Who is the better player for the Red Sox or the Yankees? - MLB, Boston Red Sox, New York Yankees

Asked by: leeharalabidis (+)

» Contact me
» Send Gift

» me

Answers Created: 1218
Mike Bryan

Last Answer: dasoxfan24 (+)

» Contact me
» Send Gift

» me

Answers: 5
Boston Red Sox

Who liked it? 61

Cardsfan5 (+)
St. Louis Cardinals

LLUmpJimWard (+)
Boston Red Sox

blondie45044 (+)
Detroit Red Wings

DckyJay (+)
Pittsburgh Pirates

LBCfan (+)
Los Angeles Angels

MileHighManiac (+)
Colorado Rockies

Hec718 (+)
New York Yankees

coyotedances (+)
Chicago Cubs

redsox1002003 (+)
Boston Red Sox

luvdemREDSOX (+)
Boston Red Sox

... and 51 other fans

« MLB Polls | Skip to Next Poll »

61	Who is the better player for the Red Sox or the Yankees? Who has the better players. FanIQ Pts? No \| MLB, Boston Red Sox, New York Yankees \| Closes 38 days \| Multiple Choice Opinion Poll

	&nbp;
TOP COMMENT
(4) This comment was voted poor quality by FanIQ (Show anyway)
#1 \| 203 days ago qtowndogg (+)	I don't like either team, but I just noticed that I picked all Red Sox. Enter the poll to see my answer
	11


37 Comments \| Sorted by Most Recent First \| Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
(4) This comment was voted poor quality by FanIQ (Show anyway)
#1 \| 203 days ago qtowndogg (+)	I don't like either team, but I just noticed that I picked all Red Sox. Enter the poll to see my answer
	11
(6) This comment was voted poor quality by FanIQ (Show anyway)
#2 \| 185 days ago dragonzblade3232 (+)	qtowndogg wrote: I don't like either team, but I just noticed that I picked all Red Sox. Posada better then Varitek, Matsui better the Ortiz, Mark better then Kevin lol you don't know your sports your stupid Enter the poll to see my answer
	2
#3 \| 185 days ago derms33 (+)	6. can I get a neither? Enter the poll to see my answer
	2
#4 \| 185 days ago Kmacnealy1 (+)	i don't know how Ortiz can be picked as best DH at this time, he is deffinetly not the threat he used to be and is not making any kind of contact at crucial times. Voting is done by what the player is doing at the moment, not over his career. Though I don't like Matsui, he is producing better at this time. Just as veritek against Posada. In career, Posada may get nod but not at this moment. Vote with the performance, not with your hearts. Enter the poll to see my answer
	6
#5 \| 183 days ago leeharalabidis (+)	dragonzblade3232 wrote: Posada better then Varitek, Matsui better the Ortiz, Mark better then Kevin lol you don't know your sports your stupid Says the yankee fan.
	4
#6 \| 183 days ago dragonzblade3232 (+)	leeharalabidis wrote: Says the yankee fan. Fact Ortiz is washed up he gonna get traded lol Posada is way better then Varitek and Mark a superstar he better then Kevin that fact nothing from a Yankee fan seam like non Yankee fans are slow Enter the poll to see my answer
	3
#7 \| 182 days ago seanrrpsnm (+)	posada is dfinately better than varitek.........hands down! Enter the poll to see my answer
	7
#8 \| 182 days ago leeharalabidis (+)	dragonzblade3232 wrote: Fact Ortiz is washed up he gonna get traded lol Posada is way better then Varitek and Mark a superstar he better then Kevin that fact nothing from a Yankee fan seam like non Yankee fans are slow Posada is always injured, Big Papi is getting there, and Kevin Youkilis is a gold glover and is pretty close to the level of Mark.
	2
#9 \| 182 days ago Brendanc8504 (+)	seanrrpsnm wrote: posada is dfinately better than varitek.........hands down! you lost all cred. when you said Cano is better then pedroia. Frankly, I dont even think its close anywhere but first base, and I almost picked youk. Enter the poll to see my answer
	2
#10 \| 182 days ago dserra (+)	Brendanc8504 wrote: you lost all cred. when you said Cano is better then pedroia. Frankly, I dont even think its close anywhere but first base, and I almost picked youk. says the sox fan Enter the poll to see my answer
	3
#11 \| 182 days ago Brendanc8504 (+)	dserra wrote: says the sox fan says the ~~sox fan~~ 2007 Rookie of the Year trophy and the 2008 MVP Trophy! Fixed it. Enter the poll to see my answer
	2
#12 \| 182 days ago dserra (+)	Brendanc8504 wrote: says the ~~sox fan~~ 2007 Rookie of the Year trophy and the 2008 MVP Trophy! Fixed it. true but 2 years ago means nothing cause cano will be league MVP this year Enter the poll to see my answer
	2
#13 \| 182 days ago keppieboy (+)	Who has the better waterboy? Enter the poll to see my answer
	1
#14 \| 182 days ago Brendanc8504 (+)	dserra wrote: true but 2 years ago means nothing cause cano will be league MVP this year I would argue that Cano wont even be MVP of the Yankees, never mind the American league Enter the poll to see my answer
	3
#15 \| 179 days ago Kmacnealy1 (+)	OK Die hard fans, Ortiz better? his .189 average so NOOOOOO but he does break a mean bat! Posada? hasn't played since May 4th! would'nt you have to actually play to be the better player? Enter the poll to see my answer
	5
#16 \| 179 days ago Brendanc8504 (+)	Kmacnealy1 wrote: OK Die hard fans, Ortiz better? his .189 average so NOOOOOO but he does break a mean bat! Posada? hasn't played since May 4th! would'nt you have to actually play to be the better player? Ok, if you want to compare this seasons numbers there is no question ortiz blows. He will work through it though. I dont care any other day I wouldnt trade Matsui for Ortiz. Enter the poll to see my answer
	3
#17 \| 132 days ago MarkTheShark (+)	I'd take Crawford and Upton over any Red Sox or Yankees OF's: They are both better defensively than anyone on the Yankees or Sawx and frankly, it's not even close. Crawford and Bay are different animals at the plate: if you need a guy to score you a run it's CC, to drive in a run: Bay.
	2
#18 \| 132 days ago bubas38 (+)	MarkTheShark wrote: I'd take Crawford and Upton over any Red Sox or Yankees OF's: They are both better defensively than anyone on the Yankees or Sawx and frankly, it's not even close. Crawford and Bay are different animals at the plate: if you need a guy to score you a run it's CC, to drive in a run: Bay. I agree Mark I would take Crawford or Upton over any of them How bout the awesome catch Crawford made in AllStar Game Yep that says it all
	1
#19 \| 132 days ago gayskip3girl (+)	MarkTheShark wrote: I'd take Crawford and Upton over any Red Sox or Yankees OF's: They are both better defensively than anyone on the Yankees or Sawx and frankly, it's not even close. Crawford and Bay are different animals at the plate: if you need a guy to score you a run it's CC, to drive in a run: Bay. Crawford and Upton come through on defense and offense so I agree there sin't no better than them too Crawford proves it in ALL STAR game with an awesome catch to ROB the homerun
	1
#20 \| 121 days ago djagameking (+)	Im a giant Yankee fan so I pretty much said everyone for the Yankees. Almost everyone. I think Dustin Pedroia has a little bit more talent. I tried to be honest with the poll but everything kept draging me to the Yankees. Once a Yankee fan, always a Yankee fan. Enter the poll to see my answer
	1
#21 \| 112 days ago tigger88 (+)	I hate both teams, Justin Morneau and Joe Mauer are better than any player on the Yanks or sox except Derek Jeter

