Worst superbowl quarterback starter

You Might Like

More Polls By: wyldePHX

Who liked it? 20

Jahiegel (+)
Green Bay Packers

sportsgnork (+)
Green Bay Packers

Southern Lion (+)
Houston Texans

Soxfest (+)
Chicago Bears

forrest_viv (+)
Dallas Cowboys

bhopp4p1 (+)
Buffalo Bills

Damondogg31 (+)
Dallas Cowboys

majikmanseven (+)
Green Bay Packers

Roe (+)
Atlanta Falcons

DiabloLoco (+)
New York Giants

... and 10 other fans

NFL Results Skip to Next Poll »

Like it?

Worst superbowl quarterback starter (Edited 05/03/08 03:44PM by Seth)

Read the Article: ESPN's worst superbowl quarterback starter

| Closed on 07/05/08 at 11:45PM
FanIQ Pts? No | NFL | Multiple Choice Opinion Poll

81 Fans
1%	a. Joe Kapp (iv Vikings)
2%	b. Craig Morton (v Cowboys, xii Broncos)
0%	c. Billy Kilmer (vii Redskins)
2%	d. Vince Ferragamo (xiv Rams)
5%	e. David Woodley (xvii Dolphins)
9%	f. Tony Eason (xx Patriots)
2%	g. Stan Humphries (xxix Chargers)
7%	h. Neil O' Donnell (xxx Steelers)
4%	i. Chris Chandler (xxxii Falcons)
16%	j. Trent Dilfer (xxxv Ravens)
5%	k. Kerry Collins (xxx Giants)
1%	l. Rich Gannon (xxxvii Raiders)
40%	m. Rex Grossman (xli Bears)
5%	n. Other: (Please List)

	&nbp;
TOP COMMENT
#1 \| 154 days ago jrgriffey (+)	+11 I just picked the only girl on the list Rex Grossman (xli Bears)
	Was this comment...? (11)


