Please sign in to complete your action
 
DONE!
Cheer and debate with
6,000,000+ fans!
My Team:
Charlotte
My Team:
Michael
My Team:
Britney
Asked by: johnshirey54 (+)

» Contact me
» Send Gift
Answers Created: 991
Florida Gators



Last Answer: grampamurdoc (+)
grampamurdoc (Murray) profile photo
» Contact me
» Send Gift
Answers: 37
Minnesota Vikings




Who liked it? 33
koko1224 (+)
Minnesota Vikings

jbmyb98 (+)
Minnesota Vikings

summerhorseskate (+)
Atlanta Braves

hwsteelers (+)
Pittsburgh Steelers

tnavrkal (+)
Denver Broncos

Frankie_D (+)
Chicago Bears

dbaker (+)
Pittsburgh Steelers

rogercarver1960 (+)
Chicago Bears

Kmacnealy1 (+)
Pittsburgh Steelers

sharks12 (+)
New York Giants

... and 23 other fans
 « NFL Polls  |  Skip to Next Poll »
33
Where does Brett Favre rank amongst the best ever?
Recently Brett Favre has been the most scrutinized athlete in America, as we all know. Statistically Brett Favre is the best QB ever but stats aren't everything, where do you think Brett ranks amongst the best ever?
FanIQ Pts? No | NFL, Minnesota Vikings | Closes 37 days | Multiple Choice Opinion Poll
Teams:  Brett Favre
Brett is the best ever
Top three
Top five
Top ten
He's not even in the top ten
33

(Caution -- you will be unable to change your answer.)


 &nbp;
TOP COMMENT * * * * * * * * * * * *
#2 | 52 days ago

 I'd like to put him in my bedroom !
18

  
48 Comments | Sorted by Most Recent First | Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 | 52 days ago

 Who?
Enter the poll to see my answer
11

#2 | 52 days ago

 I'd like to put him in my bedroom !
18

#3 | 52 days ago

 he's great n all but he only has one super bowl ring and he's thrown more picks than anybody else n HISTORY so i say he's top five material but thats it. You got Marino, Young, Montana, Staubach, Namath, i'll even say Bart Starr over him
Enter the poll to see my answer
8

#4 | 52 days ago

I may be a little biased because of last week.

Enter the poll to see my answer
4

Poor Quality (5) This comment was voted poor quality by FanIQ (Show anyway)
#6 | 52 days ago

 I like the way Brett plays the game and he is in the top ten for his passion and his most consecutive starts!  He plays the game the way it was meant to be played, or least, how I learned to play it.  It can be fun and a job at the same time!
Enter the poll to see my answer
9

#7 | 52 days ago

 I'm a total homer and I'll admit that freely.  IF he guides the Vikes to a Super Bowl victory, I'll rank him #1!

He'll have the stats at the top in every category, he'll have 2 rings and he'll have done the impossible.  Win a Super Bowl with the Vikings...
Enter the poll to see my answer
8

#8 | 51 days ago

 He has got the numbers and is by far the best ever at UN-retiring!
Enter the poll to see my answer
7

#9 | 51 days ago

 ...Joe Montana is better!
Enter the poll to see my answer
7

#10 | 51 days ago

 Brett is the best QB of all time he holds almost every record there is including most int but still when u put up those kind of numbers who is going to argue and at least he has more ring's than marino he should not be judge by how many Superbowl his team has one it is on a individual performance and there is no one better..... he is still a trader and i hope the pack send him into retirement this weekend .
Enter the poll to see my answer
2

#11 | 51 days ago

 Concerning Brett Favre, I commend him for the comeback and the TD play but I don't think Greg Lewis got enough credit for his catch.  They just gave ALL the praise to Favre...
Enter the poll to see my answer
3

#12 | 51 days ago

 Come people u have to see what he has done for teams he played for he put them in playoffs and has won super bowl me i am just a truck driver but i know a great qb he has to be in the top 3 behind Joe Montana and Terry Bradshaw
Enter the poll to see my answer
6

#13 | 51 days ago

 rspecial wrote:
I'd like to put him in my bedroom !
now thats a thought lol
Enter the poll to see my answer
8

#14 | 51 days ago

 He might be a good QB, but when it comes to being decisive, he doesn't have it, so therefore if he's not a good man to make a decision and stick to it, and stand by his word, then he isn't good enough to be a QB of a team and to lead a team!! It just isn't right and it isn't MANLY!
Enter the poll to see my answer
2

