Skip to Next Poll »
5
Versus: Players Gon' Play (Edited 09/15/11 07:34PM by Kenne)

So... this is a spin-off poll of Ashlie's popular new poll about musicians. This time we're doing athletes.
1st person posts a match. Next tells who wins and posts the next one, and so on.

Example: P1: Jordan vs Chamberlain. 
                  P2: Jordan - Mantle vs DiMaggio

| Closed on 10/26/11 at 12:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | Locker Room, Games | Multiple Choice Opinion Poll
25 Fans 
20%a. MLB is coming to a close :(
32%b. Yay NFL is back!
0%c. when will the NBA get it together
16%d. I miss NHL
20%e. other
8%f. I dont wanna play this game

 &nbp;
TOP COMMENT * * * * * * * * * * * *
#32 | 1043 days ago

I refuse to answer until you stop yelling at me.
  
83 Comments | Sorted by Most Recent First | Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 | 1044 days ago

Mickey Mantle vs Joe DiMaggio
Yay NFL is back!  
#2 | 1044 days ago

This time we're doing athletes....................mmmmkay...............

Joe banged Marilyn.     Winner

Kobe-LeBron     Get it out of the way..........
MLB is coming to a close :(  
#3 | 1044 days ago

Kobe


Brett Hull...or...Jeremy Roenick
I miss NHL  
#4 | 1044 days ago

BRETT HULL................OLD school

SAMMY SOSA VS MARK MCGWIRE..................
#5 | 1044 days ago

Steroids only over Steroids and cork........McGwire


Ty Cobb-Rickey Henderson           
MLB is coming to a close :(  
#6 | 1044 days ago

 Ugh. Versus: Players Gon' Play*


thank you in advance.
Yay NFL is back!  
#7 | 1044 days ago

ohwell_ wrote:
Steroids only over Steroids and cork........McGwire


Ty Cobb-Rickey Henderson           
Henderson - more speed and power in a more advanced era



Montana vs Aikman
other  
#8 | 1044 days ago

easy one.........MONTANA.............AIKMAN DIDNT have the great stats...............

BARRY BONDS VS HANK AARON
#9 | 1044 days ago

alainpeartree wrote:
Henderson - more speed and power in a more advanced era



Montana vs Aikman
Montana

Earnhardt Sr VS. Jimmie Johnson
other  
#10 | 1044 days ago

Jeff_P wrote:
easy one.........MONTANA.............AIKMAN DIDNT have the great stats...............

BARRY BONDS VS HANK AARON
Hammerin' Hank. Was through with it before Barry knew what to do with it.

Steve Nash vs. John Stckton
Yay NFL is back!  
#11 | 1044 days ago

(Edited by HULL_17)
John Stockton...Awesom


Dirk Nowitzki...or...Shaq
I miss NHL  
#12 | 1044 days ago

kobe_lova wrote:
 Ugh. Versus: Players Gon' Play*


thank you in advance.
 
Sorry, you've already given kobe_lova the 5 Respect you can give to one person in a day
MLB is coming to a close :(  
#13 | 1044 days ago

HULL_17 wrote:
John Stockton...Awesom


Dirk Nowitzki...or...Shaq
DIRK............all around player

SERENA WILLIAMS  vs  MARIA SHARIPOVA........
#14 | 1044 days ago

(Edited by Kenne)
HULL_17 wrote:
John Stockton...Awesom


Dirk Nowitzki...or...Shaq
Now I'll take Dirk, but I think Shaq will be better remembered in the future
Serena to the above post

Johnny Unitas vs Peyton Manning
Yay NFL is back!  
#15 | 1044 days ago

(Edited by maddhatter6691)
Kenne wrote:
Now I'll take Dirk, but I think Shaq will be better remembered in the future
Serena to the above post

Johnny Unitas vs Peyton Manning
Peyton


Joe Montana vs Roger Staubach
Yay NFL is back!  
#16 | 1044 days ago

maddhatter6691 wrote:
Peyton


Joe Montana vs Roger Staubach
Montana

Muhammad Ali vs Sugar Ray Robinson
Yay NFL is back!  
#17 | 1044 days ago

Muhammad


Babe Ruth vs. Derek Jeter
MLB is coming to a close :(  
#18 | 1043 days ago
18packabs (+)

The BABE

Terry Bradshaw vs. Roger Staubach
other  
#19 | 1043 days ago

Bradshaw-he was in Smokey and the Bandit II and the Cannonball Run

Gordie Howe vs. Sidney Crosby

(Anyone who pick Crosby should be dismembered with a hockey stick)
MLB is coming to a close :(  
#20 | 1043 days ago

Miguel94 wrote:
Bradshaw-he was in Smokey and the Bandit II and the Cannonball Run

Gordie Howe vs. Sidney Crosby

(Anyone who pick Crosby should be dismembered with a hockey stick)
Gordie Howe

Barry Sanders vs Walter Payton
Yay NFL is back!  
#21 | 1043 days ago

Kenne wrote:
Gordie Howe

Barry Sanders vs Walter Payton




Gheorghe Muresan vs Manute Bol
I miss NHL  
#22 | 1043 days ago

UGLY PICK..................BOTH SUCKED........LOL.....................BOL.....

