| Rank | 16 Fans | Avg (1st) |
| 1. | * Stan Musial, OF, 1941-1944, 1946-1963 | 6.8 (9) |
| 2. | * Bob Gibson, P, 1959-1975 | 5.0 (1) |
| 3. | * Ozzie Smith, SS, 1982-1996 | 3.7 (1) |
| 4. | * Rogers Hornsby, 2B, 1915-1926, 1933 | 3.4 |
| 5. | * Lou Brock, OF, 1964-1979 | 3.1 |
| 6. | * Albert Pujols, 1B/3B/OF, 2001- | 3.1 |
| 7. | * Dizzy Dean, P, 1930, 1932-1937 | 2.9 |
| 8. | * Grover Cleveland Alexander, P, 1926-1929 | 1.5 (1) |
| 9. | * Joe Medwick, OF, 1932-1940, 1947-1948 | 1.2 |
| 10. | * Ted Simmons, C, 1968-1980 | 1.2 |
| Also receiving votes: | * Enos Slaughter, OF, 1938-1942, 1946-1953 | 1.2 (1) |
* Joe Adams, P, 1902 | 0.9 | * Sparky Adams, 3B, 1930-1933 | 0.9 | * Red Schoendienst, 2B, 1945-1956, 1961-1963 | 0.9 | * Ken Boyer, 3B, 1955-1965 | 0.8 | * Jim Adduci, 1B, 1983 | 0.8 | * Bob Uecker, C, 1964-1965 | 0.7 | * Ody Abbott, OF, 1910 | 0.6 (1) | * Jim Adams, C, 1890 | 0.6 (1) | * Steve Carlton, P, 1965-1971 | 0.6 | * Cy Young, P, 1899-1900 | 0.6 (1) | * Chris Carpenter, P, 2004- | 0.6 | * Mike Shannon, 3B, 1962-1970 | 0.6 | * Ted Abernathy, P, 1970 | 0.6 | * Joe Torre, C/1B/3B, 1969-1974 | 0.6 | * Babe Adams, P, 1906 | 0.5 | * John Tudor, P, 1985-1988, 1990 | 0.5 | * Mike Tyson, 2B, 1972-1979 | 0.5 | * Jim Edmonds, OF, 2000-2007 | 0.4 | * Adam Wainwright, P, 2005- | 0.4 | * Frankie Frisch, 2B, 1927-1937 | 0.4 | * Matty Alou, OF, 1971-1973 | 0.4 | * Curt Flood, OF, 1958-1969 | 0.4 | * Harry Brecheen, P, 1940, 1943-1952 | 0.4 | * Henry Adkinson, OF, 1895 | 0.4 | * Keith Hernandez, 1B, 1974-1983 | 0.4 | * Hi Bell, P, 1924, 1926-1927, 1929-1930 | 0.3 | * Jim Donnelly, 3B, 1890, 1898 | 0.3 | * Mark McGwire, 1B, 1997-2001 | 0.3 | * Andy Van Slyke, OF, 1983-1986 | 0.3 | * Tito Francona, 1B/OF, 1965-1966 | 0.3 | * Harry Walker, OF, 1940-1943, 1946-1947, 1950 | 0.3 | * Tommie Agee, OF, 1973 | 0.3 | * Vince Coleman, OF, 1985-1990 | 0.3 | * Mort Cooper, P, 1938-1945 | 0.3 | * Bruce Sutter, P, 1981-1984 | 0.2 | * Pepper Martin, OF, 1928, 1930-1940, 1944 | 0.2 | * Bill Doak, P, 1913-1924, 1929 | 0.2 | * Buster Adams, OF, 1939, 1943, 1945-1946 | 0.2 | * Jim Bottomley, 1B, 1922-1932 | 0.2 | * Joe Frazier, OF, 1954-1956 | 0.2 | * Juan Agosto, P, 1991-1992 | 0.2 | * Charlie Comiskey, 1B, 1882-1889, 1891 | 0.2 | * Walker Cooper, C, 1940-1945, 1956-1957 | 0.2 | * Walter Alston, 1B, 1936 | 0.2 | * Andy Benes, P, 1996-1997, 2000-2002 | 0.2 | * Joe Girardi, C, 2003 | 0.2 | * Eddie Ainsmith, C, 1921-1923 | 0.2 | * Whitey Kurowski, 3B, 1941-1949 | 0.1 | * Tim McCarver, C, 1959-1961, 1963-1969, 1973- | 0.1 | * Alan Benes, P, 1995-1997, 1999-2001 | 0.1 | * Johnny Mize, 1B, 1936-1941 | 0.1 | * Howie Pollet, P, 1941-1943, 1946-1951 | 0.1 | * Gibson Alba, P, 1988 | 0.1 | * Al Hrabosky, P, 1970-1977 | 0.1 | * Lee Smith, P, 1990-1993 | 0.1 | * Dick Allen, 1B, 1970 | 0.1 | * Tito Landrum, OF, 1980-1987 | 0.1 | * Paul Dean, P, 1934-1939 | 0.1 | * Willie McGee, OF, 1982-1990, 1996-1999 | 0.1 | * Bobby Wallace, SS, 1899-1901, 1917-1918 | 0.1 | * Ozzie Canseco, OF, 1992-1993 | 0.1 | * Todd Worrell, P, 1985-1989, 1992 | 0.1 | * Matt Holliday, LF, 2009- | 0.1 | * Cy Alberts, P, 1910 | 0.1 |