FanIQ

You Might Like

More Polls By: Kenne

Who liked it? 2

... and 2 other fans

Skip to Next Poll »

Which active QB bust is the worst?

Which QBs, drafted in the top 3, that is still currently active in the NFL would you say is the least productive?

Players are listed with their QB rating.

Which active QB bust is the worst? Photo

Rank	38 Fans	Avg (1st)
1.	JaMarcus Russell 67.6	3.8 (30)
2.	David Carr 75.1	2.1 (6)
3.	Alex Smith 65.5	2.1 (1)
4.	Vince Young 67.8	1.4
Also receiving votes:	Matthew Stafford 55.9	0.8 (3)

	&nbp;
TOP COMMENT
#1 \| 1289 days ago qtowndogg (+)	Stafford's still a rookie (and he got stuck with Detroit), so I will give him some leeway on this one. 1. JaMarcus Russell 67.6 2. Vince Young 67.8 3. David Carr 75.1 4. Alex Smith 65.5
	4


12 Comments \| Sorted by Most Recent First \| Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 \| 1289 days ago qtowndogg (+)	Stafford's still a rookie (and he got stuck with Detroit), so I will give him some leeway on this one. 1. JaMarcus Russell 67.6 2. Vince Young 67.8 3. David Carr 75.1 4. Alex Smith 65.5
	4
#2 \| 1289 days ago Kenne (+)	qtowndogg wrote: Stafford's still a rookie (and he got stuck with Detroit), so I will give him some leeway on this one. I agree. He still has a chance to redeem himself, but he's thrown more than twice as many INTS as TD's. That type of statistic for a high pick always lands them the Bust label. 1. JaMarcus Russell 67.6 2. Alex Smith 65.5 3. Vince Young 67.8 4. David Carr 75.1

#3 \| 1289 days ago Beaneaters (+)	Carr was the first pick of a new franchise. Looking at the 2002 draft, there really wasn't a decent QB among the group. Carr picked first and then Julius Peppers 2nd to the Panthers. I wonder how many times the Texans kicked their backends on that decision. 1. David Carr 75.1 2. JaMarcus Russell 67.6 3. Alex Smith 65.5 4. Matthew Stafford 55.9
	2
#4 \| 1289 days ago goalieone_99 (+)	While i believe stafford will become a serviceable career I can only judge on his current status. I feel vince young is starting to show more while stafford has so little to work with. He is capable of not being included on a list like this. 1. JaMarcus Russell 67.6 2. David Carr 75.1 3. Alex Smith 65.5 4. Matthew Stafford 55.9
	1
#5 \| 1289 days ago uwgb44 (+)	Carr never really got a fair chance at things. The Texans took two veteran O lineman in the Expansion draft, neither of which played a down for them. And he took a beating that no should have to endure. 74 sacks his rookie year and he still took every snap. So I cant say in a different situation he would have been great. But you have to agree that it was his situation to start his career that hindered him greatly. 1. JaMarcus Russell 67.6 2. Alex Smith 65.5 3. David Carr 75.1 4. Vince Young 67.8
	2
#6 \| 1289 days ago Hec718 (+)	Beaneaters wrote: Carr was the first pick of a new franchise. Looking at the 2002 draft, there really wasn't a decent QB among the group. Carr picked first and then Julius Peppers 2nd to the Panthers. I wonder how many times the Texans kicked their backends on that decision. No one deserves to be higher than JaMarcus Russell. 1. JaMarcus Russell 67.6 2. David Carr 75.1 3. Alex Smith 65.5 4. Matthew Stafford 55.9
	2
#7 \| 1288 days ago Superbleeder (+)	Vince Young should be a close second. Come on he lost his starting job to Kerry Collins. 1. JaMarcus Russell 67.6 2. Vince Young 67.8 3. Alex Smith 65.5 4. David Carr 75.1

#8 \| 1287 days ago Mr_Rogers (+)	The answer is JaMarcus Russel. The guy is horriable, ive watched several Raider games this year and i always cringe when he throws the ball. Its either waaay over the receivers head or underthrown. I really dont think hes going to make it as an NFL QB, they should seriously consider moving him to Running Back...or maybe Tight End.