WILT CHAMBERLAIN vs BILL RUSSELL
#23 | 1043 days ago

Jeff_P wrote:
UGLY PICK..................BOTH SUCKED........LOL.....................BOL.....

WILT CHAMBERLAIN vs BILL RUSSELL
Wilt- Russell always had a GREAT SUPPORTING cast- Wilt always had to do it all by himself





Erving vs Jordan
other  
#24 | 1043 days ago

alainpeartree wrote:
Wilt- Russell always had a GREAT SUPPORTING cast- Wilt always had to do it all by himself





Erving vs Jordan
Wilt also slept with over 20'000 women.  That just adds to his awesome legacy if you ask me.

MJ, no contest.  He's the GOAT.


Ric Flair vs Jose Canseco 
I miss NHL  
#25 | 1043 days ago

jswol54 wrote:
Wilt also slept with over 20'000 women.  That just adds to his awesome legacy if you ask me.

MJ, no contest.  He's the GOAT.


Ric Flair vs Jose Canseco 
There you go talking about someone who people only know the myth of Earl Manigaut 

Ric Flair- old time wrestler when smackdowns were REAL!!!!!



Bobby Orr vs Wayne Gretzky
other  
#26 | 1043 days ago

alainpeartree wrote:
There you go talking about someone who people only know the myth of Earl Manigaut 

Ric Flair- old time wrestler when smackdowns were REAL!!!!!



Bobby Orr vs Wayne Gretzky
Haha.  "The Goat" was a great movie. 


Gotta go with "The Great One" Wayne Gretzky/


Spud Webb vs  Muggsy Bogues
I miss NHL  
#27 | 1043 days ago

the SPUD-STER................

TONY GWYNN VS WADE BOGGS...........2 GREAT hitters.....................
#28 | 1043 days ago

Jeff_P wrote:
the SPUD-STER................

TONY GWYNN VS WADE BOGGS...........2 GREAT hitters.....................

aaaarrrrggghhhh- that damn Ty Bogues- was just a novelty damn act- couldnt hit a jumpshot if his life depended on it

 

Gwynn- I believe his lifetime avergae is better

 

Micheal Phelps vs Mark Spitz

other  
#29 | 1043 days ago

(Edited by kobe_lova)
Phelps. Beauty before Ugh. (and by beauty, I mean anything over Mark Spitz, except maybe Leon Spinks)



Adrian Peterson vs. Arian Foster
Yay NFL is back!  
#30 | 1043 days ago

foster...cuz he's not in our division


Yzerman or Lidstrom
I miss NHL  
#31 | 1043 days ago

not a hockey fan.................YZERMAN......lol


GREG MADDUX vs NOLAN RYAN
#32 | 1043 days ago

I refuse to answer until you stop yelling at me.
#33 | 1043 days ago

Nolan Ryan


Mario Lemieux...or...Claude Lemieux
I miss NHL  
#34 | 1043 days ago

HULL_17 wrote:
Nolan Ryan


Mario Lemieux...or...Claude Lemieux
Claude Lemieux...why not?


Pistol Pete Maravich vs Larry Bird (I don't even like the Celtics)
MLB is coming to a close :(  
#35 | 1043 days ago

davonthedl wrote:
Claude Lemieux...why not?


Pistol Pete Maravich vs Larry Bird (I don't even like the Celtics)

Oh wow..uhhh...Larry Bird.




T.O vs. Ocho Cinco


(are wrestlers athletes)

Yay NFL is back!  
#36 | 1043 days ago
Nick__ (+)

kobe_lova wrote:

Oh wow..uhhh...Larry Bird.




T.O vs. Ocho Cinco


(are wrestlers athletes)

FO#K both of them!   -  OCHOSTINKO


DOMINEK HASEK or MARTIN BRODEUR
I miss NHL  
#37 | 1043 days ago

HASEK.............................

