Skip to Next Poll »
3
Who do u think is the biggest Goat for the Yankees in Game 5? (Edited 11/03/09 02:23AM by Hec718)
Who's to blame for the loss?
| Closed on 11/04/09 at 08:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | MLB | Multiple Choice Opinion Poll
Team Breakout:
13 Fans 
62%a. Joe Girardi for starting A.J. Burnett on 3 days rest
8%b. Phil Coke for allowing Utley's HR, which proved to be the difference
23%c. Mark Teixeira for not coming through in the 9th with the tying run at the plate (He's batting under .100 in this World Series)
8%d. Derek Jeter for killing the 9th-inning rally by grounding into a Double Play

 &nbp;
TOP COMMENT * * * * * * * * * * * *
#2 | 1630 days ago

My vote goes to anyone wearing pinstripes..... Go Phillies!
  
11 Comments | Sorted by Most Recent First | Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 | 1630 days ago

I have 2 choices, that bum Coke for not being able to get lefties out and Mr. Teixeira who can't hit a beachball with the way he's hitting in this W.S. Had it been A-Rod with an under .100 BA in the W.S. he would've been getting killed by the media and critics. I wana hear people criticize Teixeira.
#2 | 1630 days ago

My vote goes to anyone wearing pinstripes..... Go Phillies!
#3 | 1630 days ago
SuperStar123 (+)

 There really was no goat! With Lee starting the Phillies should have won that one. They have a great team, just not better than this years Yankee's, who have developed into a TEAM! Congratulations Phils fans!    
Joe Girardi for starting A.J. Burnett on 3 days rest  
#4 | 1630 days ago

he should of known better. a.j. is no c.c. , i think joe got a little too cocky.
Joe Girardi for starting A.J. Burnett on 3 days rest  
#5 | 1630 days ago

How can you pitch to this man. I hope they keep it coming. The next game starts off with Utley getting hit by a pitch and then they will walk him the rest of the game. Do you think the Yankees will let a Phillie beat Reggie Jackons record and at Yankee Stadium of all places. Maybe he will break it with a bases loaded grandslam. Go PHILLIES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Phil Coke for allowing Utley's HR, which proved to be the difference  
#6 | 1630 days ago

Game 6 they start off hitting Utley in his first at bat and then they wont pitch to him the rest of the game. The Yankees dont want a Phillie to beat out Reggie Jacksons homerun record and definitly not at Yankee stadium. GO PHILLIES!!!
Phil Coke for allowing Utley's HR, which proved to be the difference  
#7 | 1630 days ago
jigga_2_k (+)

(Edited by jigga_2_k)
SuperStar123 wrote:
 There really was no goat! With Lee starting the Phillies should have won that one. They have a great team, just not better than this years Yankee's, who have developed into a TEAM! Congratulations Phils fans!    

LMAO, not many people know Pedro had the flu in GM2, Mark Grace mentioned that lastnight. Pedro is alot better now, he'll be ready. Andy Pettite admitted he had nothing against the Phillies hitters, now he's pitching on short rest? He's fortunate Hamels had a bad outing. The Yankees have awakened a sleeping giant in the Phillies bats. The Yankees have been in ALL these games except GM1. Second time through the rotation and you see what the Phillies are doing, getting it done. Yankees have out scored the Phillies 25-24, AGAIN I say there is NO Yankee Superiority. As far as lee starting there are NO guarantees, just like Pettite pitching tomorrow there is no guarantee the Yankees will win, no gurantee they win the series, if they were SO SUPERIOR they would have closed the Series out in Philly. Perhaps they were celebrating to prematurely in the dugout before game 5? After all Cano did say he was number 1.

#8 | 1630 days ago
SuperStar123 (+)

SuperStar123 wrote:
 There really was no goat! With Lee starting the Phillies should have won that one. They have a great team, just not better than this years Yankee's, who have developed into a TEAM! Congratulations Phils fans!    
Mark Grace is our Diamond Backs announcer and anything he says I would take with a grain of salt. He was a great Cubbie, but as Announcer he should retire! He sucks!

I'll stay with my prediction. Petite closes it tomorrow night! I won every game and won a ton of money with the Vegas line. You scared me last night with my money on Lee, and you pretty near blew a good lead. And you still expect those underpaid players to win? Good luck!!!
Joe Girardi for starting A.J. Burnett on 3 days rest  
#9 | 1630 days ago
jigga_2_k (+)

(Edited by jigga_2_k)
SuperStar123 wrote:
Mark Grace is our Diamond Backs announcer and anything he says I would take with a grain of salt. He was a great Cubbie, but as Announcer he should retire! He sucks!