#22 \| 112 days ago dragonzblade3232 (+)	(Edited by dragonzblade3232) tigger88 wrote: I hate both teams, Justin Morneau and Joe Mauer are better than any player on the Yanks or sox except Derek Jeter LOL ALEX is better then Justin Morneus Joe Mauer and Derek Jeter if you don't think he is you never seen him play he is one of the top two baseball players in the game his number are scary good he a few homerun short of everyone and he did it in less time and he already has more RBI's then Derek Jeter also home runs and he been very clutch and he hits the ball as good or better then anyone else in the American League if you don't think so you really don't have a clue also he plays a harder fielding postion well beside catcher but no catcher can be as good as a infielder Enter the poll to see my answer

#23 \| 48 days ago nortonsfury (+)	stricltly by numbers this year. cano had a better year then pedroia, ortiz and matsui were about even, bay was better then damon, tex was better then youk like it or not sox fans dont hate cause he didnt sign with you, ellsbury aint great but gardener doesnt play everyday, posada is leaps and bounds better then varitek (hits, homers, rbi, defense) it aint even close. varitek calls a better game and thats it. its not even up for debate who has the better overall catcher. people shade to their favorites which is unfair. lets be realistic about this though Enter the poll to see my answer

#24 \| 48 days ago MarkTheShark (+)	nortonsfury wrote: stricltly by numbers this year. cano had a better year then pedroia, ortiz and matsui were about even, bay was better then damon, tex was better then youk like it or not sox fans dont hate cause he didnt sign with you, ellsbury aint great but gardener doesnt play everyday, posada is leaps and bounds better then varitek (hits, homers, rbi, defense) it aint even close. varitek calls a better game and thats it. its not even up for debate who has the better overall catcher. people shade to their favorites which is unfair. lets be realistic about this though ..and Ben Zobrist had a better year than Cano and Pedroia
	1
#25 \| 48 days ago nortonsfury (+)	nortonsfury wrote: stricltly by numbers this year. cano had a better year then pedroia, ortiz and matsui were about even, bay was better then damon, tex was better then youk like it or not sox fans dont hate cause he didnt sign with you, ellsbury aint great but gardener doesnt play everyday, posada is leaps and bounds better then varitek (hits, homers, rbi, defense) it aint even close. varitek calls a better game and thats it. its not even up for debate who has the better overall catcher. people shade to their favorites which is unfair. lets be realistic about this though he wasnt part of the question. i agree with you though Enter the poll to see my answer
	1
#26 \| 46 days ago ohwell1219 (+)	(Edited by ohwell1219) oops, i was distracted, had to pay the Yankee fan at the door for the pizza Enter the poll to see my answer

#27 \| 46 days ago MarkTheShark (+)	ohwell1219 wrote: oops, i was distracted, had to pay the Yankee fan at the door for the pizza I'm sorry about your friend...had he been racing a long time?

