| Correct Answer | 11 Fans | |
| | | 1. J. Garcia (STL) will face 25.5 hitters (10 points) |
| 45% | a. Over |
| Correct | 55% | b. Under |
| | | 2. J. Cueto (CIN) will toss 6 and 1/3 innings (10 points) |
| 73% | a. Over |
| Correct | 27% | b. Under |
| | | 3. S. Strasburg (WAS) will have a combined 8.5 strikeouts + walks (10 points) |
| Correct | 73% | a. Over |
| 27% | b. Under |
| | | 4. J. Santana (NYM) will have a WHIP of 1.155 (10 points) |
| Correct | 27% | a. Over |
| 73% | b. Under |
| | | 5. R. Delgado (ATL) will walk 2.5 hitters (10 points) |
| Correct | 73% | a. Over |
| 27% | b. Under |
| | | 6. W. Rodriguez (HOU) will allow a combined 9.5 hits + runs (10 points) |
| Correct | 91% | a. Over |
| 9% | b. Under |
| | | 7. Y. Gallardo (MIL) will allow .5 homeruns (10 points) |
| 55% | a. Over |
| Correct | 45% | b. Under |
| | | 8. R. Dempster (CHC) will strikeout 5.5 hitters (10 points) |
| 91% | a. Over |
| Correct | 9% | b. Under |
| | | 9. J. Saunders (ARI) will toss 5 and 2/3 innings (10 points) |
| Correct | 91% | a. Over |
| 9% | b. Under |
| | | 10. C. Luebke (SD) will face 24.5 hitters (10 points) |
| Correct | 27% | a. Over |
| 73% | b. Under |
| | | 11. J. Johnson (FLA) will have a combined 7.5 strikeouts + walks (10 points) |
| 64% | a. Over |
| Correct | 36% | b. Under |
| | | 12. R. Halladay (PHI) will have an ERA of 1.995 after the game (10 points) |
| 9% | a. Over |
| Correct | 91% | b. Under |
| | | 13. T. Lincecum (SF) will allow 7.5 hits (10 points) |
| Correct | 18% | a. Over |
| 82% | b. Under |
| | | 14. J. Guthrie (COL) will throw 97.5 pitches (10 points) |
| 45% | a. Over |
| Correct | 55% | b. Under |
| | | 15. E. Bedard (PIT) will throw 63.5% of his pitches as strikes (10 points) |
| Correct | 55% | a. Over |
| 45% | b. Under |
| | | 16. C. Billingsley (LAD) will have a WHIP of 1.155 (10 points) |
| 45% | a. Over |
| Correct | 55% | b. Under |
| | | Tiebreaker: How many HITS ALLOWED by all 16 pitchers in this poll? |
| Correct | | 112 |