Skip to Next Poll »
9
Worst Super Bowl Quarterback Matchups Ever
What were the worst overall matchups of Quarterbacks ever in a Super Bowl?, based on career, not just the game.

Worst Super Bowl Quarterback Matchups Ever Photo
| Closed on 04/20/13 at 05:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | NFL | Opinion List
Teams:  Super Bowl
Tagged as:   Quarterbacks
Team Breakout:
Rank13 FansAvg (1st)
1.37 Brad Johnson (TB) - Rich Gannon (Oak)5.4 (3)
2.20 Jim McMahon (Chi) - Tony Eason (NE)4.9 (2)
3.35 Trent Dilfer (Balt) - Kerry Collins (NYG)4.6 (3)
4.17 Joe Theismann (Was) - David Woodley (Mia)3.5
5.4 Len Dawson (KC) - Joe Kapp (Min)3.3 (1)
6.26 Mark Rypien (Was) - Jim Kelly (Buf)2.9 (1)
7.7 Bob Griese (Mia) - Billy Kilmer (Was)2.7
8.25 Jeff Hostetler (NYG) - Jim Kelly (Buf)2.3
Also receiving votes:15 Jim Plunkett (Oak) - Ron Jaworski (Phi)2.2 (2)
47 Colin Kaepernick (SF) - Joe Flacco (Balt)1.5
40 Ben Roethlisberger (Pit) - Matt Hasselbeck (Sea1.1
18 Jim Plunkett (Oak) - Joe Theismann (Was)0.9 (1)
14 Terry Bradshaw (Pit) - Vince Ferragamo (LARams)0.5
# _________ - ___________0.2
# _________ - ___________0.1

  
2 Comments | Sorted by Most Recent First | Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 | 450 days ago

The reason for this poll, I was thinking this current matchup is the worst in quite a while, so I wanted to see how it ranks amongst the worst ever.
1. 35 Trent Dilfer (Balt) - Kerry Collins (NYG)  2. 20 Jim McMahon (Chi) - Tony Eason (NE)  3. 37 Brad Johnson (TB) - Rich Gannon (Oak)  4. 47 Colin Kaepernick (SF) - Joe Flacco (Balt)  5. 17 Joe Theismann (Was) - David Woodley (Mia)  6. 4 Len Dawson (KC) - Joe Kapp (Min)  7. 7 Bob Griese (Mia) - Billy Kilmer (Was)  8. 40 Ben Roethlisberger (Pit) - Matt Hasselbeck (Sea  
#2 | 449 days ago

(Edited by kobe_lova)
Bad qb matchups usually make funny football games.
1. 20 Jim McMahon (Chi) - Tony Eason (NE)  2. 26 Mark Rypien (Was) - Jim Kelly (Buf)  3. 7 Bob Griese (Mia) - Billy Kilmer (Was)  4. 4 Len Dawson (KC) - Joe Kapp (Min)  5. 35 Trent Dilfer (Balt) - Kerry Collins (NYG)  6. 37 Brad Johnson (TB) - Rich Gannon (Oak)  7. 15 Jim Plunkett (Oak) - Ron Jaworski (Phi)  8. 47 Colin Kaepernick (SF) - Joe Flacco (Balt)  

Post a Comment   Already a user? Sign in here
Join FanIQ - It's Free
FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.
Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,649,417+ Comments
Track your game picks - 38,670,182,382+ Sports Predictions
Prove you know sports - 116,275+ Trivia Questions
Find fans of your teams - 11,453,110+ New Friends
If you had to start an NFL franchise and had your pick of any running back, rank your top 5 Choices.
Asked by jdoug | NFL | 5 questions asked 09/26/12
180 opinions | 6 comments | Last by abac89
In The 2000 Super Bowl (Titans vs Rams) Did The Titans Receiver ACTUALLY Cross the goalline?
Asked by collinbentley11 | NFL, TEN, STL | 1 questions asked 07/17/12
34 opinions | 9 comments | Last by abac89
Who's the better running back?
Asked by collinbentley11 | NFL, MIN, TEN | 1 questions asked 08/09/13
24 opinions | 1 comment | Last by Psyduckisboss
Do you think a quarterback under 6'2" can survive in the NFL?
Asked by chevleclair | NFL | 1 questions asked 07/05/12
26 opinions | 9 comments | Last by NYMets7ss
Who is your #1 Arizona Cardinal QB of all time?
Asked by ChicagoMonkey28 | NFL | 5 questions asked 06/30/10
285 opinions | 14 comments | Last by NYMets7ss