Skip to Next Poll »
9
Best Undrafted NFL Players of the past 25 years?
Which players that went unnoticed coming out of college, but went on to star in the NFL and help their team to success were the best? (This poll will require an extensive amount of past and present NFL expert knowledge) Best Undrafted NFL Players of the past 25 years? Photo

*Players that were active in the past 25 years are listed, but may have entered the league before then.'

*Players are listed with position and  # of Pro Bowl appearances.
| Closed on 07/25/10 at 05:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | NFL, *Draft | Opinion List
Team Breakout:
Rank29 FansAvg (1st)
1.Warren Moon QB (9 PBs)8.5 (13)
2.Kurt Warner QB (4 PBs)8.3 (9)
3.John Randle DT (7 PBs)6.7 (3)
4.Antonio Gates TE (6 PBs)5.0
5.Jeff Saturday C (4 PBs)3.1
6.Nate Newton OL (6 PBs)2.9 (1)
7.Priest Holmes RB (3 PBs)2.7
8.Rod Smith WR (3 PBs)2.0 (1)
9.Adam Vinatieri K (2 PBs)1.7
10.Wes Welker WR (2 PBs)1.7
Also receiving votes:Tony Romo QB (3 PBs)1.7
Donnie Shell CB (5 PBs)1.5 (1)
Brian Waters OL (4 PBs)1.2
James Harrison LB (3 PBs)1.2
Jeff Garcia QB (4 PBs)1.1 (1)
Pat Williams DT (3 PBs)1.1
Everson Walls CB (4 PBs)1.0
Deron Cherry DB (6 PBs)0.9
Joe Jacoby OL (4 PBs)0.7
Shaun O'Hara C (2 PBs)0.4
Jake Delhomme QB (1 PBs)0.3
Nick Lowery K (3 PBs)0.3
___ _____ __ (__) (please specify)0.3
Dave Kreig QB (3 PBs)0.3
Willie Parker RB (2 PBs)0.2
Kris Dielman G (3 PBs)0.1
Adewale Ogunleye (1 PBs)0.0
Mark Tuinei OL (2 PBs)0.0

  
7 Comments | Sorted by Most Recent First | Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 | 1639 days ago

My other is Joshua Cribbs......

I'm not in love with my order though, and this was a hard ass question?! You suck!

I probably wanna change my answers. LOL
1. Warren Moon QB (9 PBs)  2. Kurt Warner QB (4 PBs)  3. John Randle DT (7 PBs)  4. Pat Williams DT (3 PBs)  5. Nate Newton OL (6 PBs)  6. James Harrison LB (3 PBs)  7. Rod Smith WR (3 PBs)  8. Shaun O'Hara C (2 PBs)  9. Wes Welker WR (2 PBs)  10. ___ _____ __ (__) (please specify)  
#2 | 1639 days ago

kobe_lova wrote:
My other is Joshua Cribbs......

I'm not in love with my order though, and this was a hard ass question?! You suck!

I probably wanna change my answers. LOL
If you hadn't of already voted, I would've thrown him in for you
1. Kurt Warner QB (4 PBs)  2. Warren Moon QB (9 PBs)  3. John Randle DT (7 PBs)  4. Antonio Gates TE (6 PBs)  5. Donnie Shell CB (5 PBs)  6. Priest Holmes RB (3 PBs)  7. Nate Newton OL (6 PBs)  8. Tony Romo QB (3 PBs)  9. Adam Vinatieri K (2 PBs)  10. James Harrison LB (3 PBs)  
#3 | 1639 days ago

(Edited by kobe_lova)
Kenne wrote:
If you hadn't of already voted, I would've thrown him in for you
next time, do it right the first go round!



and, Romo? Really?!
1. Warren Moon QB (9 PBs)  2. Kurt Warner QB (4 PBs)  3. John Randle DT (7 PBs)  4. Pat Williams DT (3 PBs)  5. Nate Newton OL (6 PBs)  6. James Harrison LB (3 PBs)  7. Rod Smith WR (3 PBs)  8. Shaun O'Hara C (2 PBs)  9. Wes Welker WR (2 PBs)  10. ___ _____ __ (__) (please specify)  
#4 | 1639 days ago

kobe_lova wrote:
My other is Joshua Cribbs......