#15 | 51 days ago

 Brett Favre, the last of the great gunslingers is one of the best QBs of all time
Enter the poll to see my answer
6

#16 | 51 days ago

 rspecial wrote:
I'd like to put him in my bedroom !
his body will not work the full time, he is always sore LLOL
nothing worse than getting ready and 'mister' doesnt participate LOLOLOL
Enter the poll to see my answer
4

#17 | 51 days ago

 i just wish he would retire, he is looking pretty sad
Enter the poll to see my answer
5

#18 | 51 days ago

 What criteria are you using? If just stats, He would have to be No.1; If play on the field (what I used), Top 5; he leads teams forward, he has the Big 4 QB stats., he has won a SB( tied with Staubach, Namath, Dawson and I believe Stabler) and appeared in another. How many 4th quarter comebacks? 40? Who do you think made Sterling Sharpe, Sterling Sharpe? or Donald Driver, Donald Driver? He made Mike Holgrem look like a Super Coach (How about them Seahawks!). People "hate" him because of his off field activities which have very little to do with his job as a QB. Please folks judge him on what he does on the field not how he can't make a retirement decision.
Enter the poll to see my answer
8

#19 | 51 days ago

 danzak44 wrote:
He might be a good QB, but when it comes to being decisive, he doesn't have it, so therefore if he's not a good man to make a decision and stick to it, and stand by his word, then he isn't good enough to be a QB of a team and to lead a team!! It just isn't right and it isn't MANLY!
So for 16 years he was good but now he can't lead a team? If that was the case why did his GM in Green Bay make stipulations in the Jets trade he couldn't be traded to Minn.? I'm sorry but he can still lead a team and GB front office knew it otherwise why would they care if he went to Minn.?
Enter the poll to see my answer
5

#20 | 51 days ago

 His actions as of late have tainted my thoughts on Brett. I had always been a fan of him but since he has started this yo-yo mentallity I have knocked him out of the top ten. A QB needs to be a leader on and off the field so what kind of example is he setting didnt get what you want oh well retire and come back when you can get what you want.
Enter the poll to see my answer
2

#21 | 51 days ago

 cowboyeddiej wrote:
His actions as of late have tainted my thoughts on Brett. I had always been a fan of him but since he has started this yo-yo mentallity I have knocked him out of the top ten. A QB needs to be a leader on and off the field so what kind of example is he setting didnt get what you want oh well retire and come back when you can get what you want.
Everyone has an opinion and we must agree to disagree....I just think he shows his leadership on the field which is backed up by comments of his past and current teammates. I invite you took take another look at what and how exactly everything went down starting at the end of the 2007 season in Green Bay.
Enter the poll to see my answer
3

#22 | 51 days ago

 John Madden thinks he is #1.... and turducken. BOOM!
http://blitzmagonline.com/images/sidelines/20941_maddenTurducken3_M.jpg" />
2

#23 | 51 days ago

 (Edited by tonyalibra12)
Bret  needs to retire and learn how to stay retired. What this makes 6 times he has retired, what the deal. /stay booboo stay Forget the stats some people are just tired of him period,  if you say you're going to do something just be like MIKE and  JUST DO IT already  and if you're not quit saying( I"M  RETIRING AGAIN)  Let's make it final.
2

#24 | 50 days ago

 Not before Brady

#25 | 50 days ago

 He breaks a lot of individual records because he has played a long time (many years). In term of ability to consistently lead the team to wins (arguably the most important measure of a QB), there are many more QB's better, to name a few: Staubach, Brady, Montana, Aikman, Unitas, Bradshaw, Elway.
Enter the poll to see my answer
1

#26 | 50 days ago

 the stats  are there   but  you  must  look  at the  entire  package    ---  joe montana   rodger stabach   and terry  bradshaw    joe namiath    ---  if  he  had  to  compete  agaenst  these  guys   i  dont  know  if  he  could  of  held  up  ----   the  defences   were  alot  tougher  back  then!!!!
Enter the poll to see my answer
3

#27 | 50 days ago

 Top 10 .... Umm maybe?
Enter the poll to see my answer
3

#28 | 49 days ago

 danzak44 wrote:
He might be a good QB, but when it comes to being decisive, he doesn't have it, so therefore if he's not a good man to make a decision and stick to it, and stand by his word, then he isn't good enough to be a QB of a team and to lead a team!! It just isn't right and it isn't MANLY!
Even though he won tonight, it still puts alot of doubt towards him being able to still do the job. If I had a sergeant that was that indecisive, I probably would've smacked him upside the head!
Enter the poll to see my answer
2

