| Correct Answer | 23 Fans | |
| | | 1. First Round - #16 DePaul vs. #9 UConn (4 points) |
| 0% | a. DePaul |
| Correct | 100% | b. UConn |
| | | 2. First Round - #13 Pittsburgh vs. #12 St. John's (4 points) |
| Correct | 57% | a. Pittsburgh |
| 43% | b. St. John's |
| | | 3. First Round - #15 Providence vs. #10 Seton Hall (4 points) |
| 4% | a. Providence |
| Correct | 96% | b. Seton Hall |
| | | 4. First Round - #14 Villanova vs. #11 Rutgers (4 points) |
| Correct | 74% | a. Villanova |
| 26% | b. Rutgers |
| | | 5. Second Round - DePaul/UConn winner vs. #8 West Virginia (6 points) |
| 43% | a. West Virginia |
| Correct | 52% | b. UConn |
| 4% | c. DePaul |
| | | 6. Second Round - Pittsburgh/St. John's winner vs. #5 Georgetown (6 points) |
| Correct | 100% | a. Georgetown |
| 0% | b. St. John's |
| 0% | c. Pittsburgh |
| | | 7. Second Round - Providence/Seton Hall winner vs. #7 Louisville (6 points) |
| Correct | 83% | a. Louisville |
| 17% | b. Seton Hall |
| 0% | c. Providence |
| | | 8. Second Round - Villanova/Rutgers winner vs. #6 South Florida (6 points) |
| Correct | 57% | a. South Florida |
| 4% | b. Rutgers |
| 39% | c. Villanova |
| | | 9. Quarterfinals - DePaul/UConn/West Virginia winner vs. #1 Syracuse (8 points) |
| Correct | 96% | a. Syracuse |
| 0% | b. West Virginia |
| 4% | c. UConn |
| 0% | d. DePaul |
| | | 10. Quarterfinals - Pittsburgh/St. John's/Georgetown winner vs. #4 Cincinnati (8 points) |
| Correct | 30% | a. Cincinnati |
| 70% | b. Georgetown |
| 0% | c. St. John's |
| 0% | d. Pittsburgh |
| | | 11. Quarterfinals - Providence/Seton Hall/Louisville winner vs. #2 Marquette (8 points) |
| 78% | a. Marquette |
| Correct | 17% | b. Louisville |
| 4% | c. Seton Hall |
| 0% | d. Providence |
| | | 12. Quarterfinals - Villanova/Rutgers/South Florida winner vs. #3 Notre Dame (8 points) |
| Correct | 87% | a. Notre Dame |
| 0% | b. South Florida |
| 4% | c. Rutgers |
| 9% | d. Villanova |
| | | 13. Semifinals - DePaul/UConn/West Virginia/Syracuse winner vs. Pittsburgh/St. John's/Georgetown/Cincinnati winner (9 points) |
| 91% | a. Syracuse |
| Correct | 4% | b. Cincinnati |
| 4% | c. Georgetown |
| 0% | d. West Virginia |
| 0% | e. UConn |
| 0% | f. St. John's |
| 0% | g. Pittsburgh |
| 0% | h. DePaul |
| | | 14. Semifinals - Providence/Seton Hall/Louisville/Marquette winner vs. Villanova/Rutgers/South Florida/Notre Dame winner (9 points) |
| 70% | a. Marquette |
| 13% | b. Notre Dame |
| 0% | c. South Florida |
| Correct | 13% | d. Louisville |
| 0% | e. Seton Hall |
| 4% | f. Rutgers |
| 0% | g. Villanova |
| 0% | h. Providence |
| | | 15. Championship - Which team will win the 2012 Big East Conference Tournament (10 points) |
| 78% | a. Syracuse |
| 17% | b. Marquette |
| 0% | c. Notre Dame |
| 4% | d. Cincinnati |
| 0% | e. Georgetown or Pittsburgh or St. John's |
| 0% | f. South Florida or Rutgers or Villanova |
| Correct | 0% | g. Louisville or Seton Hall or Providence |
| 0% | h. West Virginia or UConn or DePaul |
| | | Tiebreaker: Combined points in championship game? |
| Correct | | 94 |
.png "2012 Big East Tournament Challenge Photo")