53 Comments \| Sorted by Most Recent First \| Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 \| 154 days ago jrgriffey (+)	+11 I just picked the only girl on the list Rex Grossman (xli Bears)
	Was this comment...? (11)
#2 \| 154 days ago Pat (+)	+1 Yup...Eason was pretty awful. He wasn't even good OUT of the Super Bowl either. I DID like seeing who got the #10 spot though...it's nice to see someone else acknowledge what I've been saying for years. Other: (Please List)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#3 \| 154 days ago Pat (+)	+1 How come Roethlisberger was on ESPN's list, but you left him off of yours? That was pretty disappointing. Other: (Please List)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#4 \| 154 days ago wyldePHX (+)	Pat wrote: How come Roethlisberger was on ESPN's list, but you left him off of yours? That was pretty disappointing. He hasn't had enough time to prove himself yet. Also he's a better general QB than most of the listed non-rememberable players. Tony Eason (xx Patriots)
	Was this comment...?
#5 \| 154 days ago kramer (+)	Pat wrote: How come Roethlisberger was on ESPN's list, but you left him off of yours? That was pretty disappointing. Maybe that's because Ben didn't single-handedly throw away the game. Neil O' Donnell (xxx Steelers)
	Was this comment...?
#6 \| 153 days ago vindog (+)	+1 forgot about Tony Eason; the only QB in NFL history to not complete at least 1 pass in a Superbowl game>>>>. Trent Dilfer (xxxv Ravens)
	Was this comment...? (1) (1)
#7 \| 153 days ago scottraven (+)	+1 Had to put mr fumbleitis Morton in at number one. Craig was practically worthless for the Broncos in that game, against his former team, the Cowboys. Of course, losing two super bowls for two different teams doesn't help, but considering he had no TDs and 4 picks in the second Super Bowl. Craig Morton (v Cowboys, xii Broncos)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#8 \| 153 days ago JRE1969 (+)	David Woodley sucked, this should be a lay-up, come on people. David Woodley (xvii Dolphins)
	Was this comment...?
#9 \| 153 days ago khova22 (+)	grossman besides odonnel probably had tha best stats outta all of em(thats jus at tha top of my head didnt look at tha stats) Rich Gannon (xxxvii Raiders)
	Was this comment...?
#10 \| 153 days ago Pat (+)	kramer wrote: Maybe that's because Ben didn't single-handedly throw away the game. +1 But he damn sure tried, didn't he? Other: (Please List)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#11 \| 153 days ago kramer (+)	Pat wrote: But he damn sure tried, didn't he? Hmm, the guy I picked threw 3 interceptions, 2 directly to the same guy, which both led to TDs. No, he really wasn't even close. Neil O' Donnell (xxx Steelers)
	Was this comment...?
#12 \| 153 days ago Pat (+)	kramer wrote: Hmm, the guy I picked threw 3 interceptions, 2 directly to the same guy, which both led to TDs. No, he really wasn't even close. +1 For the record, the only reason Ben didn't actually cost them the game was the officiating...easily the worst in SB history. Other: (Please List)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#13 \| 153 days ago kramer (+)	Pat wrote: For the record, the only reason Ben didn't actually cost them the game was the officiating...easily the worst in SB history. For the record, Matt Hasselbeck and Mike Holmgren didn't help matters either...and neither did Josh Brown. Last time I checked, they weren't the refs. Neil O' Donnell (xxx Steelers)
	Was this comment...?
#14 \| 153 days ago Pat (+)	kramer wrote: For the record, Matt Hasselbeck and Mike Holmgren didn't help matters either...and neither did Josh Brown. Last time I checked, they weren't the refs. I'm not saying they were stellar...only that the officiating was bad enough that it could have made the difference. I believe it's safe to say that neither team really DESERVED to walk away with a trophy after that game. Easily the most miserable Super Bowl game I've ever witnessed. Other: (Please List)
	Was this comment...?
#15 \| 153 days ago kramer (+)	+2 I know there were questionable calls on both sides of the ball, the problem is people fail to realize 2 things when it came to the Seahawks scoring. 1. Josh Brown missed 2 field goals in a dome, and distance wasn't his problem. 2. Hasselbeck called audibles to Holmgren at the end of both halves. The Seahawks were marching right down the field at the end of the first half, and I believe they could've scored a TD pretty easily if they wouldn't have wasted time with the audibles. That would be 17 points, add up the 6 points for the 2 FGs Josh Brown kicks through the uprights if he had any sense of accuracy, and that's 23 for the Seahawks. The officiating wasn't the greatest, but the Seahawks couldn't cap off a drive because of their own mistakes which weren't called as penalties, although Holmgren & Hasselbeck should've been penalized for stupidity with those audibles. I believe that cost Seattle 7 points at the end of the first half. Neil O' Donnell (xxx Steelers)
	Was this comment...? (2)
#16 \| 153 days ago azcardsfan (+)	+2 Man I wish I could say Jim Hart, but my Cards never even sniffed a super bowl Tony Eason (xx Patriots)
	Was this comment...? (1) (1)