#9 \| 1286 days ago kramer (+)	Russell will never take the dictionary definition of "draft day bust" away from Ryan Leaf, but he's certainly making a strong case to be #2. 1. JaMarcus Russell 67.6 2. Vince Young 67.8 3. Alex Smith 65.5 4. David Carr 75.1
	1
#10 \| 1286 days ago Kenne (+)	Superbleeder wrote: Vince Young should be a close second. Come on he lost his starting job to Kerry Collins. Vince Young is improving, he's 3-0 as a starter this season and has made some impressive plays. 1. JaMarcus Russell 67.6 2. Alex Smith 65.5 3. Vince Young 67.8 4. David Carr 75.1

#11 \| 1285 days ago Beaneaters (+)	Hec718 wrote: No one deserves to be higher than JaMarcus Russell. Point taken... 1. David Carr 75.1 2. JaMarcus Russell 67.6 3. Alex Smith 65.5 4. Matthew Stafford 55.9

#12 \| 1216 days ago coach_miller (+)	JaMarcus Russell is the only bust on this list. He should have never been drafted in the NFL. All the others are still young and have plenty of upside.

Post a Comment Already a user? Sign in here

Join FanIQ - It's Free

FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.

•Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,649,417+ Comments

•Track your game picks - 38,670,182,382+ Sports Predictions

•Prove you know sports - 116,275+ Trivia Questions

•Find fans of your teams - 11,453,110+ New Friends

Start here >> Select your favorite teams. It's free.

Polls You Might Like
	NFL Draft Busts - Past 5 Years Asked by Kenne \| NFL, DRAFT \| 10 questions asked 04/05/13 140 opinions \| 5 comments \| Last by elevenbravo138again
	Best NFL 1st Overall Draft Picks - Super Bowl Era Asked by Kenne \| NFL, DRAFT \| 10 questions asked 04/02/13 110 opinions \| 3 comments \| Last by Dream_Machine
	if you had to start an NFL franchise and had your pick of any running back, rank your top 5 Choices. Asked by jdoug \| NFL \| 5 questions asked 09/26/12 125 opinions \| 6 comments \| Last by elevenbravo138again
	Has anyone else noticed that when the Panthers play a home game it is the same as an away game? Asked by Khatulu \| NFL, CAR \| 1 questions asked 12/29/12 3 opinions \| Last by Dream_Machine
	NIners are gonna win the Super Bowl in 2014... LOCK IT UP Asked by bayareabeast21 \| NFL, SF \| 1 questions asked 05/05/13 7 predictions \| 2 comments \| Last by Dream_Machine