STONE COLD STEVE AUSTIN v s THE ROCK....................
#38 | 1043 days ago

the rock




Randy Orton...or...Edge
I miss NHL  
#39 | 1043 days ago
Nick__ (+)

HULL_17 wrote:
the rock




Randy Orton...or...Edge
ORTON


TORRIE WILSON    or TRISH STRATUS 

       

I miss NHL  
#40 | 1043 days ago

BOTH...........ooooooooooh yessssssssss....way to go NICK..........

EMMITT SMITH vs BARRY SANDERS
#41 | 1043 days ago

Emmitt

 

Wayne Gretzsky VS. Michael Jordan

Yay NFL is back!  
#42 | 1043 days ago

hmmmmmmmm........2 different sports...................JORDAN


JOE MONTANA  vs  BRETTY FAVRE
#43 | 1043 days ago

Jeff_P wrote:
hmmmmmmmm........2 different sports...................JORDAN


JOE MONTANA  vs  BRETTY FAVRE
Montana

Mike Schmidt vs Rickey Henderson
Yay NFL is back!  
#44 | 1043 days ago

2 different players.....styles.......give me SCHMIDT

JACK NICKLAUS vs TIGER
#45 | 1042 days ago

 Tiger




Serena Williams vs Lisa Leslie
Yay NFL is back!  
#46 | 1042 days ago

kobe_lova wrote:
 Tiger




Serena Williams vs Lisa Leslie
Lisa Leslie

Pele vs David Beckham
Yay NFL is back!  
#47 | 1042 days ago

PELE.......he WASNT so into HIMSELF


CAL RIPKEN JR  vs  DEREK JETER
#48 | 1042 days ago

Ripken (as an O's fan, this is the required answer)

Justin Verlander vs. Roy Halladay
#49 | 1042 days ago

HALLADAY.........more seasons......more proven

HANK AARON vs ALBERT PUJOLS.........
#50 | 1042 days ago

Hank Aaron




Wayne Rooney...or...David Beckham
I miss NHL  
#51 | 1042 days ago

HULL_17 wrote:
Hank Aaron




Wayne Rooney...or...David Beckham
 Wayne Rooney


Steven Stamkos vs. Drew Doughty 
I miss NHL  
#52 | 1042 days ago

kteacher wrote:
 Wayne Rooney


Steven Stamkos vs. Drew Doughty 
Who?
#53 | 1042 days ago

(Edited by kteacher)
Jason_ wrote:
Who?
 I don't like you, but I'll play. 

 this dude who plays for Tampa Bay and scored 50+ goals last year and is only 21 vs. THIS former fav (possible return to fav status when his young slightly chubeque self signs with the Kings and stops being a money hungry hold out.....I may be a little upset)  Kings player, same age, two years removed from Best D-man status with a total drop off year last year, and got totally pucked by young Sharks dude in the playoffs last year...........Oh and he wants more than 6.8 million a year. 



Oh....and the year they were drafted (2008) they went 1 and 2 with Stamkos being the first pick, and Stamkos already signed HIS contract. 
I miss NHL  
#54 | 1042 days ago

YOU DONT LIKE ME?
#55 | 1042 days ago

Jason_ wrote:
YOU DONT LIKE ME?
 That just came out of my fingers. ........Kind of an endearment. 


I miss NHL  
#56 | 1042 days ago

kteacher wrote:
 That just came out of my fingers. ........Kind of an endearment. 


It was hurtful.
#57 | 1042 days ago

Jason_ wrote:
It was hurtful.
Sorry. Fingers get twitchy sometimes. 

  



Better?
I miss NHL  
#58 | 1042 days ago

kteacher wrote:
Sorry. Fingers get twitchy sometimes. 

  



Better?
Much...
I want to put on that hoodie and eat the sh** out of those cookies so bad.  I could be the 5th turtle...Fata$$atello.
#59 | 1042 days ago

Jason_ wrote:
Much...
I want to put on that hoodie and eat the sh** out of those cookies so bad.  I could be the 5th turtle...Fata$$atello.
 
I miss NHL  
#60 | 1042 days ago

Stamkos





Dasyuk...or...Ovechkin
I miss NHL  
#61 | 1042 days ago

HULL_17 wrote:
Stamkos





Dasyuk...or...Ovechkin
Excuse me...we were talking here.
#62 | 1042 days ago
Nick__ (+)

HULL_17 wrote:
Stamkos





Dasyuk...or...Ovechkin
DATSYUK


GEORGE HALAS or VINCE LOMBARDI
I miss NHL  
#63 | 1042 days ago

Halas


Charles Woodson...or...Braylon Edwards (Michigan Time..Not Pros)
I miss NHL  
#64 | 1042 days ago