#29 | 49 days ago

 ladybost1 wrote:
his body will not work the full time, he is always sore LLOL
nothing worse than getting ready and 'mister' doesnt participate LOLOLOL
Oh well I could dream about it, if it doesn't rise tonight !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LMAO
2

#30 | 49 days ago

 danzak44 wrote:
Even though he won tonight, it still puts alot of doubt towards him being able to still do the job. If I had a sergeant that was that indecisive, I probably would've smacked him upside the head!
I must have been watching a different game.......3 TDs, 0 int., 270+ yards passing,  where was the indecision? 

Drop and give me 20 for that statement.......LOL
Enter the poll to see my answer
2

#31 | 49 days ago

 He's my fave QB, but his passion for winning can get him into trouble quite often. His eyes are at times bigger than his stomach, which is why I love him so, but taking risks messes up the stats sometimes, so I can't in all honesty name him the greatest ever, but lord knows I want to.
Enter the poll to see my answer
1

#32 | 49 days ago

 Longevity aside, he is one of the best if not the best at improvising when a play breaks down ( compareable to Elway). Arm strength, right with Marino. Leadership, no one touches Johnny U! Ability to change a teams attitude ( remeber what the Jets were before he got there?) and what he is doing in Minn. making everyone on both sides better. He has got to be top three
Johnny U-1
Favre-2
Tarkington-3
Montana-4
Enter the poll to see my answer
5

#33 | 49 days ago

 you neglected to mention one thing- who would you have handed the ball off to? do you remember the running Backs that he had to work with in GB? I can't. The fact that it was given to him to win it tells alot.
Enter the poll to see my answer
2

#34 | 49 days ago

 I think he is a stupid for going to the vikings and winning against us the Packers!!@!!!!!  ughhh
Enter the poll to see my answer
1

#35 | 47 days ago

 ladybost1 wrote:
i just wish he would retire, he is looking pretty sad
what? your comments makes no sense. do you watch brett favre games?
Enter the poll to see my answer
3

#36 | 47 days ago

 Kmacnealy1 wrote:
you neglected to mention one thing- who would you have handed the ball off to? do you remember the running Backs that he had to work with in GB? I can't. The fact that it was given to him to win it tells alot.
fyi, ahman green who was always hurt. great running back for the 3 games a season he was available for. and i think najee davenport was the fullback. he was decent, too i guess if you ignore the fumbles.
Enter the poll to see my answer
2

#37 | 47 days ago

 godisapackerfan wrote:
I think he is a stupid for going to the vikings and winning against us the Packers!!@!!!!!  ughhh
you know what bothers me most about packers fan, i being one of them, but i dont live there, is the fact that you all loved and adored brett as a qb but now too many packers fans hate him. Brett loved yall but he was kinda mistreated by corporate so you all should not have turned on him personally in my opinion. I know you have to hate the vikings, thats a part of the game, but personally speaking, it seems like you all devoloped a serious hate and disrespect for a man who was a great leader for the team. It amazes me everytime i see favre haters from green bay. People say what they will about his age and retirement issues, but he was good to yall and it took only a hot second to throw him to the wolves. i was very disappointed and shocked by that. i thought he would have been one of those great players who received a warm reception from most, not all, when he returned green bay.  so sad.
Enter the poll to see my answer
4

#38 | 47 days ago

 He might be in the top three during the regular season, but when playoffs come, his interceptions have cost him a lot of playoff wins.  If not for Reggie White running the defense, his Super Bowl win might not have happened.
Enter the poll to see my answer
3

#39 | 47 days ago

 SuperStar123 wrote:
 Like somebody said, "Who?" I could go through a list and put 20 better than him. He is a flake! 
 name them....cause your wrong
Enter the poll to see my answer
4

#40 | 47 days ago

 rogercarver1960 wrote:
He might be in the top three during the regular season, but when playoffs come, his interceptions have cost him a lot of playoff wins.  If not for Reggie White running the defense, his Super Bowl win might not have happened.
but  it did happen. remember that!
Enter the poll to see my answer
1

