Skip to Next Poll »
10
Who Was the Best Ever?
In this poll I want you to tell me who the best baseball players of all-time are. You will put the position first and then the players name.

Example:

RF David Justice


We are using the American League rules with a DH, but don't forget to add the best pitcher of all time in your line-up.
| Closed on 05/31/13 at 05:00PM
FanIQ Pts? No | Locker Room, FanIQ | Multiple Choice Opinion Poll
8 Fans 
63%a. These
38%b. Those

 &nbp;
TOP COMMENT * * * * * * * * * * * *
#1 | 446 days ago

(Edited by cubsgirl)
Ok, here's my great team. 

Pitcher -  Nolan Ryan

Catcher -  Johnny Bench

1st. base -  Ernie Banks

2nd base -  Ryne Sandberg

S.S. Ernie Banks.  (yes I know)

3rd base - Mike Schmidt

Left field - Stan Musial

Center - Willie Mays

Right field - Andre Dawson..


Great poll John.  smiley

These  
  
23 Comments | Sorted by Most Recent First | Red = You Disagreed
Vote for your favorite comments. Fans decide the Top Comment (3+ votes) and also hide poor quality comments (4+ votes).
#1 | 446 days ago

(Edited by cubsgirl)
Ok, here's my great team. 

Pitcher -  Nolan Ryan

Catcher -  Johnny Bench

1st. base -  Ernie Banks

2nd base -  Ryne Sandberg

S.S. Ernie Banks.  (yes I know)

3rd base - Mike Schmidt

Left field - Stan Musial

Center - Willie Mays

Right field - Andre Dawson..


Great poll John.  smiley

These  
#2 | 446 days ago

cubsgirl wrote:
Ok, here's my great team. 

Pitcher -  Nolan Ryan

Catcher -  Johnny Bench

1st. base -  Ernie Banks

2nd base -  Ryne Sandberg

S.S. Ernie Banks.  (yes I know)

3rd base - Mike Schmidt

Left field - Stan Musial

Center - Willie Mays

Right field - Andre Dawson..


Great poll John.  smiley

Thanks Glenda, but since when did you start calling me Bryan? 
#3 | 446 days ago

(Edited by cubsgirl)
Lol, I changed it as soon as I did it. I'm sorry, I have no idea what I was thinking. 






And, I have to tell you, I went back and forth between Ernie Banks and Jackie Robinson at first base, then Ryne Sandberg and Jackie   

Robinson at 2nd base. Hard choices. 
These  
#4 | 446 days ago

basically this is an All Time Fantasy League Roster?

C - Yogi Berra
1B - Albert Pujols
2B - Jackie Robinson
3B - Mike Schmidt
SS - Cal Ripkin Jr (I can't bring myself to vote for either of those Yanks)
LF - Barry Bonds
CF - Joe DiMaggio
RF - Hank Aaron (Babe a close 2nd)
DH - Frank Thomas

LHP - Randy Johnson
RHP - Nolan Ryan
RP - Dennis Eckersly

Manager - Tony La Russa
#5 | 446 days ago

cubsgirl wrote:
Ok, here's my great team. 

Pitcher -  Nolan Ryan

Catcher -  Johnny Bench

1st. base -  Ernie Banks

2nd base -  Ryne Sandberg

S.S. Ernie Banks.  (yes I know)

3rd base - Mike Schmidt

Left field - Stan Musial

Center - Willie Mays

Right field - Andre Dawson..


Great poll John.  smiley

I want to face this team, since they only have 8 players for a game that uses 9. Silly Cubs fans!
Those  
#6 | 445 days ago

(Edited by rkonkol78)
All Time Best Line Up

C    Johnny Bench
1B  Lou Gehrig
2B  Rogers Hornsby
3B  Mike Schmidt
SS  Honus Wagner
LF  Ted Williams
CF  Willie Mays
RF  Hank Aaron
DH  Paul Molitor
P     Walter Johnson
#7 | 445 days ago

c       Johnny Bench
1b    Lou Gehrig
2b    Jackie Robinson
3b    Mike Schmidt
ss    Honus Wagner
LF    Ted Williams
CF    Willie Mays
RF    Babe Ruth

RHP    Walter Johnson
LHP     Lefty Grove
These  
#8 | 445 days ago

C- Elston Howard
1B - Don Mattingly
2B - Willie Randolph
3B- Greg Nettles
SS- Derek Jeter
LF- Paul O'Neill
CF- Mickey Mantle
RF- Reggie Jackson
RHP- Catfish Hunteri
LHP- Lefty Gomez or Ron Guidry
RP- Maraiano Rivera

And those are the NY YANKEES!!!!!
#9 | 445 days ago

(Edited by davonthedl)
C - Yogi Berra
1B - Lou Gehrig
2B - Jackie Robinson
3B - Brooks Robinson
SS - Ozzie Smith
LF - Ted Williams
CF - Willie Mays
RF - Henry Louis "Hank" Aaron
RHP - Nolan Ryan
LHP - Sandy Koufax
DH - Paul Molitor

Just my opinion! Very tough, good poll!

I forgot to add ...
Chico Escuela from the Mets

These  
#10 | 445 days ago
Nick__ (+)

C - Johnny Bench
1B - Lou Gehrig
2B - Jackie Robinson
SS - Cal Ripken Jr
3B - Mike Schmidt
LF - Ted Williams
CF - Willie Mays
RF - Babe Ruth
DH - Frank Thomas
LP - Sandy Koufax
RP - Cy Young

In my birth life, these are top ones

C - Johnny Bench
1B - Eddie Murray but I think Albert Pujols will end up having a better career in the end
2B - Ryne Sandberg
SS - Cal Ripken Jr
3B -  Mike Schmidt
LF -  Carl "Yaz" Yastrzemski
CF - Ken Griffey Jr
RF -  Hank Aaron
DH - Frank Thomas
LP - Randy Johnson
RP - Nolan Ryan
Those  
#11 | 445 days ago

cubsgirl wrote:
Lol, I changed it as soon as I did it. I'm sorry, I have no idea what I was thinking. 