#17 \| 153 days ago Chaseisawsome19 (+)	+1 Im still not sure why Rex is in the NFL? Rex Grossman (xli Bears)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#18 \| 151 days ago Keeter (+)	+3 How 'bout these doozies: - Earl Morrall, SB 3. 6 outta 17 for 71 yards, 0 TD, 3 int, passer rating of 9.3 - Kerry Collins, SB 35. 15 outta 39 for 112, 0 TD, 4 int, passer rating of 7.1 - Fran Tarkenton, SB 9. 11 outta 26 for 102, 0 TD, 3 int, passer rating of 14.1 - John Elway, SB 24. 10 outta 26 for 108, 0 TD, 2 int, passer rating of 19.4 (and the worst for last, in terms of lowest QB rating ever in a SB) - Craig Morton, SB 12. 4 outta 15 for 39, 0 TD, 4 int, passer rating of 0. Yup....zero ! For the record, Grossman was 19 outta 28 for 165, 1 TD, 2 ints, rating of 68.3. Could've been better, but certainly not the worst. Woodley SB 17, 4 outta 14 for 97, 1 TD, 1 int, rating of 50 Roethlesberger (spell check...) SB 40, was 9 outta 21 for 123, 0 TD, 2 int, rating of 22.6. Dilfer SB 35, 12 outta 25 for 153, 0 TD, 1 int, rating of 50.9 Kilmer SB 7, was 14 outta 28 for 104, 0 TD, 3 int, rating 19.6 Elway (again) SB 22, 14 outta 38 for 257, 1 TD, 3 int, rating 36.8 Eason SB20, was 0 outta 6, obviously 0 yards, rating 39.6 (0 ints saved his @ss). (In fact, Eason holds the record for most passes in a SB without a completion) The defense rests.............. David Woodley (xvii Dolphins)
	Was this comment...? (2)
#19 \| 151 days ago Beaneaters (+)	+1 I never liked him as the tv show, "Hulk", either. Vince Ferragamo (xiv Rams)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#20 \| 151 days ago derms33 (+)	+2 I should have went O'Donnell, but he played awesome for the Cowboys! Rex Grossman (xli Bears)
	Was this comment...? (2) (1)
#21 \| 151 days ago kramer (+)	derms33 wrote: I should have went O'Donnell, but he played awesome for the Cowboys! +2 I wanted to PQ this so bad, but damnit I laughed. Neil O' Donnell (xxx Steelers)
	Was this comment...? (2)
#22 \| 150 days ago YankeeDudeL (+)	I had to go w/ Collins. Seriously, I think he got into a bad way w/ some worse people, and threw the game. Twice it said he threw 4 ints, but I remember 5. Of course, by the end of that night I was pretty well trashed. Kerry Collins (xxx Giants)
	Was this comment...?
#23 \| 148 days ago Gazzo (+)	khova22 wrote: grossman besides odonnel probably had tha best stats outta all of em(thats jus at tha top of my head didnt look at tha stats) +1 Rich Gannon? Really? How can you call him the worst to ever start a Super Bowl? Rex Grossman (xli Bears)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#24 \| 148 days ago Gazzo (+)	I don't really think there is a competition here. Grossman takes it hands down. How he is still an NFL QB is beyond me. Rex Grossman (xli Bears)
	Was this comment...?
#25 \| 148 days ago majikmanseven (+)	Keeter wrote: How 'bout these doozies: - Earl Morrall, SB 3. 6 outta 17 for 71 yards, 0 TD, 3 int, passer rating of 9.3 - Kerry Collins, SB 35. 15 outta 39 for 112, 0 TD, 4 int, passer rating of 7.1 - Fran Tarkenton, SB 9. 11 outta 26 for 102, 0 TD, 3 int, passer rating of 14.1 - John Elway, SB 24. 10 outta 26 for 108, 0 TD, 2 int, passer rating of 19.4 (and the worst for last, in terms of lowest QB rating ever in a SB) - Craig Morton, SB 12. 4 outta 15 for 39, 0 TD, 4 int, passer rating of 0. Yup....zero ! For the record, Grossman was 19 outta 28 for 165, 1 TD, 2 ints, rating of 68.3. Could've been better, but certainly not the worst. Woodley SB 17, 4 outta 14 for 97, 1 TD, 1 int, rating of 50 Roethlesberger (spell check...) SB 40, was 9 outta 21 for 123, 0 TD, 2 int, rating of 22.6. Dilfer SB 35, 12 outta 25 for 153, 0 TD, 1 int, rating of 50.9 Kilmer SB 7, was 14 outta 28 for 104, 0 TD, 3 int, rating 19.6 Elway (again) SB 22, 14 outta 38 for 257, 1 TD, 3 int, rating 36.8 Eason SB20, was 0 outta 6, obviously 0 yards, rating 39.6 (0 ints saved his @ss). (In fact, Eason holds the record for most passes in a SB without a completion) The defense rests.............. +1 I took this post to be the worst QB overall to start a Super Bowl... not which QB had the worst game in a Super Bowl. And, as much as I wanted to vote Woodley or Dilfer ... overall, GRossman ended up with my vote. Rex Grossman (xli Bears)
	Was this comment...? (1)
#26 \| 148 days ago Gazzo (+)	Keeter wrote: How 'bout these doozies: - Earl Morrall, SB 3. 6 outta 17 for 71 yards, 0 TD, 3 int, passer rating of 9.3 - Kerry Collins, SB 35. 15 outta 39 for 112, 0 TD, 4 int, passer rating of 7.1 - Fran Tarkenton, SB 9. 11 outta 26 for 102, 0 TD, 3 int, passer rating of 14.1 - John Elway, SB 24. 10 outta 26 for 108, 0 TD, 2 int, passer rating of 19.4 (and the worst for last, in terms of lowest QB rating ever in a SB) - Craig Morton, SB 12. 4 outta 15 for 39, 0 TD, 4 int, passer rating of 0. Yup....zero ! For the record, Grossman was 19 outta 28 for 165, 1 TD, 2 ints, rating of 68.3. Could've been better, but certainly not the worst. Woodley SB 17, 4 outta 14 for 97, 1 TD, 1 int, rating of 50 Roethlesberger (spell check...) SB 40, was 9 outta 21 for 123, 0 TD, 2 int, rating of 22.6. Dilfer SB 35, 12 outta 25 for 153, 0 TD, 1 int, rating of 50.9 Kilmer SB 7, was 14 outta 28 for 104, 0 TD, 3 int, rating 19.6 Elway (again) SB 22, 14 outta 38 for 257, 1 TD, 3 int, rating 36.8 Eason SB20, was 0 outta 6, obviously 0 yards, rating 39.6 (0 ints saved his @ss). (In fact, Eason holds the record for most passes in a SB without a completion) The defense rests.............. I too didn't look at this as the worst Super Bowl stats by a QB. I don't think that is the question. I simply answered based on (just like majikmanseven) the worst overall QB to start a Super Bowl. Rex Grossman (xli Bears)
	Was this comment...?
#27 \| 148 days ago Keeter (+)	+2 OK, good point - then I really like my Woodley pick....let's analyze (leading into their SB): - Grossman: 54.3% completions, 27 TD/26 int, rating 71.7 - Woodley: 53.6% completions, 31 TD/38 int, rating 65.4 - Ferragamo: 47.6% completions, 7 TD/12 int, rating 53.8 - Eason: 57.1% completions, 35 TD/30 int, rating 79.4 - Dilfer: 56.9% completions, 82 TD/91 int, rating 72.0 - Collins: 53.7% completions, 81 TD/88