#41 | 47 days ago

 kobe_lova wrote:
fyi, ahman green who was always hurt. great running back for the 3 games a season he was available for. and i think najee davenport was the fullback. he was decent, too i guess if you ignore the fumbles.
and Dorsey Levins...he had a couple good years
Enter the poll to see my answer
4

#42 | 46 days ago

 mnstar1959 wrote:
and Dorsey Levins...he had a couple good years
OH MY GOODNESS. THANK YOU. I was racking my brain trying to remember dorsey levens. I thought, I know they had a running back that really was good but I just couldnt recall it. good job.
Enter the poll to see my answer

#43 | 46 days ago

 kobe_lova wrote:
OH MY GOODNESS. THANK YOU. I was racking my brain trying to remember dorsey levens. I thought, I know they had a running back that really was good but I just couldnt recall it. good job.
No prob; glad I could help jar your memory...
Enter the poll to see my answer
1

#44 | 42 days ago

 all farve has done is pad his stats against weak nfc north teams
Enter the poll to see my answer
1

#45 | 42 days ago

 truely wrote:
all farve has done is pad his stats against weak nfc north teams
Like the Lions?
Enter the poll to see my answer
2

#46 | 32 days ago

 millie757 wrote:
he's great n all but he only has one super bowl ring and he's thrown more picks than anybody else n HISTORY so i say he's top five material but thats it. You got Marino, Young, Montana, Staubach, Namath, i'll even say Bart Starr over him
when you throw more passes and are put in more positions than anyone you are more likely to throw more picks then anybody. he ALSO threw more touchdowns then anyone in history. more passing yards then anyone in history. more completions then anyone in history. should i go on? only quarterback in history to beat all 32 teams. 3x league MVP. should i keep going at all the positive things he has done?
Enter the poll to see my answer
2

#47 | 32 days ago

 Easily top 3!  Very few experts would even try to disagree! 

Not wanting to retire is something EVERY pro has to deal with, whether they're Flutey Flakes or Smokin Joe!  If him not retiring actually had anything to do with his ability to lead, than the Vikings wouldn't have been pressing him to NOT retire! 

Whether you're a computer salesman or a postal clerk, everyone wants to leave their job believing they went out at the peak of their performance!  He finally got a shot to play on a team with, arguably the best runningback, and with a solid D!  Trent Dilfer would've given up his position in the booth to jump on the shot to play in Minnesota had it been swung his way!!  So, it's not a knock on Favre, even the least bit, that he opted not to retire once again!

AND ... the fact that his team is still undefeated only solidifies his choice!  I feel kind of sorry for the man, because even if he does win the Superbowl this year, and even if he is named the League MVP and Superbowl MVP, he'll still go down in the books by many D-bag fans who are simply butt hurt that he couldn't make up his mind about whether he was done playing or not.

He's going to the Hall!  And, if you were to ask Montana himself, he'd probably say something along the lines of, "Well, you know, I could never throw a ball as far him, nor could I even expect to roll out to the right and lob a pass into a covered receiver's hands down the left sideline, sooooooooooooooo ... in that regard, AT LEAST, ... he's great!"
Enter the poll to see my answer
3

#48 | 6 days ago

 mnstar1959 wrote:
What criteria are you using? If just stats, He would have to be No.1; If play on the field (what I used), Top 5; he leads teams forward, he has the Big 4 QB stats., he has won a SB( tied with Staubach, Namath, Dawson and I believe Stabler) and appeared in another. How many 4th quarter comebacks? 40? Who do you think made Sterling Sharpe, Sterling Sharpe? or Donald Driver, Donald Driver? He made Mike Holgrem look like a Super Coach (How about them Seahawks!). People "hate" him because of his off field activities which have very little to do with his job as a QB. Please folks judge him on what he does on the field not how he can't make a retirement decision.
You speak the truth! More people need to be as open minded as you.If I was Brett ,I'd question retirement,as long as he can enjoy the game and the team he's with...why retire. I like his attitude on the field,always smiling.
Enter the poll to see my answer


Post a Comment   Already a user? Sign in here
Join FanIQ - It's Free
FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.
•Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,649,417+ Comments
•Track your game picks - 38,670,182,382+ Sports Predictions
•Prove you know sports - 116,275+ Trivia Questions
•Find fans of your teams - 11,453,110+ New Friends



Join Today
About FanIQ
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
DMCA Policy
Contact Us
Report A Bug
Help

Copyright 2009 Sportelligence, Inc. All Rights Reserved