And, I have to tell you, I went back and forth between Ernie Banks and Jackie Robinson at first base, then Ryne Sandberg and Jackie   

Robinson at 2nd base. Hard choices. 
I stii have a hard time watching Ryan Sandburg in a Phillies uniform.
Those  
#12 | 445 days ago

huskerdoug2009 wrote:
I stii have a hard time watching Ryan Sandburg in a Phillies uniform.
That's where he started out....

P-RHP-Tom Seaver
    LHP-Sandy Koufax
C- Yogi Berra
1B-Lou Gehrig
2B-Jackie Robinson
SS-Ernie Banks
3B-Brooks Robinson or Graig Nettles
LF-Jim Rice
CF-Mickey Mantle
RF- Babe Ruth
DH-Edgar Martinez
RP-Mariano Rivera
These  
#13 | 445 days ago

like Nick did, I'm going in my lifetime that I remember watching or seeing in person:

C - Johnny Bench
1B - Eddie Murray
2B - Sandberg
3B - Schmidt
SS - Cal
LF - Tim Raines (homer pick over Rickey & Bonds, don't judge me)
CF - Junior
RF - Vlady (homer pick numero deux)
DH - Molitor (Baines was close. I went back and forth a bit)

RP - Maddux
LP - Steve Carlton
R - Mariano
These  
#14 | 445 days ago

(Edited by ML31)
Really rough...

P  Cy Young
C  Johnny Bench
1B  Lou Gherig
2B  Rogers Hornsby
3B  Mike Schmidt
SS  Honus Wagner
LF  Barry Bonds
CF Ty Cobb
RF Babe Ruth
DH  Ted Williams
#15 | 445 days ago

And just for fun...

Here is my all time Giants line up...

P  Christy Mathewson
C  Harry Danning  (Could be Posey if he keeps playing well.. )
1B  Bill Terry
2B  Jeff Kent
SS  Travis Jackson
3B  Matt Williams
LF  Barry Bonds
CF  Willie Mays
RF  Mel Ott



Manager:  John McGraw
#16 | 445 days ago

I can't believe Barry Bonds isn't in more of these line-ups. Steroids or not he was one of the best. Mix in the juice and you can't even pitch to the guy.
#17 | 445 days ago

Tiger_Pride2 wrote:
I can't believe Barry Bonds isn't in more of these line-ups. Steroids or not he was one of the best. Mix in the juice and you can't even pitch to the guy.
He's clearly the choice, but I'm on a Raines HOF truther mission. Also, he's a pr!ck. So there's that. Rickey needs love too.
These  
#18 | 445 days ago

Tiger_Pride2 wrote:
I can't believe Barry Bonds isn't in more of these line-ups. Steroids or not he was one of the best. Mix in the juice and you can't even pitch to the guy.
Nope, won't give him the time of day. As far as i'm concerned if you did it on juice it doesn't count. 
These  
#19 | 445 days ago

huskerdoug2009 wrote:
I stii have a hard time watching Ryan Sandburg in a Phillies uniform.
meeeee too. 
These  
#20 | 444 days ago
Nick__ (+)

Tiger_Pride2 wrote:
I can't believe Barry Bonds isn't in more of these line-ups. Steroids or not he was one of the best. Mix in the juice and you can't even pitch to the guy.
F**K BONDS!

And HANK AARON is still the all-time HR leader in my book!
Those  
#21 | 444 days ago

marcus_nyce wrote:
He's clearly the choice, but I'm on a Raines HOF truther mission. Also, he's a pr!ck. So there's that. Rickey needs love too.
So I guess your team was more like the all nice guy team?

That explains the absence of Bonds, Ruth, Cobb, among many others.

You know what Leo said about nice guys?

wink
#22 | 444 days ago

Nick__ wrote:
F**K BONDS!

And HANK AARON is still the all-time HR leader in my book!
And in my book, teams who win the World Series using the wild card don't count.   F**K the wild card.
#23 | 444 days ago

ML31 wrote:
So I guess your team was more like the all nice guy team?

That explains the absence of Bonds, Ruth, Cobb, among many others.

You know what Leo said about nice guys?

wink
True. I also only included guys from my time that I had seen play on TV, etc.
These  

Post a Comment   Already a user? Sign in here
Join FanIQ - It's Free
FanIQ is the ultimate free community for sports fans.
Talk sports with fans from all over - 1,649,417+ Comments
Track your game picks - 38,670,182,382+ Sports Predictions
Prove you know sports - 116,275+ Trivia Questions
Find fans of your teams - 11,453,110+ New Friends
Awards Night at the Q
Asked by rockysnappyduke | Locker Room, FanIQ | 6 questions asked 05/09/13
168 opinions | 15 comments | Last by KSbengals99
Should Faniq make A MOBILE APP for this site and IF SO would you use it ?
Asked by irmacourt | Locker Room, FanIQ | 1 questions asked 04/19/12
40 opinions | 28 comments | Last by KSbengals99
Favorite Teams?
Asked by OneStepBeyond | Locker Room, FanIQ | 1 questions asked 02/12/13
21 opinions | 25 comments | Last by KSbengals99
HOF or Not?
Asked by Tiger_Pride2 | Locker Room, FanIQ | 1 questions asked 02/07/13
16 opinions | 18 comments | Last by KSbengals99
Happy Birthday to a Best Coaster Teachest aka Becky!
Asked by Beaneaters | Locker Room | 1 questions asked Today
0 opinions | Last by -