Skip to Next Poll »
Should Peyton Manning of won the MVP?
What Player do you think should of been MVP?
| Closed on 02/08/10 at 05:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | NFL | Opinion List
Team Breakout:
Rank12 FansAvg (1st)
1.Peyton Manning8.5 (7)
2.Drew Brees7.4 (4)
3.Brett Favre5.9
4.Aaron Rodgers5.3
5.Adrian Peterson4.2 (1)
6.Tom Brady3.9
7.Wes Welker2.9
8.Desean Jackson2.8
9.Ben Rothelisberger2.1
Also receiving votes:Donavon McNabb2.0

  
13 Comments | Sorted by Most Recent First | Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 | 1666 days ago
vindog (+)

Tony Romo should be on this list- just saying!  
1. Drew Brees  2. Peyton Manning  3. Aaron Rodgers  4. Wes Welker  5. Tom Brady  6. Adrian Peterson  7. Brett Favre  8. Desean Jackson  9. Ben Rothelisberger  
#2 | 1666 days ago

ABSO_FRICKIN LUTELY!!!!! Congrats Peyton!!!
#3 | 1665 days ago

How the hell does Donovan get on this list when he is 17th in passing yards..Matt Schaub 1st in passing yards and Tony Romo 3rd in passing yards both dont make the list...terrible list...but i do give all the credit in the world to manning..great season, the colts would be nothing without you!!
#4 | 1665 days ago
vindog (+)

STLCardinalsFan wrote:
How the hell does Donovan get on this list when he is 17th in passing yards..Matt Schaub 1st in passing yards and Tony Romo 3rd in passing yards both dont make the list...terrible list...but i do give all the credit in the world to manning..great season, the colts would be nothing without you!!
That is funny considering that Romo threw for 930 more yards than McNabb did this season, Romo had 4 more Td passes than McNabb and 1 less interception than Donovan........  Hmmmm  (***shakes his head in confusion****)     AND Romo (and his Cowboys) beat McNabb 3 times this season......
1. Drew Brees  2. Peyton Manning  3. Aaron Rodgers  4. Wes Welker  5. Tom Brady  6. Adrian Peterson  7. Brett Favre  8. Desean Jackson  9. Ben Rothelisberger  
#5 | 1664 days ago

Chris Johnson, yes.
#6 | 1664 days ago
lovinmyjeffgordon (+)

My Future Husband Mr. Peyton Manning....lololo
1. Peyton Manning  2. Adrian Peterson  3. Brett Favre  4. Tom Brady  5. Ben Rothelisberger  6. Aaron Rodgers  7. Drew Brees  8. Desean Jackson  9. Wes Welker  
#7 | 1664 days ago

Yeah, even as an Eagles fan, I don't think McNabb should've been on this list.  I love him and he did pretty well during the regular season, but it was just NOT an MVP season.
1. Adrian Peterson  2. Peyton Manning  3. Drew Brees  4. Desean Jackson  5. Brett Favre  6. Aaron Rodgers  7. Tom Brady  8. Ben Rothelisberger  9. Donavon McNabb  
#8 | 1664 days ago

I picked Adrian Peterson only because he basically won me my fantasy league (and lots of money!).
1. Adrian Peterson  2. Peyton Manning  3. Drew Brees  4. Desean Jackson  5. Brett Favre  6. Aaron Rodgers  7. Tom Brady  8. Ben Rothelisberger  9. Donavon McNabb  
#9 | 1663 days ago

Horrible list left off Chris Johnson from Titans, QB Texans Schuab.  But I think it should have been a CO-MVP Brees and Long Neck P.Manning!
1. Drew Brees  2. Peyton Manning  3. Brett Favre  4. Donavon McNabb  5. Aaron Rodgers  6. Tom Brady  7. Adrian Peterson  8. Desean Jackson  9. Wes Welker  
#10 | 1663 days ago

Objectively you really think he was the MVP? Take off the Star and Blue glasses, just weeks ago he was on the verge of being benched, can't win in Dec. comments about him all over ESPN and other affilates.  He has had a good year but not an MVP year.
1. Drew Brees  2. Peyton Manning  3. Brett Favre  4. Donavon McNabb  5. Aaron Rodgers  6. Tom Brady  7. Adrian Peterson  8. Desean Jackson  9. Wes Welker  
#11 | 1663 days ago
vindog (+)

(Edited by vindog)
shfessler wrote:
Objectively you really think he was the MVP? Take off the Star and Blue glasses, just weeks ago he was on the verge of being benched, can't win in Dec. comments about him all over ESPN and other affilates.  He has had a good year but not an MVP year.
O.K;  so you may feel that Romo shouldn't be considered for the NFL MVP- I get it- you have been bashing him all season on this site.....  But when in the hell was he " on the verge of being benched just weeks ago?"   Tony Romo led the NFL in Passer rating throughout the entire month of December...Romo has led the Cowboys to consecutive wins over the Saints, Redskins, and Eagles TWICE;  and in the losses to San Diego and New York- he passed for over 300 yards in both game and threw NO interceptions........ Seriously, where do you come up with this crap?
1. Drew Brees  2. Peyton Manning  3. Aaron Rodgers  4. Wes Welker  5. Tom Brady  6. Adrian Peterson  7. Brett Favre  8. Desean Jackson  9. Ben Rothelisberger  
#12 | 1659 days ago

Chris Johnson should certainly be on this list, though I think Manning absolutely deserves the MVP award
1. Peyton Manning  2. Drew Brees  3. Brett Favre  4. Adrian Peterson  5. Desean Jackson  6. Donavon McNabb  7. Aaron Rodgers  8. Wes Welker  9. Tom Brady  
#13 | 1636 days ago

ummm, what about philip rivers?
1. Drew Brees  2. Aaron Rodgers  3. Peyton Manning  4. Brett Favre  5. Wes Welker  6. Desean Jackson  7. Adrian Peterson  8. Donavon McNabb  9. Tom Brady  

Post a Comment   Already a user? Sign in here
Join FanIQ - It's Free
FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.
Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,649,417+ Comments
Track your game picks - 38,670,182,382+ Sports Predictions
Prove you know sports - 116,275+ Trivia Questions
Find fans of your teams - 11,453,110+ New Friends
2014 AFC North Prediction: How will each team in the AFC North finish this season?
Asked by RaiderSteeler15 | NFL | 4 questions asked 07/20/14
20 predictions | Last by LACavsFan
NFL**San Diego Chargers**2014 Season Prediction Poll**pt.2
Asked by Michael_G | NFL, SD, SF | 8 questions asked 05/24/14
48 predictions | Last by Smokesfan
NFL**San Diego Chargers**2014 Season Prediction Poll**pt.1
Asked by Michael_G | NFL, SD, SF | 8 questions asked 05/24/14
48 predictions | Last by Smokesfan
NFL**San Francisco 49ers**2014 Season Prediction Poll**pt.2
Asked by Michael_G | NFL, SF, SF | 8 questions asked 04/25/14
72 predictions | Last by Smokesfan
NFL**Tennessee Titans**2014 Season Prediction Poll**pt.1
Asked by Michael_G | NFL, TEN, SF | 8 questions asked 06/30/14
56 predictions | Last by Smokesfan