#28 \| 46 days ago ohwell1219 (+)	ohwell1219 wrote: oops, i was distracted, had to pay the Yankee fan at the door for the pizza yes, thanks for your comment Enter the poll to see my answer

#29 \| 33 days ago LLUmpJimWard (+)	I can understand a lot of things, but I can't seem to find why the unbiased baseball fan in Boston wouldn't take Posada, Teixiera, and Matsui over Ortiz, Varitek, and Youkillis. I can understand the Youkillis/Teixiera discussion. You can't go wrong with either guy at 1st Base. Get a grip Sox Nation! A couple of years ago there would be no comparison when Papi and Tek were playing out of their cleats, but today is a different story. While I am very happy that Tek and Papi have given me great enjoyment watching them play in the Red Sox uniform, I have to face facts that Posada and Matsui today are the better choices. Posada, although having injury problems of his own, has given the Bombers better stability behind the dish and a consistant bat in the line up. Matsui is definately a better choice for the simple fact that he can play defense on a near daily basis and has always had a solid stick at the plate. So, in my mind, there really is no discussion here! Tek and Ortiz, although having had fine years with Boston, are today second fiddle to Posada and Matsui. Enter the poll to see my answer
	2
#30 \| 23 days ago carlalbert64 (+)	LLUmpJimWard wrote: I can understand a lot of things, but I can't seem to find why the unbiased baseball fan in Boston wouldn't take Posada, Teixiera, and Matsui over Ortiz, Varitek, and Youkillis. I can understand the Youkillis/Teixiera discussion. You can't go wrong with either guy at 1st Base. Get a grip Sox Nation! A couple of years ago there would be no comparison when Papi and Tek were playing out of their cleats, but today is a different story. While I am very happy that Tek and Papi have given me great enjoyment watching them play in the Red Sox uniform, I have to face facts that Posada and Matsui today are the better choices. Posada, although having injury problems of his own, has given the Bombers better stability behind the dish and a consistant bat in the line up. Matsui is definately a better choice for the simple fact that he can play defense on a near daily basis and has always had a solid stick at the plate. So, in my mind, there really is no discussion here! Tek and Ortiz, although having had fine years with Boston, are today second fiddle to Posada and Matsui. I disagree on only one point.... I think Varitek is a better catcher then Posada. I would agree Varitek's bat has dropped of the last couple of season but his value with the pitching staff is incredible...... Enter the poll to see my answer

#31 \| 22 days ago wayne4461 (+)	MarkTheShark wrote: I'd take Crawford and Upton over any Red Sox or Yankees OF's: They are both better defensively than anyone on the Yankees or Sawx and frankly, it's not even close. Crawford and Bay are different animals at the plate: if you need a guy to score you a run it's CC, to drive in a run: Bay. well guess what, they weren't a choice Enter the poll to see my answer

#32 \| 22 days ago wayne4461 (+)	Ortiz is washed up. Maybe he can go to the Dodgers with Manny and bring the Dodgers down worse then they are now Enter the poll to see my answer

#33 \| 22 days ago MarkTheShark (+)	wayne4461 wrote: well guess what, they weren't a choice Right, but the freaking MOMENT Carl Crawford becomes either a Yankee or Red Sox then he will be hailed as one of the best players in the majors...hilarious

#34 \| 22 days ago wayne4461 (+)	MarkTheShark wrote: Right, but the freaking MOMENT Carl Crawford becomes either a Yankee or Red Sox then he will be hailed as one of the best players in the majors...hilarious i'm not saying he's not good, just that he wasn't a choice Enter the poll to see my answer

#35 \| 20 days ago LLUmpJimWard (+)	carlalbert64 wrote: I disagree on only one point.... I think Varitek is a better catcher then Posada. I would agree Varitek's bat has dropped of the last couple of season but his value with the pitching staff is incredible...... I agree with you on Tek's handling of pitchers. He is without a doubt the best in this part of his game. He just needs to find a bat that works! Maybe he should be allowed to use an alluminum bat! LOL! Enter the poll to see my answer

#36 \| 13 days ago beccahi (+)	dragonzblade3232 wrote: Posada better then Varitek, Matsui better the Ortiz, Mark better then Kevin lol you don't know your sports your stupid Posada and Tex are better but I'm not sure about Matsui, you've got to be fair... Enter the poll to see my answer

#37 \| 9 days ago vindog (+)	The Yankees have the better players in the infield, the Red Sox have the better outfield and the pitching is relatively a wash! Enter the poll to see my answer