FanIQ

  • join now
  • login
  • Login
You Might Like




Asked By: BigBen7


Who liked it? 5
... and 5 other fans
 Skip to Next Poll »
5
Will Ben Roethlisberger make the hall of fame (Edited 03/18/10 08:02PM by BigBen7)
| Closed on 03/02/11 at 05:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | NFL, Pittsburgh Steelers | Multiple Choice Opinion Poll
Players:  Ben Roethlisberger
Team Breakout:
46 Fans 
30%a. yes
37%b. no
33%c. maybe

 &nbp;
TOP COMMENT * * * * * * * * * * * *
#4 | 1158 days ago

 BigBen7 wrote:
Maybe one more ring but 5 more good years and he is in
Those 5 good years with the San Quentin Rapists will NOT count towards the Pro Football HOF
no   
4

  
22 Comments | Sorted by Most Recent First | Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 | 1160 days ago

 (Edited by BigBen7)
Maybe one more ring but 5 more good years and he is in
yes   

#2 | 1160 days ago

 not if he goes to prison...3rd time will NOT be a charm.
maybe  
1

#3 | 1159 days ago

 I'd say no at this point, but I'd need to wait and see how the rest of his career plays out.  He certainly has the potential (as long as he can keep himself out of jail).
maybe  

#4 | 1158 days ago

 BigBen7 wrote:
Maybe one more ring but 5 more good years and he is in
Those 5 good years with the San Quentin Rapists will NOT count towards the Pro Football HOF
no   
4

#5 | 1156 days ago

 No.  Dennis Dixon will be starting for the Steelers next season.
no   

#6 | 1155 days ago

 BigBen7 wrote:
Maybe one more ring but 5 more good years and he is in
Ben is the next Terry Bradshaw/Lynn swann all rolled into one.  He will make it all the way..providing he dont let it all go to his head
yes   

#7 | 1139 days ago

 hes a great QB and he wins alot but i think the legacy he is creating for himself is alittle too scared for him to be considered for the hall of fame
no   
1

#8 | 1134 days ago

 themalonephone wrote:
hes a great QB and he wins alot but i think the legacy he is creating for himself is alittle too scared for him to be considered for the hall of fame
allegations won't lose your seat in the HOF.  Prosecutions will.
yes   

#9 | 1131 days ago

 SteelerSteve wrote:
allegations won't lose your seat in the HOF.  Prosecutions will.
you have a point
no   

#10 | 1131 days ago

 To have come from Miami-Ohio and have accomplished what he has is phenominal. If he stays out of trouble, YES!

#11 | 1128 days ago

 If he keeps performing as he does on the field and his stats are very good.
yes   

#12 | 1128 days ago

 He wins another ring, he has a chance.  He does need to stop acting STUPID. Let me see, did Micheal Irvin, O J Simpson, Carl Eller, Bob Haynes, make it in the Hall of Fame? And they were convicted.    Paul Horning , hmmm Ray Lewis, yeah he'll  probably get in.  It has been proven over, and over, what you do on the field, has alot of say than what you do off of it.
yes   

#13 | 1127 days ago

 IF Pete Rose cant get in because of Gambling,,, what do you think they are going to think of a guy who forces himself on women,or at least puts himself in situations where he doesnt  use his head..errrr well the right one anyway!!!
no   
2

#14 | 1111 days ago

 Onegoodredhead2 wrote:
IF Pete Rose cant get in because of Gambling,,, what do you think they are going to think of a guy who forces himself on women,or at least puts himself in situations where he doesnt  use his head..errrr well the right one anyway!!!
yeah!
no   

#15 | 974 days ago

 I say as of right now he has a 50/50 chance of getting into the hall of fame.If he wins one more superbowl I think its a Lock.
yes   

#16 | 973 days ago

 If Ben wins another Super Bowl I believe he's a lock also.  Just like Kobe is a lock to get in the Basketball Hall of Fame.
yes   

#17 | 973 days ago

  You people are delusional....Ben's stats are no where NEAR HOF worthy
no   

#18 | 936 days ago

 Some players stats that are in the Hall of Fame right now, are not worthy, but they're in, minus the stats..  Ben wins another Super Bowl he's a lock to get in.
yes   

#19 | 847 days ago

  I think there are 3 Hall of Famers on that team and all of them play defense...Polamalu, Harrison and Hampton.
no   

#20 | 834 days ago

 I believe allegations do cloud the judgment when it comes to the HOF for some players. IMO you should be judged by stats not by their personal life. Judge not less thee be judged. There will be a time that Ben, Tiger and Pete will be judged, it should not be here on the Q or by keeping them out of the HOF.Hope God is more forgiving then the Q nation and the newspapers and trash magazines!
maybe  

#21 | 833 days ago

  Ben's passer tgs: in his first SB the Steelers won is SPITE of him: 22.6 <<beyond horrible
second SB 93.2 and threw the winning TD pass
This years AFC Championship game: 35.5 as once again the Steelers D bails him out
This years SB: 77.5 and he fails to lead his team down the field
If Ben is a HOF QB, so is Dave Kreig, so is Brad Johnson, so is Steve McNair, so is Mark Rypien
no   

#22 | 821 days ago

 MarkTheShark wrote:
 Ben's passer tgs: in his first SB the Steelers won is SPITE of him: 22.6 <<beyond horrible
second SB 93.2 and threw the winning TD pass
This years AFC Championship game: 35.5 as once again the Steelers D bails him out
This years SB: 77.5 and he fails to lead his team down the field
If Ben is a HOF QB, so is Dave Kreig, so is Brad Johnson, so is Steve McNair, so is Mark Rypien
As Rodgers with a 55.4 passer rating was bailed out by his defense in the NFC Championship game. What's your point, other than hating Ben?

Ben doesn't win pretty, anyone watching the game knows that. What he does off the field has no baring on the HOF, we all know he makes poor decisions.

I don't even know why this is a argument, there is to many years left in his career. His resume so far (on field) isn't bad.

Moving on! 


Post a Comment   Already a user? Sign in here
Join FanIQ - It's Free
FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.
•Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,649,417+ Comments
•Track your game picks - 38,670,182,382+ Sports Predictions
•Prove you know sports - 116,275+ Trivia Questions
•Find fans of your teams - 11,453,110+ New Friends
Polls You Might Like

if you had to start an NFL franchise and had your pick of any running back, rank your top 5 Choices.
Asked by jdoug | NFL | 5 questions asked 09/26/12
125 opinions | 6 comments | Last by elevenbravo138again
NFL Draft Busts - Past 5 Years
Asked by Kenne | NFL, DRAFT | 10 questions asked 04/05/13
140 opinions | 5 comments | Last by elevenbravo138again
Best NFL 1st Overall Draft Picks - Super Bowl Era
Asked by Kenne | NFL, DRAFT | 10 questions asked 04/02/13
110 opinions | 3 comments | Last by Dream_Machine
Has anyone else noticed that when the Panthers play a home game it is the same as an away game?
Asked by Khatulu | NFL, CAR | 1 questions asked 12/29/12
3 opinions | Last by Dream_Machine
NIners are gonna win the Super Bowl in 2014... LOCK IT UP
Asked by bayareabeast21 | NFL, SF | 1 questions asked 05/05/13
7 predictions | 2 comments | Last by Dream_Machine