(Edited by Kenne)
HULL_17 wrote:
Halas


Charles Woodson...or...Braylon Edwards (Michigan Time..Not Pros)
Charles Woodson

Ryne Sandburg vs Mark Grace
Yay NFL is back!  
#65 | 1042 days ago
Nick__ (+)

SANDBERG



TOMMY LASORDA or EARL WAEAVER
I miss NHL  
#66 | 1042 days ago

Nick__ wrote:
SANDBERG



TOMMY LASORDA or EARL WAEAVER
Weaver, not even close

Aaron Rodgers or Drew Brees
#67 | 1040 days ago

Eric_ wrote:
Weaver, not even close

Aaron Rodgers or Drew Brees

Drew Brees



Bob Probert or Stu Grimson

Yay NFL is back!  
#68 | 1040 days ago

bob probert....(RIP)


The Grind Line...or...The Production Line
I miss NHL  
#69 | 1040 days ago

HULL_17 wrote:
bob probert....(RIP)


The Grind Line...or...The Production Line
Production Line.


Mays or Mantle
MLB is coming to a close :(  
#70 | 1040 days ago

ML31 wrote:
Production Line.


Mays or Mantle
Mantle

Jamarcus Russell vs Ryan Leaf
Yay NFL is back!  
#71 | 1040 days ago

umm Ryan Leaf....



The Toronto Maple Leafs...or...The San Jose Sharks (As A Team To Win The Cup...LMAO)
I miss NHL  
#72 | 1040 days ago

(Edited by ML31)
I thought theses were supposed to at least be somewhat debatable...

San Jose Sharks of course!

Jack Nicklaus  vs  Bobby Jones
MLB is coming to a close :(  
#73 | 1038 days ago

Bobby Jones.



Payne Stewart...or...Tiger Woods.
I miss NHL  
#74 | 1037 days ago

HULL_17 wrote:
Bobby Jones.



Payne Stewart...or...Tiger Woods.
Tiger Woods

Larry Fitzgerald vs Anquan Boldin
Yay NFL is back!  
#75 | 1037 days ago

Fitz...go pitt...



The Production Line...or...The French Connection
I miss NHL  
#76 | 1037 days ago

The French Connection  (Cooler name)


Zenendine Zidane  or Diego Maradona
MLB is coming to a close :(  
#77 | 1036 days ago

Maradona



Rooney...or...Ronaldo
I miss NHL  
#78 | 1036 days ago

HULL_17 wrote:
Maradona



Rooney...or...Ronaldo
N/A - Soccer isn't a sport. 
I miss NHL  
#79 | 1036 days ago

jswol54 wrote:
N/A - Soccer isn't a sport. 
just because you're not athletic and or man enough to play it doesn't mean it's not a sport.
I miss NHL  
#80 | 1036 days ago

HULL_17 wrote:
just because you're not athletic and or man enough to play it doesn't mean it's not a sport.
Yes it does.  And for the record, I'm plenty athletic.  I'm one hell of a poker player. 
I miss NHL  
#81 | 1036 days ago

jswol54 wrote:
Yes it does.  And for the record, I'm plenty athletic.  I'm one hell of a poker player. 
I Bet You Not...In Fact...I'd Put Money On It That Says I'd Beat You At Poker & Take All Your Money.
I miss NHL  
#82 | 1035 days ago

HULL_17 wrote:
Maradona



Rooney...or...Ronaldo
Ronaldo

John McEnroe vs Andre Agassi
Yay NFL is back!  
#83 | 1035 days ago

McEnroe




Agassi...or...Sampras

I miss NHL  

Post a Comment   Already a user? Sign in here
Join FanIQ - It's Free
FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.
Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,649,417+ Comments
Track your game picks - 38,670,182,382+ Sports Predictions
Prove you know sports - 116,275+ Trivia Questions
Find fans of your teams - 11,453,110+ New Friends
The Spring Games
Asked by rockysnappyduke | Locker Room, Games | 6 questions asked 08/07/13
78 opinions | 8 comments | Last by KSbengals99
Don't hate the game
Asked by rockysnappyduke | Locker Room, Games | 4 questions asked 04/16/13
104 opinions | 24 comments | Last by KSbengals99
Clue IQ
Asked by rockysnappyduke | Locker Room, Games | 6 questions asked 08/10/13
108 opinions | 7 comments | Last by KSbengals99
F/E 7/24
Asked by kobe_lova | Locker Room | 1 questions asked Yesterday
6 opinions | 22 comments | Last by woody050681
F/E 7/22
Asked by kobe_lova | Locker Room | 1 questions asked 07/22/14
5 opinions | 9 comments | Last by woody050681