pudge Rodriguez 2006  9. P-Morris,Petry,Wilcox,Lopez,Hernandez 1984  10. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  
Was this comment...? Smart(3) Funny Bold Poor
#4 | 62 days ago

 +4 thumbs upI went with all of the 1984 guys because they actually won the World Series.  I know guys like Mags and Pudge are better than the "other" guys at those positions but obviously they(the '84 Tigers) had the chemistry and talent to win it all in '84.

I know... I'm a buzzkill.
1. RF-Kirk Gibson 1984  2. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  3. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  4. LF-Larry Herndon 1984  5. CF-Chet Lemon 1984  6. 1B-Darrell Evans 1984  7. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  8. P-Morris,Petry,Wilcox,Lopez,Hernandez 1984  9. C-Lance Parrish 1984  10. 3B-Tom Brookens 1984  
Was this comment...? Smart(4) Funny Bold Poor
#5 | 62 days ago

 EdSpeshel wrote:
I went with all of the 1984 guys because they actually won the World Series.  I know guys like Mags and Pudge are better than the "other" guys at those positions but obviously they(the '84 Tigers) had the chemistry and talent to win it all in '84.

I know... I'm a buzzkill.

I agree, you can't argue with results...Bless You Boys!  lol

1. LF-Craig Monroe 2006  2. CF-Curtis Granderson 2006  3. RF-Magglio Ordonez 2006  4. 3B-Brandon Inge 2006  5. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  6. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  7. 1B-Darrell Evans 1984  8. C-Lance Parrish 1984  9. P-Morris,Petry,Wilcox,Lopez,Hernandez 1984  10. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  
Was this comment...? Smart Funny Bold Poor
#6 | 35 days ago

I put them in their position order with the exception of Inge. I picked him since he is a utility though.

1. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  2. P-Bonderman,Rogers,Verlander,Zumaya,Jones 2006  3. C-Pudge Rodriguez 2006  4. 1B-Sean Casey 2006  5. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  6. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  7. LF-Craig Monroe 2006  8. CF-Chet Lemon 1984  9. RF-Kirk Gibson 1984  10. 3B-Brandon Inge 2006  
Was this comment...? Smart Funny Bold Poor
#7 | 35 days ago

 EdSpeshel wrote:
I went with all of the 1984 guys because they actually won the World Series.  I know guys like Mags and Pudge are better than the "other" guys at those positions but obviously they(the '84 Tigers) had the chemistry and talent to win it all in '84.

I know... I'm a buzzkill.
+1 thumbs upI did the same thing.....
1. LF-Larry Herndon 1984  2. CF-Chet Lemon 1984  3. RF-Kirk Gibson 1984  4. 3B-Tom Brookens 1984  5. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  6. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  7. 1B-Darrell Evans 1984  8. C-Lance Parrish 1984  9. P-Morris,Petry,Wilcox,Lopez,Hernandez 1984  10. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  
Was this comment...? Smart(1) Funny Bold Poor
#8 | 35 days ago

 Anthonyg7575 wrote:
I did the same thing.....
You must be a buzzkill too.
1. RF-Kirk Gibson 1984  2. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  3. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  4. LF-Larry Herndon 1984  5. CF-Chet Lemon 1984  6. 1B-Darrell Evans 1984  7. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  8. P-Morris,Petry,Wilcox,Lopez,Hernandez 1984  9. C-Lance Parrish 1984  10. 3B-Tom Brookens 1984  
Was this comment...? Smart Funny Bold Poor
#9 | 34 days ago

 EdSpeshel wrote:
You must be a buzzkill too.
+1 thumbs upNot a buzzkill, I simply look at the facts. The 1984 Tigers won the World Series, the 2006 didn't. End of story.
1. LF-Larry Herndon 1984  2. CF-Chet Lemon 1984  3. RF-Kirk Gibson 1984  4. 3B-Tom Brookens 1984  5. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  6. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  7. 1B-Darrell Evans 1984  8. C-Lance Parrish 1984  9. P-Morris,Petry,Wilcox,Lopez,Hernandez 1984  10. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  
Was this comment...? Smart(1) Funny Bold Poor
#10 | 34 days ago