I'm not in love with my order though, and this was a hard ass question?! You suck!

I probably wanna change my answers. LOL
nice list
1. Warren Moon QB (9 PBs)  2. Kurt Warner QB (4 PBs)  3. John Randle DT (7 PBs)  4. Antonio Gates TE (6 PBs)  5. Jeff Saturday C (4 PBs)  6. Priest Holmes RB (3 PBs)  7. Nate Newton OL (6 PBs)  8. Deron Cherry DB (6 PBs)  9. Everson Walls CB (4 PBs)  10. Pat Williams DT (3 PBs)  
#5 | 1634 days ago

Very difficult to choose. but stud line line who not only was undrafted but should be one day all be hall of famers definitely top my list. As well as others who should or are in the hall of fame when they finish their careers
1. Nate Newton OL (6 PBs)  2. Jeff Saturday C (4 PBs)  3. John Randle DT (7 PBs)  4. Joe Jacoby OL (4 PBs)  5. Warren Moon QB (9 PBs)  6. Kurt Warner QB (4 PBs)  7. Adam Vinatieri K (2 PBs)  8. Antonio Gates TE (6 PBs)  9. James Harrison LB (3 PBs)  10. Priest Holmes RB (3 PBs)  
#6 | 1623 days ago

Hard poll!! Good job!
1. Kurt Warner QB (4 PBs)  2. Warren Moon QB (9 PBs)  3. Shaun O'Hara C (2 PBs)  4. Jeff Saturday C (4 PBs)  5. Joe Jacoby OL (4 PBs)  6. Tony Romo QB (3 PBs)  7. Adam Vinatieri K (2 PBs)  8. Nate Newton OL (6 PBs)  9. Deron Cherry DB (6 PBs)  10. Brian Waters OL (4 PBs)  
#7 | 1621 days ago

Kicker Shouldn't Count On This List Because The Majority Of The Good Ones Are Never Drafted.
1. Warren Moon QB (9 PBs)  2. Kurt Warner QB (4 PBs)  3. John Randle DT (7 PBs)  4. Antonio Gates TE (6 PBs)  5. Priest Holmes RB (3 PBs)  6. Nate Newton OL (6 PBs)  7. Jeff Saturday C (4 PBs)  8. Jeff Garcia QB (4 PBs)  9. Wes Welker WR (2 PBs)  10. James Harrison LB (3 PBs)  

Post a Comment   Already a user? Sign in here
Join FanIQ - It's Free
FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.
Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,649,417+ Comments
Track your game picks - 38,670,182,382+ Sports Predictions
Prove you know sports - 116,275+ Trivia Questions
Find fans of your teams - 11,453,110+ New Friends
Redskins at Cow***s 10/27/14
Asked by hskrdave | NFL, WAS, DAL | 6 questions asked 10/20/14
42 predictions | Last by Dream_Machine
Rank the AFC East Scoring Leaders Week #8 10/26 /2014
Asked by maroon&gold4eve | NFL, AFC East, BUF | 4 questions asked 10/19/14
48 predictions | Last by Dream_Machine
Rank the NFC East Scoring Leaders Week#8 10/26-27/2014
Asked by maroon&gold4eve | NFL, NFC East, WAS | 4 questions asked 10/19/14
48 predictions | Last by Dream_Machine
Rank the NFC West Scoring Leaders Week #8 10/26/2014
Asked by maroon&gold4eve | NFL, NFC West, ARI | 4 questions asked 10/19/14
44 predictions | Last by Dream_Machine
Rank the NFC North Scoring Leaders Week#8 10/26/2014
Asked by maroon&gold4eve | NFL, NFC North, DET | 4 questions asked 10/19/14
48 predictions | Last by Dream_Machine