I'll stay with my prediction. Petite closes it tomorrow night! I won every game and won a ton of money with the Vegas line. You scared me last night with my money on Lee, and you pretty near blew a good lead. And you still expect those underpaid players to win? Good luck!!!
Dude personally no one cares about your betting habits. A win is a win, it doesn't matter if it's 1 or 100. As for the Phillies being underpaid, they're paid according to the market they are in. They aren't the Yankees, they had to OVER BID on players just to keep anyone else from getting them. Tex, C.C, Burnett, A-Rod all OVERPAID. furthermore, thos so called "underpaid" players if I'm not mistaken are the reigning World Series Champions. Andy Pettite hasn't pitched on short rest in 3 years and no one even knows if he's pitching tomorrow. The Yankees simply got cocky and thought they were going to celebrate in CBP, they won the Series before they actually WON it. Pettite admitted he didn't have anything for the Phillies hitters, he admitted it to his team mates, Hamels just didn't pitch well. He says he didn't have anything for Phillies hitters on normal rest what makes you think he's going to have anything on short rest???
#10 | 1629 days ago
SuperStar123 (+)

jigga_2_k wrote:
Dude personally no one cares about your betting habits. A win is a win, it doesn't matter if it's 1 or 100. As for the Phillies being underpaid, they're paid according to the market they are in. They aren't the Yankees, they had to OVER BID on players just to keep anyone else from getting them. Tex, C.C, Burnett, A-Rod all OVERPAID. furthermore, thos so called "underpaid" players if I'm not mistaken are the reigning World Series Champions. Andy Pettite hasn't pitched on short rest in 3 years and no one even knows if he's pitching tomorrow. The Yankees simply got cocky and thought they were going to celebrate in CBP, they won the Series before they actually WON it. Pettite admitted he didn't have anything for the Phillies hitters, he admitted it to his team mates, Hamels just didn't pitch well. He says he didn't have anything for Phillies hitters on normal rest what makes you think he's going to have anything on short rest???
I'M NOT DUDE, SO WHY DON'T YOU JUST DROP IT. IT CLEAR YOU DON'T LIKE ME. SO LET IT GO, HUH! I'M A LITTLE OLDER THAN YOU AND HAVE HAD A LITTLE MORE EXPERIENCE, SO I'LL TAKE YOUR RUDENESS INTO ACCOUNT. HOPE YOU WIN TONIGHT!
Joe Girardi for starting A.J. Burnett on 3 days rest  
#11 | 1629 days ago
jigga_2_k (+)

LOL how am I being rude???? You're the one who always brings up your betting habits, I mentioned the Eagles Giants game you brought up your betting habits you did it here.  I simply stated the obvious, you're one walking around running your pie hole acting cocky, say the Phillies are underpaid etc etc. Then you insult me by saying "OH because I'm older I have more experience" With age doesn't always come wisdom! Again I simply stated the OBVIOUS...

Post a Comment   Already a user? Sign in here
Join FanIQ - It's Free
FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.
Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,649,417+ Comments
Track your game picks - 38,670,182,382+ Sports Predictions
Prove you know sports - 116,275+ Trivia Questions
Find fans of your teams - 11,453,110+ New Friends
Miami Marlins @ Atlanta Braves 4/23/2014
Asked by maroon&gold4eve | MLB, ATL, MIA | 10 questions asked 04/19/14
70 predictions | Last by maroon&gold4eve
Miami Marlins @ Atlanta Braves 4/22/2014
Asked by maroon&gold4eve | MLB, ATL, MIA | 10 questions asked 04/19/14
70 predictions | Last by maroon&gold4eve
MLB*Chasing Joe D*The FanIQ Hitting Streak*4/24
Asked by Michael_G | MLB, SF, BOS | 3 questions asked Yesterday
12 predictions | Last by maroon&gold4eve
MLB*Chasing Joe D*The FanIQ Hitting Streak*4/23
Asked by Michael_G | MLB, SF, BOS | 3 questions asked Yesterday
27 predictions | Last by maroon&gold4eve
Miami Marlins @ Atlanta Braves 4/21/2014
Asked by maroon&gold4eve | MLB, ATL, MIA | 10 questions asked 04/19/14
70 predictions | Last by maroon&gold4eve | 7 hours left