Answer Breakdown

Answers are sorted in reverse chronological order

#	Name	FanIQ	#1	#2	#3	#4
38	heckler 01/31/2010 07:23AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Alex Smith 65.5	David Carr 75.1	Matthew Stafford 55.9
37	Michael G 01/31/2010 06:54AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	David Carr 75.1	Alex Smith 65.5	Matthew Stafford 55.9
36	ataqwx 01/30/2010 02:05PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Vince Young 67.8	Alex Smith 65.5	Matthew Stafford 55.9
35	Jahiegel 01/30/2010 01:47PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Alex Smith 65.5	David Carr 75.1	Matthew Stafford 55.9
34	CRAZIEJOSH23 01/14/2010 11:10PM		Alex Smith 65.5	David Carr 75.1	JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Matthew Stafford 55.9
33	hayt_hayt 01/03/2010 02:55PM		Matthew Stafford 55.9	Matthew Stafford 55.9	JaMarcus Russell 67.6	JaMarcus Russell 67.6
32	rkonkol78 12/23/2009 07:53PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	David Carr 75.1	Alex Smith 65.5	Vince Young 67.8
31	tcarraway 12/22/2009 09:33AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	David Carr 75.1	Matthew Stafford 55.9	Alex Smith 65.5
30	Sqweazel 12/18/2009 09:01AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Vince Young 67.8	Alex Smith 65.5	David Carr 75.1
29	bulls5 12/17/2009 10:02PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	David Carr 75.1	Vince Young 67.8	Matthew Stafford 55.9
28	imsports2002 12/14/2009 05:30PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Alex Smith 65.5	Matthew Stafford 55.9	David Carr 75.1
27	Kmacnealy1 12/08/2009 06:04PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	David Carr 75.1	Vince Young 67.8	Alex Smith 65.5
26	hwsteelers 11/22/2009 10:51AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Alex Smith 65.5	David Carr 75.1	Vince Young 67.8
25	HouTxFan 11/21/2009 06:36PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Alex Smith 65.5	Vince Young 67.8	David Carr 75.1
24	blondie45044 11/21/2009 04:25PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Vince Young 67.8	Matthew Stafford 55.9	Alex Smith 65.5
23	av5238 11/16/2009 06:07AM		David Carr 75.1	Alex Smith 65.5	JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Vince Young 67.8
22	kramer 11/16/2009 02:08AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Vince Young 67.8	Alex Smith 65.5	David Carr 75.1
21	ironhead_mike 11/15/2009 01:20PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Alex Smith 65.5	Vince Young 67.8	David Carr 75.1
20	cwfinley 11/15/2009 11:31AM		Matthew Stafford 55.9	JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Vince Young 67.8	Alex Smith 65.5
19	gau13 11/14/2009 11:39PM		David Carr 75.1	David Carr 75.1	JaMarcus Russell 67.6	JaMarcus Russell 67.6
18	Superbleeder 11/14/2009 11:08AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Vince Young 67.8	Alex Smith 65.5	David Carr 75.1
17	radiowave000 11/14/2009 08:14AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	David Carr 75.1	Vince Young 67.8	Alex Smith 65.5
16	rockhound87 11/13/2009 10:04PM		David Carr 75.1	Alex Smith 65.5	JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Vince Young 67.8
15	Dream_Machine 11/13/2009 09:37PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	David Carr 75.1	Alex Smith 65.5	Matthew Stafford 55.9
14	Hec718 11/13/2009 04:29PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	David Carr 75.1	Alex Smith 65.5	Matthew Stafford 55.9
13	uwgb44 11/13/2009 03:50PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Alex Smith 65.5	David Carr 75.1	Vince Young 67.8
12	dbaker 11/13/2009 03:32PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	David Carr 75.1	Alex Smith 65.5	Vince Young 67.8
11	goalieone_99 11/13/2009 03:05PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	David Carr 75.1	Alex Smith 65.5	Matthew Stafford 55.9
10	bayareabeast21 11/13/2009 02:32PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Matthew Stafford 55.9	David Carr 75.1	Alex Smith 65.5
9	OoDeviLoO 11/13/2009 01:23PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Alex Smith 65.5	David Carr 75.1	Vince Young 67.8
8	misanthrope 11/13/2009 01:14PM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Vince Young 67.8	Alex Smith 65.5	David Carr 75.1
7	ManningsOffense 11/13/2009 12:35PM		David Carr 75.1	JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Alex Smith 65.5	Matthew Stafford 55.9
6	Indydave 11/13/2009 10:57AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	David Carr 75.1	Vince Young 67.8	Alex Smith 65.5
5	TheGregg 11/13/2009 10:51AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Vince Young 67.8	Matthew Stafford 55.9	Alex Smith 65.5
4	Beaneaters 11/13/2009 10:05AM		David Carr 75.1	JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Alex Smith 65.5	Matthew Stafford 55.9
3	qtowndogg 11/13/2009 09:07AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Vince Young 67.8	David Carr 75.1	Alex Smith 65.5
2	vindog 11/13/2009 07:33AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Vince Young 67.8	Alex Smith 65.5	David Carr 75.1
1	Kenne 11/13/2009 05:38AM		JaMarcus Russell 67.6	Alex Smith 65.5	Vince Young 67.8	David Carr 75.1