 +1 thumbs upMan, see this is why I dislike polls like this. It give morons too many options and they get confused.  Granderson is the Centerfielder and leadoff man. Sweet Lou bats 2nd. Tramm is 3rd . Darrell Evans at 1st batting cleanup. You drop the rest of those scrub outfielders and start Maggs and Gibby. Herndon? Monroe? Lemon? ok. Anyways back to the Lineup Maggs batts 5th and plays right. DROP INGE and play Tram at short, Guillen at 3rd. Hello? Guillen at 3rd batting 6th. I love Pudge but you gotta go with Parrish in 84, catching and batting 7th. Gibby in left batting 8th, unless you'd rather have Monroe, Herndon, etc. The rotation from 06 is much better than 84. Ane how can you not pick Sparky to manage the bunch. I'll miss Leylands chain smoking and mumbling at press conferences, but we'll make em a bench coach. There it its folks. Feel free to bash. Im out.
1. CF-Curtis Granderson 2006  2. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  3. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  4. 1B-Darrell Evans 1984  5. RF-Magglio Ordonez 2006  6. SS-Carlos Guillen 2006  7. C-Lance Parrish 1984  8. RF-Kirk Gibson 1984  9. P-Bonderman,Rogers,Verlander,Zumaya,Jones 2006  10. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  
Was this comment...? Smart(1) Funny Bold Poor
#11 | 33 days ago

 I went all '84.  I didn't even realize it until I was done!  They did win the series though.
1. LF-Larry Herndon 1984  2. CF-Chet Lemon 1984  3. RF-Kirk Gibson 1984  4. 3B-Tom Brookens 1984  5. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  6. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  7. 1B-Darrell Evans 1984  8. C-Lance Parrish 1984  9. P-Morris,Petry,Wilcox,Lopez,Hernandez 1984  10. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  
Was this comment...? Smart Funny Bold Poor
#12 | 33 days ago

 I arranged my list as would I have the starting lineup were I in charge of a combined '84/'96 team (although I'm fairly certain that I would pinch hit for Sparky ). 
1. SS-Alan Trammell 1984  2. 2B-Lou Whitaker 1984  3. RF-Kirk Gibson 1984  4. CF-Chet Lemon 1984  5. 1B-Darrell Evans 1984  6. 3B-Brandon Inge 2006  7. LF-Larry Herndon 1984  8. C-Pudge Rodriguez 2006  9. P-Bonderman,Rogers,Verlander,Zumaya,Jones 2006  10. MGR-Sparky Anderson 1984  
Was this comment...? Smart Funny Bold Poor

Post a Comment   Already a user? Sign in here
Join FanIQ - It's Free
FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.
•Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,367,994+ Comments
•Track your game picks - 15,061,845+ Sports Predictions
•Prove you know sports - 81,306+ Trivia Questions
•Find fans of your teams - 3,529,642+ New Friends
Polls You Might Like

Baseballs Odd Stats Old and New
Asked by $Big BANK Bob$ | MLB, MIL, DET | 1 questions asked 08/20/08
14 opinions | 7 comments | Last by dave_brackett
TWINS BASEBALL POLL--(9/5) VS DETROIT TIGERS
Asked by jengirrl2007 | MLB, DET, MIN | 8 questions asked 08/06/08
48 predictions | Last by Scott | 9 hours left
TWINS BASEBALL POLL--(9/7) VS DETROIT TIGERS
Asked by jengirrl2007 | MLB, DET, MIN | 8 questions asked 08/08/08
8 predictions | Last by Nick S
TWINS BASEBALL POLL--(9/6) VS DETROIT TIGERS
Asked by jengirrl2007 | MLB, DET, MIN | 8 questions asked 08/07/08
8 predictions | Last by Nick S
9/7 - Chasing Joe D, The FanIQ Hitting Streak
Asked by tpowell25 | MLB | 3 questions asked Today
9 predictions | 1 comment | Last by GFinn